The Blue Jackets may have a chance to chase one of the NHL’s biggest names, but that doesn’t mean they should. Connor Hellebuyck’s trade request is now public, and while the Winnipeg Jets goalie would clearly raise the floor in Columbus, the price tag and the timing make this look like the wrong swing.
Hellebuyck is still a premium piece. The 33-year-old is only one year removed from winning both the Vezina Trophy and the Hart Trophy, becoming just the third goaltender to take home the league’s MVP award since Dominik Hasek won it twice in 1997 and 98, and the first in 10 years.
Even after a down season in which he posted a .895% save percentage, a 2.86 goals against average, and 0 shutouts - the first time in his career he finished under 90% and without a shutout over a full season - there’s reason to believe that was the outlier. His Olympic performance, a .956% save percentage in 3 games, also suggests there’s plenty left in the tank.
But the fit in Columbus is where this falls apart.
The Blue Jackets already have five goaltenders signed for next season, with Jet Greaves leading the way after recently landing a 3-year, $15 million deal to stay in Columbus. Elvis Merzlikins is also in the picture, assuming he’s healthy, and he enters the final year of his deal with a $5.4 million cap hit and $4.225 million in actual salary. For a small-market team, that real-money piece matters.
As it stands, Columbus already has a goaltending tandem costing $10.4 million against the cap, which is exactly 10% of the league-wide salary cap. Hellebuyck, meanwhile, is signed for the next five seasons, including this one, at an $8.7 million cap hit and is still owed $39.5 million on the contract. That includes a $10 million salary next season.
That’s the real issue: not whether Hellebuyck would improve the Blue Jackets, because he would, but whether he’s enough of an upgrade over Greaves to justify tearing up the team’s salary structure. And that’s before you even get to the rest of the cost.
Any deal would almost certainly require Greaves, at least one first-round pick, and probably a top prospect too. Merzlikins could possibly be part of the return, but that would only push the price higher on the other pieces.
The bigger question is whether Hellebuyck is the missing final piece for a team on the cusp. The answer, from the source here, is no. He’s 33, and there’s no guarantee he’d still be playing at this elite level by the time Columbus is truly ready to contend.
So even if the opportunity is there, the logic isn’t. The Blue Jackets should stay away.
In Other News...
Blue Jackets Fans Will Remember What Jersey No. 30 Came To Mean
For Blue Jackets fans, jersey No. 30 has long felt tied to the teams history in goal, tracing back to the early days of the franchise and a stretch of netminders who each left a different kind of imprint. The number became part of the clubs identity through a run of goaltenders whose arrivals, departures and next steps helped map out the organizations development in a position that has often defined its seasons.
The list has ranged from established veterans to short-term stopgaps, with each stint adding another layer to what No. 30 has meant in Columbus. The latest chapter came with a brief appearance in 2023-24, a reminder that the jersey still carries weight even when the player in it is only passing through. [Read more 🡒]