The Columbus Blue Jackets and Adam Fantilli are still trying to find the number that works for both sides, and right now the gap is real. According to Pierre LeBrun on TSN, the two sides were not focused on an eight-year deal, which is why Tuesday’s deadline didn’t carry the same weight here. Even so, the Blue Jackets don’t want Fantilli to get to training camp without a deal in place.
What’s kept this from moving is simple: the money still doesn’t line up.
“There have been offers and counteroffers throughout the summer, but the reality is that they are $2-3 million apart on average annual value.”
Fantilli is coming off a 59-point season and is clearly in position to cash in as salaries keep climbing around the league. He’s not at training camp while the negotiations continue, and the question now is what his next contract should look like.
Kyle Morton of Daily Faceoff raised that exact point, asking what Fantilli is actually worth on this deal. Tyler Yaremchuk pointed to the broader market and the kind of money top young players are landing, saying Fantilli has already shown enough to be considered a top-line center.
“The point being, he’s proven over the last couple of years that he, at age 21… He’s proven he’s a top-of-the-lineup centerman. The Capitals are paying Ryan Leonard $10.5 million, and they aren’t even 100% sure if he can be that.
Connor Bedard, who is a step up on a guy like Fantilli, obviously, he got himself $15 million. Cutter Gauthier had one good rookie year and got himself $13.
And here we have a guy in Fantilli… you can argue if he has a ceiling of a Gauthier or whoever. You can argue if he’s a true franchise, No. 1 centerman, I get that, but he’s the guy Columbus has, and that’s a really important wrinkle in this negotiation, Hutts.”
Carter Hutton then brought the discussion back to the risk that comes with a shorter-term deal. With the eight-year route off the table, the next contract becomes a bet on what Fantilli could become by the time he gets back to the market.
“If you are to go to this number with Fantilli and bridge him, and you’re not giving him that deal. Obviously, the eight years is off the table now. The factor is: what is he going to be worth after another year as these markets keep growing, as players keep making more money?
I think that’s the risk that you run of giving the bridge deal, because on the other side of it… a young guy who’s unproven getting an eight-year deal, you can’t hold it against them, but the factor is if you give him a bridge deal and he throws in a 100-point season in that deal. Next thing you know, now he’s a $16, $17, $18 million player.”
For now, the Blue Jackets and Fantilli are still in that middle ground, with offers and counteroffers continuing and the average annual value still the sticking point.
In Other News...
Blue Jackets Fans Finally Have The Full Camp And Preseason Picture
The Blue Jackets finally have the kind of late-summer schedule their fans can circle on the calendar. Training camp opens Sept. 17, and the club has laid out a full run of practices through Sept. 24, giving Columbus a clear first look at how the roster will start to take shape before the regular season conversation really gets going. There will even be a couple of chances for fans to watch in person on Sept. 19, which should make the first stretch of camp feel a little more real.
Preseason follows quickly behind, beginning Sept. 21 against the Detroit Red Wings and rolling on through Sept. 26 with games against the Buffalo Sabres and Pittsburgh Penguins. The camp roster is set at 55 players, divided into two practice groups, so there will be plenty of names to sort through as the Jackets start evaluating who can make the strongest early impression. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jackets Suddenly Have A Damon Severson Question To Watch
The Blue Jackets are heading into camp with a little extra attention on Damon Severson, whose offseason shoulder surgery has kept him out of the early on-ice work. Columbus has already had to sort through a few moving parts on defense around the league this week, but Severson remains one of the more important names to track because of how central he is to the blue line picture when he is healthy.
For now, the expectation is that Severson will work his way back in time for the regular season, even if preseason games come too soon for him. That still leaves the Jackets with a temporary hole to manage and a watchful eye on how quickly he progresses once the exhibition schedule opens, especially with the team trying to get its defense settled before the games start to count. [Read more 🡒]
Carson Soucys Blue Jackets Chance Just Got Much Tougher
Carson Soucy came to Columbus on a professional tryout with a simple goal after a difficult previous season: show enough in camp to turn the invite into a contract. For a veteran trying to reset his career, the Blue Jackets made sense as a landing spot, but the runway to prove himself is now shorter than it used to be.
The new NHL collective bargaining agreement has cut into how much preseason exposure veterans on PTOs can get, and that makes every shift more valuable for Soucy and the other non-roster players trying to stick. Rick Bowness has already acknowledged how tough that is on evaluation, saying hed like more chances to see PTO players in action and that the current setup leaves too little room to make a real decision. [Read more 🡒]