Brian Schottenheimer’s Cowboys keep stepping on the same rake, and the penalties are becoming impossible to ignore.
This isn’t just a one-game issue or a bad stretch. Dallas has been living with this problem for years.
From 2020 to 2024 under Mike McCarthy, the Cowboys piled up 570 penalties, the most in the NFL. That conversation never really went away, and it has carried right into the Brian Schottenheimer era.
Not every heavily penalized team is a bad team. The Houston Texans are second with 195 penalties since 2025, and the Denver Broncos are tied for third with 193, and their combined record is 36-16. Dallas, though, keeps drawing the kind of flags that feel familiar in the worst way - the ones that wreck drives, extend opponents’ possessions, and expose a team that looks out of sync at the worst moments.
The damage has shown up most clearly on defense. Holding and pass interference calls on third-and-long have repeatedly kept opposing offenses alive, and the Cowboys are tied with the Green Bay Packers for the NFL lead in automatic first downs given via penalty on third down with nine. Dallas also leads the league with 22 penalties that have resulted in an automatic first down for opponents.
Two moments stand out as especially costly. Against the Indianapolis Colts, DeMarvion Overshown ran onto the field as an inactive player. Dallas was still ahead 20-17, but the 15-yard penalty flipped the field position, the offense ended up punting, and Indy tied the game on the next possession.
Then came the late-game taunting penalty on George Pickens against the San Francisco 49ers. Dallas was trying to move fast and preserve clock, but the flag pushed the offense back from the 49ers’ 19-yard line to the 28. It took six more plays and burned 42 seconds.
There are plenty of reasons the Cowboys are sitting at 4-6. Penalties aren’t the only thing keeping them on the outside of the playoff picture as it starts to take shape. But they are a loud indicator of a team that keeps beating itself, and that’s starting to define the culture Schottenheimer is trying to build in Dallas.
In Other News...
Cowboys Power Ranking Jump Ignores One Problem Fans Can't Unsee
The Cowboys have been easy to read in one respect this season: when the offense is rolling, it can look like one of the leagues most dangerous units. Dak Prescott has helped drive that reputation with a sharp passing attack, and the latest performance only reinforced how explosive this side of the roster can be when everything is clicking.
But the bigger picture is harder to ignore, even as the team climbs in power rankings. Dallas keeps showing the same split personality, with one side carrying the load while the other leaves too much to clean up. Analysts have pointed to the defense as the glaring concern, and until that part of the roster steadies itself, the Cowboys will keep living with the same uncomfortable question about how far this version of the team can really go. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Make Telling Christian Parker Change After 49ers Collapse
The Cowboys are making a notable adjustment on defense after another rough outing, shifting the burden of game-day play-calling away from Christian Parker in the wake of the loss to the 49ers. Parker is staying on staff, but the move underscores how seriously Dallas is treating the recent slide on that side of the ball and how much pressure has built around the units performance.
Mike Pettine, the senior defensive assistant, is stepping into the game-day role as the Cowboys look for a steadier voice and cleaner operation on Sundays. Parker will remain with the team for the rest of the season, but this is still a significant change for a defense trying to stop the bleeding and regain some confidence before the year moves any further along. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Defense Just Put Christian Parker Under Even More Pressure
After 10 weeks, the Cowboys have made a notable shift on defense, moving the play-calling responsibilities away from defensive coordinator Christian Parker and handing them to senior assistant coach Mike Pettine. The change comes on the heels of a string of uneven defensive outings, including the kind of performance against the San Francisco 49ers that tends to force a team to rethink who is steering things on that side of the ball.
Parker is still with the team, but in an undefined defensive role, which leaves some intrigue about how much influence he will continue to have as the Cowboys try to steady that unit. For now, the message is clear enough: Dallas is looking for a different voice in the headset, even if the broader picture on Parkers future with the staff is still taking shape. [Read more 🡒]
