Colorado’s Joseph Williams has been putting up the kind of numbers that usually get a receiver mentioned in the Biletnikoff Award race. Instead, the Buffaloes wideout was left out of the award’s 13-man semifinalist group, a snub that looks even stranger when stacked against the rest of the Power Four field.
Williams ranks No. 8 among Power Four receivers with 926 yards, though Colorado’s official total lists him at 933. Even with that production, he was one of just two top-10 receivers omitted when PFF College ranked the conference’s receiving leaders Tuesday. Baylor’s Gavin Freeman was the other.
The comparison that jumps off the page is Oklahoma State’s Justin Bowick, the Big 12 semifinalist whose spot drew the loudest questions. Bowick has 49 catches for 868 yards and 10 touchdowns. Williams has 63 receptions and four 100-yard games, one more than Bowick’s three, including a 178-yard outing against FCS Murray State.
Their head-to-head meeting on Oct. 24 in Stillwater only sharpened the debate. Bowick went for 138 yards on five catches in Oklahoma State’s 57-24 win, while Williams answered with 135 yards on nine receptions.
The difference between them that day? Three yards.
Williams wasn’t the only receiver whose inclusion raised eyebrows. Rutgers’ KJ Duff and LSU’s Jackson Harris also made the semifinalist list despite sitting outside PFF’s top 10 altogether.
Still, the selection committee had ammunition of its own. Illinois receiver Collin Dixon has 13 touchdown catches along with 946 yards, and Miami receiver Malachi Toney reached 13 scores before an injury. Williams has seven touchdowns, with only two coming since he landed on the award’s watch list in early October.
There’s also the context around how Williams got here. He has produced while Colorado coach Deion Sanders rotated quarterbacks, moving from Julian Lewis to Isaac Wilson, and he did it after missing spring practice while recovering from offseason surgery. His most recent game against Houston showed the kind of impact he can still make, with five catches for 80 yards and a 53-yard touchdown in the third quarter of Colorado’s 42-32 upset.
The miss stings a little more in Boulder because of the standard already set there. Former Colorado receiver and cornerback Travis Hunter won the Biletnikoff two years ago with 1,258 yards and 15 touchdowns. Williams came to Colorado from Tulsa that December after earning American Athletic Conference Freshman of the Year honors, and he is now 67 yards away from 1,000 with two games left.
The award picture isn’t finished yet. Three finalists will be announced on Nov. 24, and the winner will be revealed on Dec.
- Williams is out of the running for now, even if his own words from Colorado Buffaloes on SI at the school’s Fall Sports Media Day in August 2025 still sound like the kind of target he was chasing all along.
"I have big goals for myself," Williams told Colorado Buffaloes on SI. "I want to win the Biletnikoff (Award) this year, but I can't do that alone.
The offensive line has to play well, the quarterback must play well, I have to do my job. I have to have my trust in my teammates as well as they have to do with me to be able to accomplish that."
In Other News...
Colorado Students Just Got A Real Reason To Show Up All Season
The University of Colorado is trying to give students a little extra incentive to stay in the stands this winter, with a new sweepstakes tied to attendance at select home games for both the mens and womens basketball teams. Students who are part of the Charged Up Student Rewards Program can qualify by showing up for six designated mens games or five designated womens games, turning regular season support into a shot at a bigger trip.
The prize is a Boston getaway to see the Celtics, with two winners from each group set to receive airfare and tickets courtesy of Derrick White and United Airlines. It is the kind of campus promotion that does more than fill seats for a night or two, because it gives Colorado a season-long hook for students who might otherwise only drift in and out of the arena. [Read more 🡒]
Colorado Fans Have An Unexpected Road Trip Debate This Week
A trip to Cincinnati is suddenly looking a little more affordable for Colorado fans who were eyeing the Buffaloes upcoming game at Nippert Stadium. Resale listings have dipped into the $34 to $43 range, a notable shift for a road game that will kick off at 10 a.m. MT on ESPN+, with Cincinnati also planning to recognize its senior class and stage a Military Appreciation event.
Nippert Stadium holds 38,088, and the smaller setting can make the atmosphere feel even tighter for visiting supporters trying to decide whether the trip is worth it. Anyone making the trek will want to pay close attention to the ticket sections, since Cincinnati has designated visitor areas, and the question now is whether the lower prices will be enough to turn a tentative road-trip debate into a full contingent of Colorado fans in the stands. [Read more 🡒]
Cincinnati Just Revealed What Worries Them Most About Colorado
Scott Satterfield spent part of the buildup to Cincinnatis game with Colorado doing what every good opponent does this time of year: digging through the tape and trying to sort out what actually travels. His read on the Buffaloes centered on a defense he sees as aggressive, with linebacker Gideon Lampron, safety Randon Fontenette and defensive lineman Santana Hopper standing out as the kinds of players who can change the tone of a series. On the other side, he pointed to the Bearcats need to account for Colorados offensive tendencies after watching recent film, with DeKalon Taylor and quarterback Isaac Wilson part of the conversation.
What makes the matchup interesting from Cincinnatis side is how much of the attention seems to come back to Wilsons ability to affect the game in more than one way. Satterfield also drew a comparison between his own coaching record and Deion Sanders, a reminder that this meeting is carrying a little extra edge beyond the usual Big 12 prep. For Colorado, the takeaway is simple enough: Cincinnati believes it has identified the Buffaloes strengths, and now the challenge is proving those concerns matter once the game starts. [Read more 🡒]
