Rockies Deadline Trade Raises A Big Question About Colorados Return

In a strategic move by the Marlins, prospect talents Aiden May and Connor Norby head to the Rockies in exchange for struggling reliever Victor Vodnik.

The Marlins spent much of Monday in seller mode, but they shifted gears as the deadline drew near and brought in Rockies reliever Victor Vodnik in a deal that sent Aiden May and Connor Norby to Colorado.

Miami had already moved catcher Liam Hicks and pitchers Braxton Garrett and Lake Bachar before making the Vodnik trade, a move that gave the club a 26-year-old right-handed arm with some success in the mix despite uneven results this season.

Vodnik has worked 36 innings over 33 appearances this year and carries a 5.25 ERA with 26 strikeouts and 19 walks. His 2025 season looked much sharper: a 3.02 ERA, 49 strikeouts, 26 walks and 10 saves in 50.2 innings.

The home split is where the drop-off has really shown up. At Coors Field, his ERA has jumped from 1.33 over 26 appearances last year to 6.61 in 16 outings this season.

May, a second-round pick out of Oregon State in 2024, has spent 2026 at High-A Beloit, where he owns a 3.80 ERA with 58 strikeouts and 24 walks in 68.2 innings. His pitch mix includes a high-80s-to-low-90s cutter, a mid-to-high-90s two-seam fastball with heavy run, a sweeping low-to-mid-80s breaking ball and an upper-80s-to-low-90s changeup with fade.

He’s considered a pitcher with advanced feel for shaping the baseball and a chance to settle in as a back-end starter, though a bullpen role is seen as the likelier outcome. May did not rank in the Marlins’ July Top 30 Prospects update.

Norby brings a much bigger major league track record. He has played in 198 big league games since debuting with the Orioles in 2024, then joined the Marlins later that season and has spent parts of the last three years in Miami.

The right-handed hitter is versatile defensively, but his offense has been below average, with below-average power as well. He remains under club control through the 2031 season.

In Other News...

Rockies Finally Made A Deadline Move That Says Plenty About Their Reset

For a Rockies club looking to reshape its future as much as its roster, the deadline brought a move that fit the moment. Antonio Senzatela had already shifted into a bullpen role this season, and the adjustment seemed to help him, with his fastball ticking up and his overall effectiveness improving. Even so, Colorado used him as part of a deal that adds a pair of lower-level pieces with different kinds of appeal, signaling a front office still sorting through what it wants this reset to become.

Juan Martinez arrives as a 19-year-old infielder whose value starts with contact, while Mark Manfredi brings a left-handed arm and some experience working at the Double-A and Triple-A levels. For the Rockies, it is the kind of deadline move that does not scream immediate help, but does say plenty about where the organization is placing its attention now, and where it hopes to find answers later. [Read more 🡒]

Rockies Fans Just Got A Clear Sign Of DePodestas Plan

The Trade Deadline gave Colorado a fresh look at where the front office wants to go next, and it came with a clear shift in direction. Paul DePodestas first major deadline posture as president of baseball operations centered on moving established big-league pieces and bringing back a crop of prospects, the kind of turnover that signals the Rockies are thinking well beyond the current standings.

The returns were headlined by right-hander Nick Frasso and Single-A outfielder Landyn Vidourek, along with other prospects, giving the organization more development pieces to work with. DePodesta also addressed the deals and the possible impact of the newcomers, leaving Rockies fans with a better sense of the plan even if the immediate on-field payoff is still something the club has to build toward. [Read more 🡒]

Rockies May Regret Passing On Their Best Deadline Opportunity

Hunter Goodman gave the Rockies exactly the kind of first-half performance that can reshape a deadline, blasting 27 home runs before the All-Star break and putting himself in the middle of plenty of contenders wish lists. Colorado did move other players for modest prospect returns, but when it came to Goodman, a catcher under team control through 2029, the front office decided to keep the bat in Denver rather than cash in one of its most valuable trade chips.

It is the kind of call that fits the uncertainty of a rebuilding club, but it also invites immediate second-guessing. Goodman still has no contract extension in place, and with the Rockies clearly not close to contention, passing on a chance to maximize his market value could look like a missed opportunity for a team that needs every edge it can find in the next phase of the rebuild. [Read more 🡒]