For Blue Jackets fans who lived through the 2005 NHL Draft, Anze Kopitar remains one of those names that can still make the whole thing sting a little.
The frustration starts with how strange that draft even was. The 2004-05 NHL season was wiped out by the lockout, and once the league and Players Union finally reached an agreement, there was no season left to play. Instead of a normal draft order based on the previous year’s standings, the league had to stage a lottery in the offseason.
That lottery drew enormous attention, and not just because of the lockout. The prize at the top was a Rimouski Oceanic prospect who was already carrying huge expectations, with hype described as arguably greater than any player since Eric Lindros. To keep things fair, all 30 teams had their lottery balls weighted, with clubs losing balls depending on prior high draft picks or playoff appearances in the years before the lockout.
Columbus had as good a shot as anyone. But when the dust settled, the Pittsburgh Penguins won the lottery and grabbed the top pick, while the Blue Jackets landed sixth. That was just far enough down to miss the group that had clearly separated itself at the top.
At that point, plenty of fans started zeroing in on a Slovenian forward who sat just outside the top five. The more people watched the highlights, the more appealing he looked.
Kopitar had the size, the hands, and the vision, and even then his game showed real intelligence. At 6'4", he looked like the kind of player who could eventually fit perfectly next to Rick Nash on Columbus’ top line.
There were reasons some scouts weren’t as sold. Concerns lingered about his overall raw game, and he also came from a non-traditional hockey country. Still, for a fan base that had long been drawn to undervalued talent, he fit the Columbus mold almost too well.
Then came draft day, and the Blue Jackets went another way.
The Montreal Canadiens changed the shape of the top of the draft by taking a goaltender fifth overall, a move that worked out extremely well for them. That opened the door for Blue Jackets general manager Doug MacLean to make the call himself, and he selected Vancouver Giants center Gilbert Brule with the sixth pick. MacLean saw Brule as the next franchise great.
At the time, that wasn’t an absurd reaction. Brule carried plenty of hype and was viewed by many as one of the top players in the class behind Sidney Crosby.
Even so, the Blue Jackets scouting staff reportedly wanted Kopitar instead. In the end, they were right.
Brule’s time in Columbus never came close to matching the promise. He played 146 games over three seasons with the Blue Jackets, scored 12 goals and 32 points, and was later traded to Edmonton for Raffi Torres. His NHL career finished with 299 games.
Kopitar’s path was the opposite. He played 1,521 regular-season games, all with the team that drafted him, and produced 452 goals and 1,316 points.
In the playoffs, he added 27 goals and 89 points in 107 games. He also won two Selke Awards, three Lady Byng Trophies, a Mark Messier Leadership Award, and two Stanley Cups.
Next season, the Kings will retire his jersey, and they are building him a statue.
That is what makes the 2005 draft so hard to revisit for Columbus. What could have been a foundational moment turned into another painful reminder of how quickly a franchise can miss on a player who was right there for the taking.
In Other News...
Nikishin Contract Tension Is Becoming A Real Hurricanes Problem
Alexander Nikishin has quickly become one of the more intriguing names in the Hurricanes summer conversation, not because of a new deal in place, but because of what happens next. The defenseman remains a restricted free agent, and while he cannot be signed away with an offer sheet, there is clearly enough interest around the league that Carolina has had to listen. GM Eric Tulsky has already acknowledged the trade calls and made it clear the Hurricanes are willing to consider moves that help the roster overall.
For a team trying to manage the balance between present needs and future value, that creates a tricky kind of pressure. Nikishins situation is not simply about keeping a useful player in the fold, it is about deciding whether his name belongs in the long-term plan or in the category of assets that can be used to reshape the roster. The fact that the inquiries keep coming suggests this is not fading anytime soon, and the Hurricanes may have to answer it before the rest of the market does. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jackets Fans May Barely Remember The Teams Only No. 54s
The No. 54 sweater has been a rare sight in Columbus, worn only by Scott Harrington and Adam McQuaid. For a franchise that has cycled through plenty of defensemen over the years, that number has barely had a history at all, which makes it one of the more obscure entries in Blue Jackets jersey lore.
Harrington spent 185 games in Columbus before his career took him through several teams and leagues, and he is currently signed with the Belleville Senators. McQuaid, meanwhile, was drafted by Columbus but did not actually skate for the club until a brief 2019 stint before an injury brought his career to an end, leaving him with 73 points and a Stanley Cup ring. [Read more 🡒]