Cale Makar keeps pushing into territory that defensemen usually don’t reach, and that’s why the Hart Trophy conversation is starting to feel real.
The debate around the NHL’s elite has mostly settled on the same three names: Connor McDavid, Nikita Kucherov and Nathan MacKinnon. The question hanging over the rest of the league is whether Makar belongs in that group, too. Based on where his game is headed, the answer looks like yes - and if he gets there, he could chase a piece of NHL history that only three defensemen have ever claimed.
That piece is the Hart Trophy.
By definition, the Hart goes to the player most valuable to his team. In practice, it has become the league’s MVP award, and that usually means a forward.
Defensemen almost never get into that race, and the list of winners is tiny. Chris Pronger was the last blueliner to win it, back in 2000.
Before him, Bobby Orr took it from 1970 to 1972. Babe Pratt won it in 1944.
That’s the full list.
Makar would need a season that feels historic from the jump to crack that club.
A 100-point year would get the conversation moving, but it probably wouldn’t be enough on its own. Still, it wouldn’t be some wild fantasy. Makar has already reached 90 points twice, so the idea of him getting to triple digits is very much in play.
But scoring alone wouldn’t do it. To win the Hart, Makar would likely need the full package: elite offense and the kind of shutdown impact that made Pronger’s 2000 season so memorable. Pronger barely edged Jaromír Jagr in Hart voting that year, and his defensive work remains one of the benchmark seasons for a modern defenseman.
The numbers would have to be outrageous. Pronger finished at +52 in 2000, and Makar has already come close to that standard with a +48 in 2021-22. That gives him a path, but not an easy one.
He might not need to win the Art Ross Trophy, but he’d need something that grabs the league by the throat. A 40-goal season from a defenseman would certainly qualify.
So would 100 assists. Playing more than 30 minutes a night could help his case, too, just like it did for Pronger.
And if Makar somehow led the Avalanche in scoring while Nathan MacKinnon keeps putting up video game-like numbers, that would only make the argument stronger.
In the end, the Hart is decided by voters, and voters love seasons that feel impossible to ignore. If Makar puts together something truly unique - the kind of year that pulls attention away from McDavid, Kucherov or even MacKinnon - then the Avalanche star has a real shot at joining the rarest company in NHL history.
In Other News...
Devon Toews Just Had A Very Colorado Sports Moment
Devon Toews got a little taste of Colorados other pro-sports stage recently, stepping onto the mound at Coors Field to throw out the ceremonial first pitch before a Rockies game. The Avalanche defenseman took part in the pregame festivities and then settled into the stands to watch from a different vantage point, a simple crossover moment that fits neatly into the way Colorados biggest teams tend to overlap.
It was one of those only-in-Colorado scenes that reminds you how tightly the states sports world can knit itself together, from the Avalanche to the Rockies and, of course, the Broncos. Even with recent reports swirling around the Broncos ownership group, Toews trip to the ballpark served as a lighter snapshot of that shared local spotlight, with one of the Avalanches most recognizable players spending an evening right in the middle of it. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Leave Jared Bednar Question Unsettled Entering Key Offseason
Jared Bednars contract situation has become one of the quieter storylines around the Avalanche as the offseason gets underway, but it carries real weight for a team that has spent the better part of a decade under his direction. Joe Sakic said there is no urgency to get an extension done, even as the sides continue talking, and that reflects a certain calm around a coach who has been on the bench since 2016 and helped guide Colorado to a Stanley Cup title in 2022.
Bednar is heading into the final year of his current deal, which would normally add a little more edge to the conversation, but both sides seem content to let the process breathe. For now, the Avalanche are leaving one of their most important decisions unresolved as they turn toward a crucial offseason, with the expectation that discussions will keep going without anyone forcing the issue. [Read more 🡒]
Rockies Fans Have A Real Beef With TJ Rumfield's ROY Buzz
TJ Rumfield has put together the kind of rookie season that usually forces its way into the conversation, even if the noise around him has not quite caught up. Through 139 games, the Rockies infielder has backed up the buzz with a .299 batting average, a .389 on-base percentage and an .849 OPS, numbers that put him near the front of the class in several key categories and make his place in the National League Rookie of the Year race hard to ignore.
Still, the latest MLB.com poll has him fifth with 37 points and just one first-place vote, a slot behind Cincinnatis Sal Stewart and a few other names drawing more of the spotlight. For Colorado fans, the gap between what Rumfield has actually done and where he sits in the voting is the sort of thing that tends to linger, especially when a player keeps producing and the recognition still feels a step slow to arrive. [Read more 🡒]