TJ Rumfield has done enough with the Colorado Rockies to force his way into the National League Rookie of the Year conversation, even if the latest MLB.com poll doesn’t reflect it.
The September 2 ballot left Rumfield buried in fifth place, well behind the pack. Cincinnati Reds slugger Sal Stewart led the way with 173 points, followed by St.
Louis Cardinals second baseman JJ Wetherhold at 140, New York Mets pitcher Nolan McLean at 115 and Mets outfielder Carson Benge at 106. Rumfield?
Just 37 points and one first-place vote in a survey of 40 MLB.com experts who ranked their top five candidates on a 5-4-3-2-1 scale.
That gap is hard to ignore, especially when Rumfield’s production stacks up so well against the hitters ahead of him. Through 139 games, he is batting .299/.389/.460 with an .849 OPS, along with 15 home runs, 28 doubles, three triples and 67 RBI. He has also drawn 65 walks against 78 strikeouts.
By comparison, Stewart is hitting .268/.338/.483 with an .821 OPS, Wetherhold is at .242/.343/.370 with a .713 OPS, and Benge is at .276/.334/.416 with a .750 OPS. In plain terms, Rumfield leads those three position players in batting average, on-base percentage and OPS.
Stewart still has the strongest power case by a wide margin, with 31 home runs and 107 RBI. McLean’s spot is easier to defend because he’s doing it on the mound, where an 11-8 record, 3.06 ERA, 1.14 WHIP and 179 strikeouts over 161.2 innings make his second-place standing easy to understand.
Wetherhold and Benge also bring skills Rumfield can’t match. Wetherhold’s defense at second base has been elite, while Benge’s speed and athleticism have helped him steal 20 bases.
But none of that fully explains how far ahead they are of Rumfield in the voting.
The usual Coors Field question does come up here, and yes, Rumfield has made the most of his home park, especially with the bat. Ten of his 15 home runs have come in Denver, and 47 of his 67 RBI have been driven in there.
Still, the split doesn’t erase what he’s done overall. He’s hitting .307 at home and .290 on the road, and he has actually drawn more walks away from Coors Field, 36 compared with 29, even though he has fewer road at-bats.
That matters because his season isn’t being propped up by one setting. It’s holding up everywhere.
He’s also finishing strong. Over his last 30 games, Rumfield is hitting .307 with a .435 on-base percentage.
Over the last 15, those numbers jump to .367 and .516. In his last seven games, he’s 12-for-26.
Wetherhold, meanwhile, was hitting .204/.323/.292 over his last 30 games before landing on the injured list. Benge has been better, but he’s gone just 6-for-28 over his last seven.
Rumfield’s season has been building all year, not fading away. He was the NL Rookie of the Month in May after hitting .310/.400/.483 with four home runs and 12 RBI.
In June, he followed with five home runs, nine doubles and 17 RBI while slashing .316/.400/.589. That made him the first Rockies player to win Rookie of the Month twice, and the first NL rookie to take consecutive monthly awards since Michael Harris II did it in 2022.
Even with that track record, he still wasn’t part of the discussion when Mike Petriello of MLB.com examined the NL Rookie of the Year race in August.
That’s where the disconnect really shows up. Rumfield may not have Stewart’s thunder, Wetherhold’s glove or Benge’s speed, but leaving him out entirely doesn’t fit the season he’s having.
He’s putting together one of the best offensive rookie seasons in the National League. And if he’s not the favorite, he shouldn’t be treated like an afterthought.
In Other News...
Devon Toews Just Had A Very Colorado Sports Moment
Devon Toews got a little taste of Colorados other pro-sports stage recently, stepping onto the mound at Coors Field to throw out the ceremonial first pitch before a Rockies game. The Avalanche defenseman took part in the pregame festivities and then settled into the stands to watch from a different vantage point, a simple crossover moment that fits neatly into the way Colorados biggest teams tend to overlap.
It was one of those only-in-Colorado scenes that reminds you how tightly the states sports world can knit itself together, from the Avalanche to the Rockies and, of course, the Broncos. Even with recent reports swirling around the Broncos ownership group, Toews trip to the ballpark served as a lighter snapshot of that shared local spotlight, with one of the Avalanches most recognizable players spending an evening right in the middle of it. [Read more 🡒]
Cale Makar Has A Chance To Enter Rare NHL History
Cale Makar keeps finding himself in the kind of conversation reserved for the NHLs most special players, and this one reaches all the way into league history. The Avalanche defenseman is not just admired as one of the games best blue-liners, but as someone with a legitimate path to an award that usually belongs to elite forwards, a path that only a handful of defensemen have ever managed to travel.
For Makar to get there, the season would have to be extraordinary in every phase, with offense and defense both strong enough to make him impossible to ignore. Even then, the Hart Trophy is a voter-driven race, and he would still have to separate himself from names like Connor McDavid, Nikita Kucherov and Nathan MacKinnon, which is what makes the possibility so intriguing and so difficult to pull off. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Leave Jared Bednar Question Unsettled Entering Key Offseason
Jared Bednars contract situation has become one of the quieter storylines around the Avalanche as the offseason gets underway, but it carries real weight for a team that has spent the better part of a decade under his direction. Joe Sakic said there is no urgency to get an extension done, even as the sides continue talking, and that reflects a certain calm around a coach who has been on the bench since 2016 and helped guide Colorado to a Stanley Cup title in 2022.
Bednar is heading into the final year of his current deal, which would normally add a little more edge to the conversation, but both sides seem content to let the process breathe. For now, the Avalanche are leaving one of their most important decisions unresolved as they turn toward a crucial offseason, with the expectation that discussions will keep going without anyone forcing the issue. [Read more 🡒]