Field Yates sees Caleb Downs as the kind of rookie who can walk into Dallas and change the temperature of the whole defense.
On ESPN, the college football analyst pointed to Downs as one of five rookies he likes most heading into the 2026 NFL season, and he was especially bullish on what the safety could mean for the Cowboys.
“And then last but not least, Caleb Downs. Now, there were some really good, thoughtful conversations just prior to the draft about the value of a safety and whether Caleb Downs had the goods to be a premier NFL safety in the category of guys like Ed Reed or Sean Taylor and some of the guys that have been remembered amongst the very best in the past 20 years,” Yates said.
For Yates, the appeal starts with the way Downs plays. He called him a “tone setter” and said that kind of presence is unusual at safety. Yates also emphasized Downs’ physicality and versatility, while noting that he could have offered even more value if the Cowboys chose to use him on special teams.
“Here's what I do know about Caleb Downs. He's a tone setter.
.@FieldYates ranks his top-5 NFL rookies 👀 pic.twitter.com/2fo8km8WWN
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) September 1, 2026
It's rare for a tone setter to be your safety on defense as well. Incredibly physical, has good versatility.
I don't think the Cowboys will tap into this, but you may remember from Caleb Downs' one year at Alabama, he could be a premier punt returner as well. More added value for a guy that slid all the way down to pick number 11.
To me, he was a top-six prospect in the draft, but because he plays safety, he slid just outside the top ten.”
Downs has long been viewed as one of the best players in the 2026 NFL Draft regardless of position, and Dallas could be getting an immediate chess piece in Christian Parker’s defense. The fit draws a parallel to Cooper DeJean in the Vic Fangio system, a role that could let Downs impact the game in multiple ways.
If that happens, the Cowboys’ defense could move quickly from a weakness to something far more dangerous. Put that together with Brian Schottenheimer’s offense, and Dallas suddenly has the kind of roster balance that can look awfully intimidating.
In Other News...
Cowboys May Have Found A Back Kansas City Let Slip Away
The Cowboys added a familiar name to their backfield by claiming running back Emari Demercado off waivers after Kansas City let him go. It is the kind of move that can fly under the radar, but it comes with a little more intrigue than most because Chiefs coach Andy Reid had praised Demercado, and some around the league believed his skill set could have fit well in Kansas Citys offense.
For Dallas, the appeal is obvious. Demercado is expected to step into a meaningful rotational role, giving the Cowboys a back who is known for pass protection and an efficient running style. In a backfield that always needs reliable pieces, the question now is not whether he has traits worth keeping, but how quickly he can carve out real snaps and prove Kansas City may have moved on a little too soon. [Read more 🡒]
Jason Witten Is Already Earning Serious Respect In His New Role
Jason Witten is back on the sideline in a different capacity, and the early word out of Oklahoma suggests the former Cowboys great has slipped into coaching with the same steady presence he showed as a player. The 11-time Pro Bowl tight end was hired as the Sooners tight ends coach, and his first game in the role comes when Oklahoma hosts UTEP. For Cowboys fans still accustomed to seeing Witten as one of the most reliable figures in franchise history, it is a notable next step in a football life that already seemed destined to stay close to the game.
Inside Oklahoma, Witten is already drawing praise from offensive coordinator Ben Arbuckle and head coach Brent Venables, who have both noticed how quickly he has made himself useful. He has also been actively mentoring quarterback John Mateer, a sign that his value may extend beyond the tight end room as he settles into coaching. It is still early, but Wittens arrival has clearly made an impression, and the Sooners appear to be embracing the kind of knowledge and credibility he carried for years in Dallas. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Finally Sent A Message Fans Have Been Waiting For
The Cowboys moved quickly after trimming down to their initial 53-man roster, and the flurry of decisions gave fans a clearer picture of how the front office wants this team built. Dallas waived Joe Milton, claimed Emari Demarcado and also added Broderick Jones in a trade that sent out Nate Thomas, part of a busy stretch that underscored how aggressively the team has been trying to reshape the roster while still keeping an eye on future assets.
The Jones deal was especially notable because it included a draft-pick swap that stretches well beyond the immediate season, with Dallas getting Jones and a future fourth-rounder while giving up a future third and sixth that originally belonged to Pittsburgh. For a fan base that has spent plenty of time waiting for a stronger signal on how the Cowboys plan to balance present needs with draft capital, the latest moves offered one, even if the larger picture is still unfolding. [Read more 🡒]