Five games into the season, the Blue Jackets’ promised culture shift still looks more like a slogan than a reality.
Rick Bowness said at the end of last season that if he was brought back, he would change this team’s culture after a miserable finish. He is back now, but the early evidence keeps pointing in the same direction: the same bad habits, the same tough losses, the same public criticism.
From the outside, the Blue Jackets still come off as fragile, undisciplined and, frankly, carefree. In five games, there’s really only one performance that looked complete.
Opening night against Buffalo had its own messiness. The team looked shaky, which was hardly shocking with the shortened preseason and training camp.
Even so, they managed to score fairly easily against a shaky Sabres group and left with the two points. There was plenty to clean up, but the result was good enough.
The next game was a different story. Against the Utah Mammoth, the Blue Jackets were flat and unprepared, and Utah ran them into the ground by exposing the defensive zone and scoring almost whenever it wanted.
That same pattern showed up again in game No. 4 in St. Louis.
Tuesday’s game was the worst result of the bunch, even though there were some positive signs at even strength. The problem was the penalties kept piling up. Once the game stopped being played at five-on-five, whether the Blue Jackets were benefiting or Florida was, their special teams were a mess.
The one outing that stood out as a real bright spot came in game No. 3 against the Pittsburgh Penguins. That night, they showed how dangerous they can be, and they did it against a talented team that still has some gas in the tank.
What has not changed through any of this is Bowness’ tone. The message keeps coming back to the same familiar framing: “these guys,” or “if they don't.” But if the goal is a real culture change, the harder question is where the accountability is coming from.
Culture change starts with accountability.
The team chose to open the season without a captain, which is understandable given the circumstances. That part of the story has already been discussed enough. The bigger issue is what comes after that: if the roster is supposed to be full of players who can lead, where is that leadership showing up?
After every loss, the postgame lines sound almost identical. Players say they need to do this better or that better.
They talk about staying out of the box. They say they need to look in the mirror.
Those are nice clichés. So far, they have not amounted to much beyond words.
From the outside, there does not seem to be anyone in that room pushing standards upward. Nobody looks like the voice that would normally come from a captain. Instead, the coach keeps going to the podium and dressing down the whole team.
The TNT discussion after the 7-3 loss to the Panthers only added to that picture. The broadcast even highlighted Bowness going off on his team, and the reaction is hard to miss.
“I’m certainly not an NHL head coach, but I have to ponder: if he wants his team to be embarrassed about that hockey game, maybe embarrassing them on camera is the wrong way to go about it?” The issue, as framed here, is that the focus shifts from the game to the coach.
There is only so many times a coach can go nuclear before it stops landing. Bowness has already done that at least twice this season. If the players are not prepared, that is still something he can try to control.
One sign of that control is sitting right there in the lineup decisions. There has been one player in the press box for every game so far, and now that Damon Severson is back, there is a seventh defenseman available.
That should matter. Ice time is one of the clearest tools a coach has in the modern NHL. Instead of unloading on the whole group after every loss, Bowness could use those extra bodies to apply pressure where it belongs and hold the players making the mistakes to account.
On Tuesday, there was one forward and one defenseman who could have used a night off because of the decisions they made. That kind of move would send a message far more clearly than another public blast. It would say what Bowness has been promising all along: that this team is not here to mess around.
No one expects culture to flip overnight. But right now, the Blue Jackets seem to be trying to change theirs in exactly the wrong way, and that is a trap plenty of other coaches here have fallen into before.
Nobody wants another rebuild. The hope is they figure it out before this starts looking even more familiar.
In Other News...
Blue Jackets Defense Problem Is Making Guillaume Richard Hard To Ignore
The Blue Jackets keep running into the same issue on their blue line: injuries have thinned the group, and the current options have not done enough to stabilize the bottom four. With the defense under pressure and the roster picture getting shakier, attention has started to turn toward Guillaume Richard, who has been building a case in Cleveland with the kind of steady play that makes a call-up harder to dismiss.
Richards appeal is not just about filling a body in the lineup. His AHL work suggests a defenseman who can handle real minutes and add some value beyond simply surviving shifts, which matters for a Columbus team looking for someone who can help rather than patch holes. Ivan Provorov being out longer term only sharpens the urgency, and it leaves the Blue Jackets weighing how long they can keep waiting before giving Richard a look. [Read more 🡒]
Carson Soucys Blue Jackets Role Suddenly Looks Far Less Secure
Carson Soucys first stretch with the Blue Jackets has not gone the way anyone in Columbus hoped, and the early returns have made his place in the lineup feel much less certain. Through his first five games, he has had trouble finding his footing, and the roughest moment came against Florida when a mistake directly helped turn the game against his team.
With injuries still thinning the blue line, Columbus is not exactly overflowing with easy answers, but there are alternatives worth considering. Emil Andrae and Guillaume Richard both profile as options who could give the Jackets a steadier look, and after Soucys recent run of uneven play, there is a real case for keeping him out of the lineup when New York comes to town. [Read more 🡒]
Blue Jackets May Have Found One Line They Can't Afford To Disrupt
Through five games of a 2-3-0 start, the Blue Jackets have already settled on one trio that looks like more than a temporary fix. Their third line, built around Cole Sillinger and Charlie Coyle and used together in four of those games, has given Rick Bowness something he can trust beyond the top six. Sillinger has talked openly about the chemistry and the groups ability to handle the defensive side of the puck, and that matters for a team still sorting out its identity early in the season.
Coyle has fit the role especially well since signing a six-year extension, piling up five assists in five games while giving the line a steady two-way base. The numbers back up what the eye test is suggesting, too, with the trio driving play at a level few lines around the league can match when it comes to expected goals rate. For a club looking for stability, the question now is less about whether the line works and more about how long Columbus can afford to leave it alone. [Read more 🡒]