Rockies Face A Huge Draft Test After Years Of First Round Frustration

As the Rockies gear up for the MLB Draft, their new front office aims to turn the corner by targeting sustained success through strategic first-round selections.

The Rockies are heading into the MLB Draft with a clear priority: find more players who can help the offense and, just as important, fit the organization’s broader vision.

That approach lines up with what general manager Josh Byrnes sees in the club’s recent surge at the plate. Over the past month, Colorado’s lineup has done damage in a variety of ways, and Byrnes believes that matters as the front office weighs its options with the No. 10 overall pick.

"We've got to score runs, and we had, generally, a very good month," general manager Josh Byrnes said. "We did it in all ways.

We had a long lineup, we were able to get hits, we had better quality at-bats and we slugged. That produces runs, so you need all of it.

"The other aspects -- defense, baserunning and positional versatility -- matter, too. We hit on a lot of these things in terms of going out for a month and scoring runs. Hopefully, we can do it over six months and it's a sustainable thing."

Byrnes, president of baseball operations Paul DePodesta and assistant general manager Tommy Tanous bring Draft experience from previous stops, while vice president of scouting Danny Montgomery and senior vice president of scouting operations Marc Gustafson remain part of the collaborative process after handling recent Drafts.

The Rockies are trying to sharpen a system that has produced mixed results in recent years. There have been some real hits in the later rounds, including two-time All-Star catcher Hunter Goodman in the fourth round in 2021, third baseman Kyle Karros in the fifth round in 2023 and center fielder Cole Carrigg in the second round in 2023. Carrigg made his MLB debut on June 9.

But the first-round track record is harder to defend. Right-hander Gabriel Hughes, taken in 2022, is the only first-rounder from those recent classes currently on the active 26-man roster.

There are some encouraging names in the pipeline. Right-hander Chase Dollander, the ninth overall pick in 2023, was pushing toward the front of the rotation before season-ending Tommy John surgery.

Outfielders Jordan Beck and Sterlin Thompson, both first-round picks in 2022, have spent time with the club this year and are now at Triple-A Albuquerque working back. Charlie Condon, the 2024 pick, and Zac Veen, taken in 2020, are also finding success at Triple-A.

Still, the list of misses is part of the picture too. Riley Pint and Robert Tyler, both first-round picks in 2016, have retired.

Pint did reach the Majors briefly, while Tyler did not. Benny Montgomery, a 2021 first-rounder, never got there during an injury-filled career.

Left-hander Ryan Rolison, picked in 2018, is now with the Cubs, and first baseman Michael Toglia, selected in 2019, is in the Reds’ organization.

The Rockies are also digging into models designed to make success more predictable, though they know the process will keep evolving.

"There are a few ways to look at it," Byrnes said. "One is historical odds that we are always studying.

Two is this year's Draft class, what's available to you. I still think it's taking the best player available.

I don't think imbalancing toward pitchers or position players is the right way to go."

Pitching, of course, comes with its own Denver-specific challenge.

"Pitching is its own riddle," Byrnes said. "We would deem why they are good, what might translate here. We'd look at why guys made it and why they didn't."

DePodesta said the organization spent the offseason trying to build a shared picture of the kind of players it wants.

"We even tried to do that through the course of this offseason," DePodesta said. "It was really starting to try to create a shared vision for the organization about what we wanted our guys to look like -- both pitchers and position players. I think we've communicated that throughout the course of the spring with our scouts, our player development people, even with our Major League team.

"As we go into the Draft process, my guess is a lot of our selections will reflect that it's hard to find 21 players for 20 rounds that are going to fit that precisely, so that's not necessarily what we're trying to do. It won't be cookie cutter, but I think there will be elements of each of those players that absolutely fit our philosophies."

On the pitching side, DePodesta described the target in simple terms.

"It's a sliding scale to some degree," DePodesta said. "We want guys who are hard to hit and we want them to throw strikes, so ideally you want them in that quadrant, if you were thinking about a sort of a four-square matrix."

Colorado enters the Draft with picks at 10, 37, 38, 76 and 104 on Day 1, plus a bonus pool of $15,557,600, including $6,393,100 tied to the No. 10 selection.

Last year’s top pick, Ethan Holliday, was taken fourth overall and signed for $9 million, a record for a high school player. He was immediately installed as the Rockies’ No. 1 prospect by MLB Pipeline.

Holliday had started to justify the hype with nine home runs and 32 RBIs in his first 33 games at Single-A Fresno before a stress fracture in his left foot ended his season in May. His recovery is expected to run toward the end of the calendar year.

There are also a few 2025 names already drawing attention. Max Belyeu, the 74th overall pick and the No. 12 prospect, has carried over his run-producing profile from Texas into pro ball. He has posted a slugging percentage in the high .400s and a mid-.800s OPS at High-A Spokane, using his speed and athleticism to create extra-base hits and cash in RBI chances, though he still needs to trim the strikeout rate.

Spokane third baseman Ethan Hedges, taken 77th overall, is another player to watch as a plus defender and doubles threat. First baseman Tanner Thach, selected 227th, has also stood out thanks to the RBI touch that helped him hit his way out of Fresno.

In Other News...

Rockies Face A Brutal Decision On One Of Their Few Stars

Ryan Goodman has become one of the few bright spots in a Rockies season defined by bigger problems on the mound. The 2026 campaign has only strengthened his value, with a .254 average, an .870 OPS and 27 home runs helping him earn a second straight All-Star nod, the kind of production that makes him one of Colorados most attractive trade chips if the front office decides to reshape the roster.

For a rebuilding club staring at a pitching staff that has struggled badly and a farm system thin on high-end arms, Goodman sits at the center of a difficult calculation. Moving him could bring back the kind of pitching help and payroll relief the Rockies badly need, but keeping him means holding onto one of the lineups few legitimate difference-makers, and the organization is still weighing whether this is the moment to make that kind of move. [Read more 🡒]

Rockies Are Already Treating Jordan Romano Like A Bullpen Answer

Jordan Romano did not have to wait long to find a new late-inning home after the Angels let him go earlier this season. Colorado signed the veteran reliever and immediately handed him the closer job, a sign the Rockies are willing to see whether his track record can still play in a thinner bullpen and at Coors Field.

Romano has given them a quick reason to be encouraged, working two clean-looking appearances in which he allowed one hit and struck out two in each outing. He picked up a save in his second game, and for a club that has been searching for stability at the back end, the early usage suggests Colorado is treating him less like a flyer and more like a real answer, even if the bigger test is still ahead. [Read more 🡒]