The Cowboys’ defense has gotten so bad that the group has already gone behind closed doors for a players-only meeting, a blunt sign of how far things have gone in Dallas.
DeMarvion Overshown said on Monday that the defense gathered to look inward and spell out exactly what needs to change. Overshown described the conversation this way, per Tommy Yarrish:
"Looking ourselves in the mirror. "Putting what we wanted our standard to be, we put that on the board.
We went by bullet point, bullet point. Are we holding up to this?
Are we being this? As a unit, how can we get closer?
What is it? Just hearing from all of us.
It really wasn't like a fire drill conversation, it was more so, 'What can I do to help you? What do I expect from you on Sundays, or every Monday walk throughs?'
We've got to talk to each other like that because the ship is only going to go as far as the weakest person on the boat. As long as we all in this together, I think we're going to be great.
I know we're going to be there."
That kind of meeting usually means a team is searching for answers, and Dallas is clearly there right now. The Cowboys entered this season with a new coordinator, new starters, and a defense that was supposed to look different after the departures of Kenneth Murray, Donovan Wilson, Trevon Diggs, and Kaiir Elam. Instead, the unit has hardly moved forward at all.
It’s a stunning place for this defense to be. A new scheme always comes with some growing pains, especially with a first-time play-caller, but this has gone way beyond that. The Cowboys still have what looks like the worst defense in football, and the situation has become desperate enough that the players are trying to reset it themselves.
There is at least one reason to spin it positively: the players are still looking for a fix. That wasn’t the feel of last year’s group, where Matt Eberflus never seemed to build much connection with his players and the trust in the scheme kept falling apart as the season went on.
Still, the timing matters. If a team is going to hit bottom, October is better than November or December, and Dallas still has 12 games left to salvage something.
The NFC is still sorting itself out, with the 49ers standing as the clear best team in football and the rest of the hierarchy still unsettled. Even in the NFC East, nine wins might be enough to get Dallas over the top.
But none of that helps if opposing quarterbacks keep posting huge numbers against this defense.
The offense can’t keep being asked to put up 28-plus points every week just to keep the Cowboys in the fight. That’s not a workable formula, and it leaves Dak Prescott with no room to breathe. He should be able to have an off day without it turning into a disaster.
That was exactly the problem against the 0-4 Buccaneers, when Dallas’ offense didn’t really get going until the fourth quarter. Tampa Bay would have been up by 21 points in the second half if it had converted a 4th-and-goal from the one-yard line.
A good defense gives its quarterback a cushion. Dallas doesn’t have that right now, and it shows in every possession.
Empty drives feel heavier. Turnovers feel like wreckage.
The defense almost never seems likely to answer with a stop.
The Buccaneers’ 15-play touchdown drive, which burned the rest of the first quarter, was a perfect example. Prescott opened the game with a touchdown drive, and then the defense responded by letting Tampa Bay march 11 minutes for its own score.
At some point, this group has to win Dallas a game. That can come through a timely takeaway, a goal-line stand, or just one complete performance from start to finish. Right now, the defense isn’t just struggling - it’s putting constant pressure on the offense to be nearly perfect.
Maybe the players-only meeting becomes the turning point. Maybe hearing the message from one another lands differently than hearing it from coaches.
But that’s the problem with meetings like this: eventually, the talking has to turn into results. Dallas can only reset and hold each other accountable so many times before the performance has to change.
For now, things are bleak.
In Other News...
Jerry Jones Just Added More Fuel To Cowboys Packers Tension
Jerry Jones opened an old wound in the Cowboys-Packers rivalry by revisiting one of his stranger memories from roughly 25 years ago, when a Packers fan reacted to a Dallas win by pressing her bare backside against his car window while his grandchildren were inside. Jones said the moment stuck with him, and he even described the cold as part of the reason the fans skin left a print on the glass. It was the kind of story only Jones could tell with a straight face, and it landed with the same mix of humor and needle that has long surrounded these two franchises.
The timing made it even more pointed, with the Cowboys and Packers already linked by recent roster business, including the trade of Micah Parsons to Green Bay. For Dallas fans, the rivalry has never needed much help finding extra edge, but Jones managed to add another layer just by digging up a bizarre episode from the past. Between the old memory and the present-day connection, the Cowboys- Packers thread feels as active as ever. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys First-Round Miss Looks Even Worse After Mazi Smith Setback
Mazi Smiths rocky NFL path has taken another turn, and it only adds to the regret around Dallas 2023 first-round gamble. Drafted to help shore up a run defense that needed immediate reinforcement, Smith never found a steady footing with the Cowboys, and his departure has only underlined how little impact the pick ultimately produced.
His latest stop ended quickly, too. Smith was released by the Miami Dolphins after time on their practice squad and a single game appearance, leaving him with four NFL games across three teams since leaving Dallas and still no tackle to show for it. For the Cowboys, it is another reminder of how a top investment in the trenches has yet to pay off. [Read more 🡒]
Jerry Jones Is Feeling Heat Over One Cowboys Trade Decision
The Cowboys uneven start on defense has only sharpened the attention on one of Jerry Jones biggest personnel calls of the year. Through the first five weeks, Dallas has had trouble settling in on that side of the ball, and the trade that sent linebacker Micah Parsons to the Green Bay Packers is looking more consequential by the week.
Parsons is injured right now, which has taken some of the immediate heat out of the discussion, but the topic has hardly gone away. A recent report suggested Jones has regrets about making the deal, and that conversation figures to get louder once Parsons is back on the field and the Cowboys are still being judged against what they gave up. [Read more 🡒]