The Rockies’ offseason has to start with one hard question: what is Hunter Goodman worth?
Colorado president of baseball operations Paul DePodesta is going into the winter with every avenue open as he looks to improve the club for the 2027 season. That includes free agency and trades.
But the Rockies are not in position to chase big-money deals or take on heavy salaries in the trade market right now. They’re still rebuilding after a fourth straight 100-loss season, and the next step has to be measured.
That’s why Goodman stands out.
Several teams would love to get their hands on the power-hitting catcher, and there have been rumors around him for a while. If DePodesta decides to move him - and that would be a risky call - the return can’t be just good. It has to be massive.
Colorado should be looking at the kind of package the Baltimore Orioles landed from the Boston Red Sox for catcher Adley Rutschman at the deadline in August. Baltimore got catcher Carlos Narváez, right-hander Kyson Witherspoon, outfielder Enddy Azocar, and outfielder Harold Rivas in that deal.
That’s the benchmark. If Goodman goes, the Rockies need something in that neighborhood or better.
Rutschman was the No. 1 overall pick, but he’s not the same player he was when he first arrived, and the source material makes clear that Goodman’s production over the last couple of seasons in Denver has been at least in that range, if not better. Boston got a useful piece. Colorado would need to do even better if it dangles Goodman.
And that’s the tension here. Power-hitting catchers are rare, and Goodman gives the Rockies one of the better ones in MLB.
He also gives them a potential long-term solution behind the plate. Still, if DePodesta wants to use Goodman to help reshape the roster for 2027 and beyond, the return has to hit.
A catcher could even be part of the haul, with Austin Wells of the New York Yankees mentioned as a possible fit since New York has been linked to Goodman.
If Colorado pulls the trigger, there’s no room for a lukewarm outcome. This is the kind of move that can help define the next phase of the rebuild - or leave the Rockies wishing they had kept the bat.
In Other News...
Rockies Face An Offseason Fans Have Been Begging For
The Rockies head into the offseason with a familiar mix of needs and not much financial room to smooth over them, which is why this winter feels so important for a club that has spent too long trying to patch holes one by one. The roster still needs help in several places, but the biggest theme is direction: finding younger starting pitching, stabilizing the bullpen, fixing second base with a more dependable option, and giving the lineup a better chance to work counts through a new hitting coach.
There is also a clear case for leaning harder on the organizations own prospects, something that would at least match the age and timeline of the rest of the roster better than another round of stopgaps. For a team that has been searching for a path back to relevance, this is the kind of offseason fans have wanted to see - one that looks less like maintenance and more like a reset, even if the most important decision still lies ahead. [Read more 🡒]