The Rockies have taken a small step forward, but they’re still buried near the bottom of the league, and 2027 is not being treated as a real window to contend. That leaves the offseason question hanging over everything: how hard will they actually push to move players off the major league roster?
For a franchise that has often been criticized for hanging onto its own too long, this is a revealing test for Paul DePodesta, who has been president of baseball operations for almost a year. The old pattern was easy to spot. Colorado stayed loyal to players well past the point where a trade might have made more sense, even when the return could have helped later.
Trevor Story and Jon Gray were both still on the roster at the 2021 deadline despite being impending free agents on a club that was out of contention. Around that same period, C.J.
Cron and Daniel Bard had already bounced around the league, found some success in Colorado, and then were extended instead of dealt. Those moves aged badly.
There has been some evidence of a different approach under DePodesta. Angel Chivilli, Seth Halvorsen, Victor Vodnik and Brenton Doyle were all traded, and each one was controllable for years. That kind of move would not have felt typical in earlier Rockies regimes.
But the bigger-picture picture is still muddy. Those were mostly supporting pieces - three relievers and a glove-first outfielder.
When it came to everyday players, the Rockies again seemed reluctant to budge. Hunter Goodman, Jake McCarthy and Mickey Moniak all came up in trade chatter before the deadline, and all three stayed put.
Moniak even got extended.
That was especially hard to square with McCarthy and Moniak. Both were cheap pickups, both were producing, and both looked like the kind of assets a club in Colorado’s position should be willing to flip.
Moniak was signed in 2025 after being released by the Angels, and he brought lefty-side power as a platoon bat. He was under control only through 2027.
McCarthy arrived from the Diamondbacks going into 2026 after a down season there, then turned in a strong bounceback year. He’s controlled through 2028.
Instead of turning either player into younger talent for the future, the Rockies kept them. Moniak got an extra year, and the decision has gone sour in a hurry. Since the extension, dating back to August 4, he has hit .172/.210/.321 with a 4.9% walk rate and a 32.9% strikeout rate.
Goodman was a little easier to understand. He still has three seasons of control left after this one, and he’s only reaching arbitration for the first time this offseason.
There wasn’t a pressing need to move him at the deadline. Even so, the market seemed real, and Colorado didn’t cash in.
Catchers can be tricky to move in-season because of the adjustment to a new pitching staff, but there was enough activity elsewhere to suggest the Rockies had a chance to strike.
So where does that leave them now? Moniak may simply not be bringing the kind of return Colorado wants, especially with most of his production coming at Coors Field and his value taking a hit since the deadline and extension.
McCarthy and Goodman, though, should still draw interest around the league. Whether the Rockies are actually open for business is the part that remains unclear.
Colorado’s books already reflect the long-term commitments. Kris Bryant is owed $52MM through 2028, Ezequiel Tovar $51.5MM through 2030 with the buyout of the 2031 club option included, Mickey Moniak $16.25MM through 2028 and Willi Castro $6.8MM through 2027. There are no option decisions on the table, and the club’s 2027 guarantees sit at $48.05MM, with total future commitments at $126.55MM.
On the arbitration side, Jimmy Herget, Jake McCarthy, Ryan Feltner, Brennan Bernardino and Hunter Goodman are eligible. Herget and Feltner are the names listed as non-tender candidates.
That’s the roster and the payroll picture. The real question is whether the Rockies finally use the offseason to act like a team building for something farther out, or whether they keep holding onto the pieces other clubs would be willing to pay for.
In Other News...
Rockies Now Have Another Rotation Tension To Sort Out This Offseason
The Rockies latest loss of momentum has only sharpened the questions facing the club as the season winds down, and the rotation is now part of that broader offseason picture. Colorado is staring at a fourth straight 100-loss season, and with the 2026 campaign nearing its finish, the front office will soon be sorting through free agents, future roles and how much stability it can actually count on in the staff.
Tomoyuki Sugano added another wrinkle to that conversation after being lifted following five innings against the Mariners, a move he said left him surprised and frustrated because he believed he could have kept going. For a team already trying to separate short-term innings management from longer-term rotation plans, even one midgame decision can echo beyond a single start, especially when the organization is trying to decide what kind of pitching structure it wants to carry into next year. [Read more 🡒]
Rockies Face An Emotional Coors Farewell With Rotation Jobs On The Line
The Rockies are closing out a season that has shown some improvement from 2025, even if the bigger picture still leaves them well out of playoff contention. Now the final homestand carries a little more weight than usual, with Kyle Freeland expected to take the mound in what could be his last start at Coors Field as the longest-tenured player on the roster and a pending free agent.
There is still evaluation to do beyond the emotion of Freelands possible farewell. Mason Adams and Tanner Gordon are lined up to start games in the final series, and both are trying to make a stronger case for themselves heading into next season, when every rotation spot and roster decision figures to be under a close watch. [Read more 🡒]
Kyle Freeland Faces A Painful Rockies Possibility At Coors Field
Kyle Freeland is set to take the ball at Coors Field against the Diamondbacks with a familiar kind of pressure hanging over the outing. The left-hander is in the final season of his five-year contract, and his year has been shaped as much by health and inconsistency as by the usual demands of pitching in Denver. He is also coming back from a neck injury suffered in August, another reminder that nothing about this stretch has been easy.
The broader issue for the Rockies is even harder to ignore: they have to decide whether Freeland fits into next seasons plans. His 4-10 record and 6.38 ERA reflect how rough the year has been, and his $17 million player option will not vest because he has not reached the required workload. What happens next is the sort of call that can define an offseason for a club trying to sort out both its rotation and its direction. [Read more 🡒]