The Columbus Blue Jackets have taken one more piece of business off the board, locking up Cole Sillinger on a three-year contract worth $13.875MM, with a $4.625MM annual average value, according to Sportsnet’s Elliotte Friedman.
It keeps one of Columbus’ key restricted free agents from reaching arbitration, and it also gives the club a clearer picture of where Sillinger fits going forward. At 23, he’s no longer the fresh-faced prospect the Blue Jackets rushed into the league, but he’s still young enough that the organization has clearly decided to bet on him in a defined role.
Sillinger’s path to this deal started back in 2021, when Columbus took him 12th overall after a big season with the USHL’s Sioux Falls Stampede. He put up 24 goals and 46 points in 31 games there, along with a +5 rating, and NHL Central Scouting ranked him 10th among North American prospects.
The Blue Jackets took an unusual route from there. Rather than letting him marinate, they signed him right away and put him on the roster out of training camp just a few months after the draft.
He was only 18 during his rookie year, and he handled the jump reasonably well, finishing with 16 goals and 31 points in 79 games while averaging 13:42 of ice time per night. Even so, he didn’t receive one of the 14 rookie votes for the Calder Trophy.
Since then, the offensive ceiling hasn’t really climbed. Outside of an injury-shortened 2022-23 season, Sillinger has settled into the 30-to-35-point range and has mostly served as a tertiary scorer in Columbus’ middle six.
The Blue Jackets have tried to mold him into more of a defensively responsible center, and he has added some physicality along the way. But the results haven’t moved much.
He’s not a standout at the faceoff dot, though he isn’t a liability there either, and his defensive numbers have stayed fairly flat. Last season, he started 55% of his shifts in the defensive zone and posted an 89.9% on-ice SV% at even strength, which sat in the middle of the pack among Columbus forwards.
The contract itself says plenty about how the Blue Jackets view him. His salary more than doubles from his previous deal, but the number lines up with what a third-line forward gets as the cap keeps rising. Barring injuries, that’s the lane he appears headed for.
Columbus also has more options ahead of him now. The team is set to get a full season from Charlie Coyle and Conor Garland, and it added winger Valeri Nichushkin earlier in the offseason, which cuts into Sillinger’s path up the lineup.
When this deal runs out, Sillinger will be 25 and eligible for unrestricted free agency after the 2028-29 season.
In Other News...
Don Waddell Just Changed The Blue Jackets' Biggest Contract Question
The Blue Jackets have quietly taken a big chunk of business off the board by locking up Jet Greaves and Cole Sillinger on separate three-year deals, and the timing matters as much as the contracts themselves. For a team trying to keep its books clean, Don Waddell has managed to avoid the kind of rushed, cap-clogging move that can haunt a roster later, and these two signings give Columbus a much clearer path as it starts sorting out its next wave of core players.
Adam Fantilli is the name that now hangs over the rest of the summer, and the structure of these deals suggests the Blue Jackets are preserving room for a major extension without boxing themselves in. Greaves contract took some late work to get across the finish line, which only adds to the sense that Columbus was willing to be patient rather than force the issue, and that approach could end up defining how the front office handles its most important negotiation next. [Read more 🡒]
The Cam Atkinson Trade Still Hits Blue Jackets Fans Hard
The Cam Atkinson trade still lands with a thud in Columbus, even years later, because it marked the end of one of the most recognizable stretches of the franchises modern era. On July 24, 2021, Atkinson was dealt to the Philadelphia Flyers for Jake Vorek, a move that sent a longtime Blue Jackets face out the door and brought back a player with his own well-established track record.
Voreks stay in Columbus ended up being brief, and the aftershocks of the deal never really faded for fans who had spent years associating Atkinson with the teams identity. Atkinson eventually came back to close the loop in October 2025, signing a one-day contract so he could retire as a Blue Jacket, a final touch that only underscored how much that trade had altered the emotional shape of the roster and the fan base. [Read more 🡒]