NHL Offer Sheet Drama Just Raised The Stakes For Adam Fantilli

In a bold move cementing Leo Carlsson's future with the team, the Anaheim Ducks outmatched the Philadelphia Flyers' ambitious offer sheet, ensuring the star center's place as the NHL's top-paid player.

The Anaheim Ducks are keeping Leo Carlsson.

After the Philadelphia Flyers sent shock waves through the league with a five-year, $90 million offer sheet on July 3, the Ducks chose to match it Thursday and hold onto the 21-year-old center they’ve long treated as a cornerstone. The deal makes Carlsson the highest-paid player in the NHL, with an $18 million average annual value, topping Kirill Kaprizov’s $17 million per season with the Minnesota Wild.

“We are very happy to have Leo under contract for five years,” Ducks general manager Pat Verbeek said in a statement. “We have viewed Leo as a franchise player since the moment we met him prior to the 2023 draft.

He’s a character person on and off the ice. Leo is viewed as a top player in this league, and it was always our intention to match any offer sheet.”

Anaheim had a choice to make: match the deal or take Philadelphia’s next four first-round picks as compensation. The Ducks passed on the picks and paid to keep the player whose entry-level contract expired this summer.

“Matching the offer sheet was an easy decision, as Pat has intelligently left enough cap space to give us the ability to retain Leo,” Ducks owners Henry and Susan Samueli said in a statement. “We have extremely high expectations for Leo. We firmly believe he will continue his strong growth trajectory and become one of the truly elite centers in the league, while continuing to make a strong impact in our community.”

Carlsson backed up the organization’s belief in him last season. He finished second on the Ducks with 29 goals and 67 points in 70 games, then added four goals and 11 points in 12 playoff games before Anaheim was knocked out in the second round.

“It was just too good to pass on,” Carlsson said via Zoom Thursday. “I think everybody understands that too. I talked to my teammates a lot too, and everybody was just super happy for me and supportive with the decisions I made too.

“It’s more like when you see that number, it’s hard to say no, which my teammates understand too, completely. They would have done the same thing.”

For Philadelphia, the move came up empty and leaves the search for a true No. 1 center unresolved. General manager Daniel Brière has collected a promising young group, but the top of the lineup still has a glaring hole. With the Flyers unlikely to land a top-three draft pick anytime soon, they’ll have to find another route to solve it.

None of their current centers - Trevor Zegras, Christian Dvorak, Noah Cates or Sean Couturier - project as a top-line center on a contending team. The offseason isn’t necessarily finished, though.

Brière could still chase Columbus restricted free agent Adam Fantilli, or perhaps the disgruntled Dylan Larkin, who remains property of the Detroit Red Wings, could become an option. Even so, there’s also a real chance the Flyers open training camp in September with the roster they have now.

They are young, they are patient, and Brière is not expected to force a move just for the sake of making one.

Anaheim, meanwhile, now has to live with the financial consequences of keeping Carlsson.

The Ducks could have taken the four first-round selections and tried to rebuild around their cap space, while also focusing on re-signing 22-year-old sniper Cutter Gauthier. Instead, they stayed true to their public stance and matched the offer sheet, even though the number was far higher than they expected.

Carlsson’s cap hit will account for 17.4 percent of Anaheim’s cap for 2026-27, and that figure will only become easier to absorb as the cap rises. But the squeeze is real now, especially with Gauthier expected to seek a major extension and rookie standout Beckett Sennecke also on the path to a big payday once his entry-level deal ends.

The Ducks are also sending a message. After contentious contract talks with Trevor Zegras, Jamie Drysdale and Mason McTavish ended with all three eventually being traded, Anaheim had to prove it was serious about keeping its best young players. Matching Carlsson’s offer sheet did that, even if the price was steeper than anything they likely imagined last summer.

Now the pressure shifts to Gauthier. With Carlsson’s $18 million on the books, PuckPedia estimates the Ducks have just over $9 million in space, and Gauthier’s next deal is expected to land at least in eight-figure territory.

Frank Vatrano, who had a difficult 2025-26 season, is viewed as a possible salary dump and would free up $4.57 million. Chris Kreider or Alex Killorn could also be moved.

Trading Gauthier is technically another path, but it would be a long shot. Anaheim acquired him from Philadelphia for Drysdale in a deal the Ducks would make “10 times over,” and with the league knowing the Ducks are tight against the cap, the return wouldn’t be strong. There’s little leverage in any move they have to make now, but Carlsson and the Ducks can at least turn the page on a wild stretch and get back to building around the center they refused to let go.

In Other News...

Blue Jackets Young Core Suddenly Carries More Risk Than Fans Realize

For all the optimism around Columbus young talent, the next stretch is going to test how quickly the front office can keep that core together. Don Waddell has already made clear that Kirill Marchenko is expected back next season, but the winger is also headed toward the end of his current deal and will need a new contract soon after, which only adds to the pressure on a roster built around players who are still getting established.

Cole Sillingers arbitration case is another sign that the Blue Jackets are moving into a more complicated phase of team-building, especially with the organization placing a high value on him. Add in the broader unease around how other clubs might view Columbus emerging pieces, and the picture gets a little less tidy than it looked when the young core first started to take shape. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jackets Suddenly Have An Opening They Have Needed For Years

The Penguins ownership change has created a ripple effect that could reach well beyond Pittsburgh, and it comes at a time when the Blue Jackets have been searching for something they have lacked for years: a stable ECHL home for their prospects. Columbus has spent a long stretch without a long-term affiliate, with its last extended arrangement dating back to the Dayton Bombers before that franchise folded in 2009.

Wheeling has been tied to Pittsburgh for 29 years, the longest active NHL-ECHL partnership, so any shift there would be a notable break from the familiar. For Columbus, it would also open a door it has not had in a while, giving the organization a chance to pursue a more permanent developmental landing spot as the lower levels of its pipeline continue to matter. [Read more 🡒]

Leo Carlsson Just Opened Up About His Ducks Offer Sheet Scare

Leo Carlssons recent comments added a little more clarity to one of the summers more closely watched offer-sheet situations. The young center said he wanted to stay with the Anaheim Ducks all along, even after the Philadelphia Flyers came in with a five-year, $90 million deal that briefly put his future in play. Anaheim ultimately matched, keeping Carlsson in place and ending the immediate drama, but the episode still offered a reminder of how quickly a team can be forced into a hard decision when a rival makes a serious push.

For Columbus fans, the broader ripple matters because the Flyers are now looking elsewhere after missing on Carlsson, and the market around top young centers is never just about one player. The Ducks, meanwhile, get to keep a cornerstone they clearly value, but they also have to live with the kind of cap and negotiation questions that follow when a player of Carlssons profile gets to the open market in the first place. [Read more 🡒]