Brian Schottenheimer has already won over plenty of people in Dallas, but he still hasn’t fully earned the kind of league-wide respect that comes with being viewed as one of the NFL’s premier play-callers. For the Cowboys, that gap comes down to one glaring issue: what happens when the field shrinks.
Schottenheimer’s first season as the Cowboys’ head coach brought enough production to change minds. Dallas finished 7-9-1 and missed the postseason, so there’s no pretending the year was perfect. But the offense still piled up big numbers, and that’s why many in and around the team believe Schottenheimer deserves more credit than he’s getting.
The problem is that the wider league doesn’t seem to see him in quite the same light. In a recent poll conducted by The Athletic’s Ted Nguyen, eight NFL defensive play-callers and assistant coaches were asked to rank the league’s best offensive minds.
Nguyen used their responses to build a top 10 and an honorable mention list, and Schottenheimer landed fourth among the honorable mentions. That puts him around No. 14 overall - solid, but not exactly elite.
That placement stands out when you look at what Dallas’ offense actually did. The Cowboys finished second in total yards, seventh in points scored and inside the top five in most major offensive categories. Even with that output, Schottenheimer still found himself behind other names in the rankings, including the Detroit Lions’ Drew Petzing, who was listed just ahead of him.
Dallas’ offensive production becomes even more impressive when you factor in the obstacles. The Cowboys got there without a fully healthy CeeDee Lamb, dealt with issues at left tackle and had no real answer for spelling Javonte Williams, who many thought was out of juice when he arrived at The Star.
Still, coaching in Dallas means every flaw gets magnified, and Schottenheimer’s biggest weak spot was hard to ignore. In 2025, the Cowboys scored more points than all but six NFL teams, yet they finished 16th in red zone scoring offense. They turned just 56.92% of their red-zone trips into touchdowns, a mark that lagged well behind the Tennessee Titans and sat 15% below the Philadelphia Eagles’ league-best rate.
That’s where the frustration comes in. There were times when Schottenheimer seemed to get too cute instead of leaning into the obvious answer: handing the ball to Williams and running behind Tyler Smith, Tyler Booker and Cooper Beebe.
With the field compressed, Dallas didn’t always need a trick play or a clever wrinkle. Sometimes it just needed to line up and move people.
That’s the hurdle in front of Schottenheimer now. If he can clean up the red-zone offense and keep the Cowboys simple and physical in scoring territory, he’ll do more than silence some of the disrespect. He’ll make Dallas better, too.
In Other News...
Cowboys Camp Is Already Sorting Out Whos Rising And Whos In Trouble
The Cowboys wrapped their first week of camp in Oxnard after three helmet-only practices, and the early pecking order already has some familiar names separating themselves. George Pickens has looked comfortable enough alongside Dak Prescott to stand out among the new faces, while DeMarvion Overshowns return has brought both health and a noticeable presence to the defense. Jaydon Blue also made an immediate impression with his burst in the backfield, giving Dallas a few bright spots as the team eases into the summer work.
Not every start was smooth, though, and that is where camp gets revealing for a roster still taking shape. Marquez Valdes-Scantling and Tyler Guyton were among the players who ran into some early difficulty during the sessions, which only adds to the sense that these next practices will matter for more than conditioning. With the first week down, the Cowboys are already learning which players look ready to rise and which ones will need a sharper response before the pads start bringing real answers. [Read more 🡒]
Why One Early Cowboys Defender Still Owns A Special Place In History
The Cowboys have had a long line of players cycle through number 27, but the standard for the jersey still goes back to the early days of the franchise. Safety Mike Gaechter, an undrafted free agent in 1962, carved out a career that made him the clear benchmark for the number, thanks in large part to the kind of playmaking that helped define Dallas in its formative years.
Gaechters most memorable moment came on a 100-yard interception return, a play that stood as the longest in team history for nearly half a century. Over eight seasons, he picked off 21 passes before an Achilles injury and a later trade brought his Cowboys run to an end, but his place in the clubs history remains secure whenever the conversation turns to the best to wear 27. [Read more 🡒]
Cowboys Still Have One Roster Concern Camp Hype Hasn't Answered
The first week of Cowboys training camp has offered enough to feed the optimism that always comes with July, especially with Dak Prescott and George Pickens turning heads early. There has been plenty to like in the building, but the early buzz has also come with the usual reminder that camp headlines can only tell you so much before the work gets harder and the pads come on.
A few of the biggest questions around this roster still need a real test, from the linebacker group to Shavon Revels development and the bigger-picture readiness of the offensive line and pass rush. Those evaluations should start to sharpen once practices intensify and live contact begins, which is when the Cowboys will find out whether the encouraging first impressions are the start of answers or just the opening act. [Read more 🡒]