Nathan MacKinnon’s Hall of Fame case is already hard to poke holes in.
The Colorado Avalanche star has stacked up the kind of résumé that usually makes the conversation pretty simple: Hart Trophy, Calder, Lady Byng, Rocket Richard and Ted Lindsay. Add a Stanley Cup to the mix, and he’s already checked off the kind of boxes that separate great players from the ones who end up in the Hall.
That Cup matters, too. It’s the sort of thing that can trip up even the biggest names, which is why Connor McDavid’s resume still gets discussed with that one obvious missing piece. MacKinnon doesn’t have that issue.
What really pushes MacKinnon into ironclad territory, though, is the way he’s played at his peak. Hall voters look hard at that, and MacKinnon’s best years have been right up there with the league’s elite. He’s been in the top three conversation year after year, and the source material makes one thing clear: there hasn’t been a down season since he entered the NHL.
That kind of consistency is rare. Even when injuries have entered the picture, MacKinnon has still stayed at an elite level. At 31, he’s still producing video game numbers, season after season, and that sustained excellence is a huge part of why his Hall case already feels so secure.
There’s also the impact he’s had on Colorado itself. MacKinnon’s influence on his team is described as undeniable, and that kind of franchise-changing presence is exactly what separates a star from an all-time great.
The one real blemish mentioned is the absence of Olympic gold. The 4 Nations Face-Off title and MVP were a major win, but the silver medal at the 2026 Milano-Cortina Olympics is the note that stands out as the lone negative on an otherwise sparkling resume.
In Other News...
Avalanche Prospect Egor Shilov Is Making Colorados Bet Look Better
The Avalanches second-round swing on Egor Shilov is already looking like a smart one, even before he ever puts on a Colorado sweater. Taken 43rd overall in the 2026 NHL Draft, the center made a strong pre-draft case with Victoriaville in the QMJHL, where he led the Tigres in both assists and points while wearing the captains letter.
Shilovs path now shifts to Penn State, where he is expected to arrive for the 2027-28 NCAA season and test himself against a higher level of competition. For Colorado, that longer development runway is part of the appeal, and the early returns suggest the organization may have found a player whose growth is tracking in the right direction. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Response After That No Show Could Shape A Bigger Problem
The Avalanche are heading into their matchup with Nashville still carrying the sting of a poor showing against Columbus, and Jared Bednar made it clear the response matters as much as the result. Colorado has been trying to steady its game by getting back to basics, with the coach pointing to consistency and defensive structure as the areas most in need of a reset.
Bednar also suggested lineup changes could be part of the answer if the team keeps leaking quality looks against. For a club that wants to give its goaltending a better chance to settle things down, the focus is on cutting down high-danger chances and tightening the details that slipped in the previous outing. [Read more 🡒]
Cale Makar Is Already Forcing A Wild Avalanche Legacy Debate
Cale Makar has spent the early part of his NHL career making the kind of impact that usually takes a defenseman a decade to build. He already has a Stanley Cup, a Conn Smythe Trophy, two Norris Trophies and the Calder Trophy on his rsum, along with multiple All-Star selections, and he has led NHL defensemen in points per game since his debut. For the Avalanche, that means the conversation around him is no longer just about where he ranks among the leagues best right now.
It is also starting to drift into a bigger debate about legacy, even with plenty of hockey still ahead of him. Makars pace and hardware have put him in rare company so quickly that the question is no longer whether he is on a Hall of Fame track, but how much more he needs to do before that case feels inevitable. [Read more 🡒]