Avalanche Suddenly Face A Brutal Test Without Their Two Biggest Stars

Without MacKinnon and Makar, the Avalanche face a critical test of their depth and resilience as they navigate the coming weeks.

The Colorado Avalanche have already shown they can survive one game without Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar. The bigger question is how long they can keep doing it.

After Thursday’s 4-3 overtime loss to the Ottawa Senators, Colorado was left picking up the pieces from a rough night that included both the blown late lead and the injuries to its two biggest stars. MacKinnon is expected to miss a month with a lower-body injury, while Makar is projected to be out at least a couple of weeks.

The Avalanche answered back with a 4-1 win over the Montreal Canadiens on Saturday, but that doesn’t erase the challenge ahead. In a tight Central Division, any slip during this stretch could push Colorado backward in the standings while it waits for its top two players to return.

That was the focus on Monday’s episode of Daily Faceoff LIVE, where Tyler Yaremchuk and Carter Hutton broke down what life might look like for Colorado in the meantime.

Yaremchuk didn’t go as far as to suggest the Avalanche are headed out of the playoff race, but he did caution against expecting the same level of production from a team missing two of its defining pieces.

“I’m not going to sit here and say that the Avs are going to not be a playoff team. They beat a very good Montreal team over the weekend without those two players, but I don’t think they’re going to be playing .700 hockey over the next month without those two. It might be a situation where we look at the standings in a month and the Avs are a lot lower than they traditionally would be in December.”

Hutton pointed to the opportunity for the rest of the roster to tighten up defensively and take on more responsibility, especially with more minutes and bigger roles opening up across the lineup.

“I guess maybe the positive takeaway from this, is as a team, as I just touched on with Carolina, now the Avalanche have to be very present about how they’re going to defend and protect their d-zone as a committee, as they add some depth to their lineup, as there’s some guys that are going to be playing in more of a top-six role and getting more minutes. I think this might shore you up a little bit about the way you’re going to defend and the way you’re going to play, knowing that you’re losing access to Nathan MacKinnon’s offense, Cale Makar’s offense, and the power play with where they’re at.

I think you might be able to use this as a rallying cry as “next man up”, and we’ve seen this numerous times with teams. You lose stars, you rally around it, you solidify what you are and your identity, and then you reinsert Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar and you’re like, “the world’s our oyster” after that.

We have our offense back, we have a good situation.”

Hutton also said the Avalanche have enough depth to get through the stretch, but he believes the outcome may hinge on the play in goal. He singled out Mackenzie Blackwood and said this is the kind of season where he has to prove he can be the guy.

“I think they’re deep enough to manage this, and it’s going to come down to goaltending. For me, Mackenzie Blackwood, a good Thunder Bay boy, I love him, but at what point are you that outright number-one guy that’s going to win them a Stanley Cup? This has to be the season for him.”

In Other News...

Avalanche Just Sent A Dangerous Message Without MacKinnon And Makar

Missing Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar would usually force any contender into survival mode, but Colorado handled Montreal with the kind of composure that suggests its depth is doing more than just filling space. The Avalanche won 4-1 anyway, getting key contributions from Fedor Svechkov, Brock Nelson and Artturi Lehkonen while MacKenzie Blackwood made the saves needed to keep the game under control.

The bigger takeaway for Colorado is what it looked like with two of its biggest names out of the lineup and the rest of the roster still dictating the terms. The power play also did its part, going 1 for 4, which only added to a night that sent a clear message about how dangerous this group can be even when it is not at full strength. [Read more 🡒]

Avalanche Suddenly Need This Depth Move To Matter

The Avalanche turned to the waiver wire for some immediate blue-line help, claiming defenseman Mike Reilly from the Carolina Hurricanes as they try to steady a roster hit by injuries to Nathan MacKinnon and Cale Makar. Reilly arrives with plenty of NHL mileage, having already spent time with several teams since being drafted in 2011, and Colorado is clearly looking for a player who can absorb minutes without forcing the club to overextend the rest of its defense.

Reillys addition is more than a simple depth pickup because of the timing around it. With two of the Avalanches most important players sidelined, every roster move carries more weight, and this one will be judged by whether it can help the team stay afloat until the lineup is healthier again. For now, Colorado has added an experienced defenseman to the mix, and the next question is how quickly he can fit into a situation that suddenly looks a lot more demanding. [Read more 🡒]

Avalanche Injuries Could Suddenly Make This Leafs Pick Matter More

The Avalanches injury situation has a way of making a future draft asset feel a lot closer than it did a few weeks ago. Toronto currently holds Colorados first-round pick, and because it is top-10 protected, the value of that selection can swing depending on how the Avalanches season unfolds. For the Maple Leafs, it is the kind of pick that could eventually be used in a trade or turned into a player in the 2027 draft, which matters even more given that Toronto does not have its own first-rounders in 2027 or 2028.

With that in mind, the conversation around possible targets is starting to feel less theoretical. Cooper McAslan, Kayden Stroeder, Levi Harper and Aleks Kulemin all bring different looks and different kinds of upside, and the Leafs could use that kind of flexibility if the pick lands in their lap. The real intrigue is less about who they like today and more about how much this injury-riddled stretch in Colorado might change the draft board before Toronto has to make a decision. [Read more 🡒]