Devon Toews Is Forcing His Way Into A Bigger Avalanche Debate

With key injuries impacting the Colorado Avalanche, Devon Toews has stepped up as a defensive anchor, raising his profile as a potential Norris Trophy contender.

Devon Toews has become the steady hand the Colorado Avalanche have leaned on while the blue line keeps getting shuffled around.

Josh Manson’s injury forced one adjustment, and then another hit when Cale Makar went down a few games ago. Head coach Jared Bednar had already split up Toews and Makar in an effort to spark more offense and bring some stability, but that setup disappeared quickly. Since then, Colorado has turned to call-ups and waiver claims, yet Toews has remained the one constant.

He’s shouldering a heavy load and still contributing at the other end. Through 23 games, Toews has seven goals and 21 points, putting him on track to top his career highs in both categories.

The workload has been just as notable as the production. On November 12 against the Ottawa Senators, he logged 29:22 in an overtime loss.

He followed that with 24:04 against the Montreal Canadiens, 25:06 against the Utah Mammoth, and then 25:54 the next night versus the Anaheim Ducks.

That Ducks game offered the cleanest snapshot of what he’s been giving the Avalanche: a goal, an assist, and a 4-0 shutout win. It’s only one example, but it fits the broader picture of a defenseman doing a little bit of everything for a team that has needed it.

That kind of season has also opened the door to a bigger question: could Toews be sneaking into the Norris Trophy conversation?

The scoring race among defensemen is crowded, and the names at the top are familiar ones. Evan Bouchard of the Edmonton Oilers leads blueliners with 37 points in 24 games. Behind him are players like Quinn Hughes, Adam Fox, Seth Jones, and Roman Josi, along with younger standouts such as Matthews Schaefer, Lane Hutson, and Jackson LaCombe, all of whom have better offensive numbers than Toews.

But offense only tells part of the story.

Bouchard’s numbers come in the context of an Oilers team that doesn’t really play defense, even though they have improved this season under Mike Babcock. And that’s where Toews starts to stand out. The question isn’t just who is piling up points; it’s who is actually proving to be one of the best all-around defensemen.

As Zach Werenski showed last season, raw production doesn’t have to be the deciding factor when it comes to Norris-worthy play. Toews may not be leading the scoring charts, but his value to Colorado has been impossible to miss.

In Other News...

Sidney Crosby To Colorado Suddenly Feels Less Impossible

Sidney Crosby to Colorado has moved from pure fantasy to something that at least merits a real conversation, even if the path there is still a long one. The idea has picked up because of Crosbys contract situation and the sense that the Avalanche may eventually have to think about a reset, but any serious pursuit would run straight into the realities of the roster and the cap.

Nathan MacKinnons long-term injury only complicates the picture further, because the Avalanche would need creative solutions to make the money work while preserving the core around him. Even then, a deal would still depend on Pittsburgh being willing to engage, and for now this remains exactly what it looks like: a speculative scenario with no confirmed movement. [Read more 🡒]

Erik Johnsons Avalanche Legacy Was Built Through Years Of Heartbreak

Erik Johnsons place in Avalanche history was never built on flash alone. It was shaped over years of injuries, frustration and a long stretch of carrying heavy minutes for a team that leaned on him as much for steadiness as for skill. By the time he retired in October 2025, after a 17-season NHL career and more than 1,000 games, he had become one of those rare defensemen whose value showed up in the less glamorous places, none more so than his status as Colorados franchise leader in blocked shots.

Johnsons path also gave his career a fittingly winding arc. He spent time with the Blues, Sabres and Flyers before returning to Colorado in 2025, closing the loop with the organization where he became a central figure and eventually a Stanley Cup champion in 2022. For Avalanche fans, his legacy is tied not just to the title, but to the years of heartbreak that made the payoff feel so hard-earned. [Read more 🡒]

Avalanche Just Got A Much Bigger Nathan MacKinnon Problem

Nathan MacKinnons absence has turned into a far bigger issue for the Avalanche than the one-month window they were first bracing for. After additional medical evaluations, Jared Bednar said after practice that the star center is now expected to be sidelined for about 12 weeks, with the lower-body injury he suffered on Nov. 12 pushing his return into February.

For a Colorado team built around MacKinnon driving the pace and tilting the ice, that length of time changes the way everything has to be managed in the middle of the lineup. The Avalanche will lean on other centers, including Brock Nelson and Nazem Kadri, to absorb the workload and keep the team afloat while it waits for its most important player to get back on the ice. [Read more 🡒]