Blue Jackets Leaders Face One Pressure Test After Last Seasons Collapse

Deck: As the Blue Jackets aim to break last season's cycle of fading in critical moments, leadership and strategic execution will be crucial in their playoff pursuit.

The Columbus Blue Jackets head into 2026-27 carrying the memory of a collapse that still stings.

On March 24, 2026, they walked out of Philadelphia with exactly what they wanted: two points in regulation against a Flyers team that was already hanging on. That win pushed Columbus into second place in the Metropolitan Division, gave them 87 points with 11 games left, and left their playoff odds at more than 80%. Philadelphia was seven points back after that night.

Then everything unraveled.

The next game in Montreal became the start of the slide. Columbus dropped a 2-1 decision to the Canadiens and lost Damon Severson to a season-ending shoulder injury.

From there, the season bled out. The Blue Jackets went 0-3-1 to finish March and then 2-5-0 in April.

They collected only five of a possible 22 points in their final 11 games and missed the playoffs by six points. Philadelphia surged into third in the Metro and eventually reached the second round.

That finish left a mark, and Rick Bowness’ rant after Game 82 only added to the frustration that followed Columbus into the offseason.

Now the Blue Jackets are back, with many of the same core players in place and a few new faces mixed in. But the lesson from last year is staring them in the face: they cannot let another season slip away in the same way. If that’s going to change, the burden falls on the players who matter most.

The biggest names have to carry more of the load.

Zach Werenski, Adam Fantilli and Kirill Marchenko were Columbus’ top offensive threats, but their numbers dipped when the season was on the line. Over those final 11 games, Werenski had 1 goal and 3 assists, Fantilli posted 3 goals and 3 assists, and Marchenko finished with 2 goals and 6 assists.

As their production faded, so did the Blue Jackets’ offense. Columbus scored 21 goals in that stretch, not counting shootouts, while allowing 35.

Werenski made it clear in August that he knows the standard has to rise.

“I think it starts with us leaders,” Werenski said. “I definitely don’t think we dragged enough guys into the fight.

I feel like on certain nights when it wasn’t going well, we didn’t have enough push and I feel like that starts with the older guys. It’s not for a lack of effort or try or any of that.

I just feel like there’s other ways to kind of get your group going.”

He was even more direct when talking about his own game.

“It’s a learning experience for me for sure,” Werenski continued. “I’ve never been in a position like that where you claw all the way back from last in the East to second in the Metro.

Then the next thing you know, you have some crazy losing streak and you’re out of it. I went home.

I looked at myself in the mirror and know I have to be better. I didn’t produce down the stretch … I think for me personally, that’s an area where I definitely drag our guys into it is producing and I didn’t down the stretch.”

That’s the crux of it for Columbus. The Blue Jackets don’t need vague talk about improvement. They need their best players to show up when the games tighten and the pressure climbs, regardless of injuries or lineup changes.

Leadership is also changing. Boone Jenner is now with the Washington Capitals, and Columbus has not announced a new captain.

Werenski is the most likely candidate if the role is offered, and Charlie Coyle is another option. Whoever gets the C will be responsible for setting the tone and making sure the room stays together.

Bowness, meanwhile, brings a track record the Blue Jackets are hoping to lean into. His most recent example was guiding the Winnipeg Jets to a President’s Trophy, with that team built on elite defense. Columbus has kept most of its core intact and wants to build on the positives from last season while absorbing more of Bowness’ structure.

That starts with team defense, especially with some continuity on the blue line after Severson’s injury changed the course of last year. It also means sticking to the process even when the results don’t come right away. Bowness has a history of getting teams to embrace that kind of discipline, and Columbus needs that kind of buy-in now.

The details matter too. The Blue Jackets have to execute the small stuff, whether it’s one play, one shift or one period.

They also have to play with more aggression and make better adjustments during games. Last season, too often, they backed off and let opponents take control, especially late.

That cost them points. They need to press more, force mistakes and stop giving teams room to breathe.

They also have to respond better when the game changes. Third periods were a problem, and the opposition made them pay for it. Whether that means adjusting coverages or tightening up within the structure, Columbus needs to be sharper when the margin gets thin.

The blueprint is obvious enough. It begins with the leaders, depends on the whole team buying in, and finishes with better execution and a better plan.

The path back to the playoffs is there for the Blue Jackets in 2026-27. Now they have to make sure they don’t repeat the ending from last season.

In Other News...

Adam Fantilli Talks Just Got Tougher For The Blue Jackets

Adam Fantillis next contract has only grown more complicated for the Blue Jackets, even before any real breakthrough at the negotiating table. NHL insider Elliotte Friedman said Columbus still has not reached the figure Fantillis camp might be seeking after Leo Carlssons new deal, a development that only adds more pressure as the market around young stars keeps moving upward.

Carlssons five-year, $90 million offer sheet, matched by Anaheim, came with an $18 million average annual value and immediately fueled more conversation about where elite center contracts are headed. Flyers general manager Daniel Briere has pushed back on the idea that Carlssons deal reset the market, pointing instead to the rising salary cap, but for Columbus the practical issue remains the same: the gap in Fantilli talks appears to be sticking around, and the number the Jackets are willing to live with may not yet be the one his camp has in mind. [Read more 🡒]

Blue Jackets Jersey No. 24 Carries One History Fans Will Recognize

Jersey No. 24 has become one of those Blue Jackets numbers that carries a little bit of everything behind it, from early-era depth players to more recognizable names who helped shape the franchises identity. The list includes Mike Gaul, Franois Beauchemin, Nathan Gerbe and others, each leaving a different imprint in Columbus before moving on to other stops, other roles or, in some cases, post-playing work in the sport.

What makes the number especially notable is how often it has been tied to players who stuck around in one form or another, with Derek MacKenzie standing out as a steady presence over a long stretch and then making the jump into coaching afterward. The current holder has only added to that lineage, giving No. 24 a little more weight for fans who like tracking the history stitched into the sweater, even if the most recent chapter is still unfolding. [Read more 🡒]