The Colorado Rockies’ season of experimentation produced a few real answers, but the biggest lesson may have come on the pitching side: they do not have time to keep guessing.
Paul DePodesta made that much clear before the year even began, and the Rockies spent the season sorting through what worked and what didn’t. Some of the position-player gambles paid off. Trading for and plugging in TJ Rumfield at first base worked better than expected, Jake McCarthy gave them help after coming over from Arizona, and in-season promotions for Cole Carrigg, Kyle Karros and, of course, 40-homer guy Hunter Goodman all fit the plan.
On the mound, there were a couple of hits too. Brennan Bernardino, acquired from Boston, turned out to be a smart pickup, and Jordan Romano gave Colorado the experienced closer it has lacked for years after coming off waivers from the Angels. Mason Adams, the right-hander brought over from the White Sox, also looks promising.
But that’s where the encouraging part of the pitching story largely ends.
Everything else about the Rockies’ mound work fell apart, from the inexperienced coaching setup to the underdeveloped arms that kept getting chances. The front office now has to treat the offseason like an emergency, not a waiting game, because with a lockout looming in December, the window to do meaningful work is tight. If Colorado wants to avoid a fifth straight 100-loss season, it has two months to move.
The warning signs from the past are already there. After the last lockout, in 2021, the Rockies waited until a compressed post-lockout offseason before signing Kris Bryant on the eve of spring training. That move became an expensive reminder of what happens when urgency comes too late.
This time, the clock is already running. Free agents won’t be available until after the World Series, but staffing decisions can be made now, and the pitching department is the obvious place to start.
Alon Leichman’s first year as major league pitching coach looks like a clear miss, and the broader development group has raised plenty of questions. Assistant Gabe Ribas, who had some moderate success as a relief pitcher in Class A ball, and pitching coordinator Matt Daniels bring analytical know-how, but little or no professional playing background. Bullpen coach Matt Buschman is the only current organizational voice with MLB experience, and he had just three games as a big-league reliever.
That résumé is thin, and it showed.
The Rockies have plenty of people who understand the numbers. What they’re missing is the kind of lived-in perspective that comes from having actually done the job at the highest level. One observer summed it up this way: “The Rockies’ pitching people have a lot of knowledge, but not a lot of wisdom.”
That has to change, and it can change in September.
Analytics still needs to matter in Colorado’s pitching development. It just needs to be paired with real major-league experience. They even have Jason Hirsh’s phone number.
DePodesta also floated another possible answer for next season: a return to piggybacking. Colorado used a similar setup in 2013, when it rolled out a four-man rotation with pitchers capped at 75 pitches, then followed them with another four arms on a schedule to cover three to four more innings under pitch limits. Ryan Feltner and Tanner Gordon were mentioned as pitchers who could benefit from that arrangement.
“We need to find the best way to get 27 outs every night,” DePodesta said.
For a staff that has struggled to get through games cleanly, piggybacking would make a lot of sense, especially at the start of next season, whenever that begins.
The Rockies have now seen enough to know where the experiment worked and where it blew up. With the offense showing progress and the pitching issues laid bare, the front office has enough information to move out of phase one and start building toward 2027.
In Other News...
Rockies Fans Finally Have An Offseason Bright Spot To Watch
September brought a familiar mix of dominance and distinction across both leagues, with the monthly honors offering a neat snapshot of who finished the season on a roll. For Rockies fans, these kinds of awards can feel like a small consolation in a long year, but they also serve as a reminder of how much star power still drives the sport when the calendar turns late and every hot streak starts to matter.
The monthly winners were spread across the usual categories, from Player of the Month to Pitcher, Rookie and Reliever honors, with each selection backed by strong September numbers. It is the sort of league-wide roundup that gives Colorado supporters something to track while the offseason settles in, especially with more of the sports biggest names starting to emerge as the conversation shifts toward what comes next. [Read more 🡒]