Sidney Crosby To Colorado Suddenly Feels Less Impossible

With Nathan MacKinnon sidelined, speculation mounts over a possible Sidney Crosby move to the Colorado Avalanche as the Penguins edge towards a rebuild.

Nathan MacKinnon’s long-term injury has put an old Sidney Crosby rumor back in play, and this time the timing feels a little less far-fetched.

The idea of Crosby ending up with the Colorado Avalanche has been floating around for years, but the setup is different now. Crosby is again in the final year of his current deal, the Pittsburgh Penguins appear to be heading toward a rebuild, and MacKinnon is out long term. That combination has reopened a conversation that usually gets dismissed as wishful thinking.

The biggest question isn’t whether the Avalanche would want Crosby. It’s whether Crosby would actually want to leave Pittsburgh.

Penguins GM Kyle Dubas has already made it clear the organization would respect whatever its captain decides. If Crosby were to say, “I want to play with MacKinnon in Colorado,” that would be the direction things go.

If he were serious enough about it, Crosby could even push Dubas into making it happen no matter what it costs the organization.

Colorado would still have to pay a price, and a meaningful one at that. A trade like this would almost certainly require a prospect-heavy return, and the Avalanche do have some rising stars they could move.

The cap situation is where things get complicated. Under the old rules, the move would have been straightforward: shut MacKinnon down for the rest of the regular season, place his $12.6 million cap hit on LTIR, add Crosby, then bring MacKinnon back for the playoffs. But the NHL closed the infamous “LTIR loophole” after the Tampa Bay Lightning and the Vegas Golden Knights abused it.

Now, if the Avalanche placed MacKinnon on LTIR, they would only get about $3.9 million in cap relief. To get the full relief, they would need to put him on season-ending LTIR, which would make him ineligible for the playoffs.

That means any serious push for Crosby would require creativity from all sides. If the Avalanche and Crosby truly wanted to make it work, the Penguins would need to be as accommodating as possible.

For now, this is still just a thought experiment, and the likeliest outcome is that nothing comes of it. Still, don’t be surprised if the Crosby-to-Colorado chatter starts getting louder, even without anything concrete behind it.

In Other News...

Erik Johnsons Avalanche Legacy Was Built Through Years Of Heartbreak

Erik Johnsons place in Avalanche history was never built on flash alone. It was shaped over years of injuries, frustration and a long stretch of carrying heavy minutes for a team that leaned on him as much for steadiness as for skill. By the time he retired in October 2025, after a 17-season NHL career and more than 1,000 games, he had become one of those rare defensemen whose value showed up in the less glamorous places, none more so than his status as Colorados franchise leader in blocked shots.

Johnsons path also gave his career a fittingly winding arc. He spent time with the Blues, Sabres and Flyers before returning to Colorado in 2025, closing the loop with the organization where he became a central figure and eventually a Stanley Cup champion in 2022. For Avalanche fans, his legacy is tied not just to the title, but to the years of heartbreak that made the payoff feel so hard-earned. [Read more 🡒]

Avalanche Just Got A Much Bigger Nathan MacKinnon Problem

Nathan MacKinnons absence has turned into a far bigger issue for the Avalanche than the one-month window they were first bracing for. After additional medical evaluations, Jared Bednar said after practice that the star center is now expected to be sidelined for about 12 weeks, with the lower-body injury he suffered on Nov. 12 pushing his return into February.

For a Colorado team built around MacKinnon driving the pace and tilting the ice, that length of time changes the way everything has to be managed in the middle of the lineup. The Avalanche will lean on other centers, including Brock Nelson and Nazem Kadri, to absorb the workload and keep the team afloat while it waits for its most important player to get back on the ice. [Read more 🡒]

Devon Toews Is Forcing His Way Into A Bigger Avalanche Debate

Devon Toews has become one of the more important reasons the Avalanche have stayed steady through stretches of lineup shuffling on the blue line. With injuries forcing Colorado to lean harder on him, Toews has answered with a bigger role, more responsibility and a level of production that has stood out even by his standards. His seven goals and 21 points in 23 games only tell part of the story, because the workload has been just as notable as the offense.

What makes this season especially interesting is how Toews is starting to push into a much larger conversation around the league. The Avalanche have long valued him as a dependable two-way defenseman, but the combination of his scoring touch, heavy minutes and all-around impact is putting him on the radar for a potential Norris Trophy run. For a player often discussed as a complementary piece, this has the feel of a season that could change how he is viewed beyond Denver. [Read more 🡒]