Part of building a contender is knowing when to pay up and when to walk away. The Colorado Avalanche have generally handled that part well in the salary cap era, but there have still been a few contracts that stuck out for all the wrong reasons.
Some of those mistakes came from trying to reward veterans. Others came from betting big on players who had already shown their best hockey. Either way, the Avalanche have had enough misses to put together a clear top five of their worst deals since the cap came in.
At No. 5 is PA Parenteau’s four-year, $16 million contract from 2012. Colorado had good reason to believe in him after he posted a career-high 67 points with the New York Islanders, and he backed that up with a strong first season in Denver, scoring 18 goals and finishing with 43 points in 48 games during the lockout-shortened year.
But the second season brought a drop-off, and by the summer of 2014 he was sent to the Montreal Canadiens. Colorado got out before the deal sank any further; Parenteau managed only 22 points in 55 games for Montreal before being bought out.
Adam Foote lands at No. 4 with the two-year, $6 million contract he signed in 2008. This one was always tricky because it involved a franchise veteran, and it came after Colorado had already given up a first-round pick to bring him in during the 2007-08 season.
Then-GM Francois Giguere handed Foote the extension, likely as much for what he had already meant to the organization as for what he still had left. The problem was that his ice time kept shrinking, his offense had basically vanished, and the numbers painted an ugly picture.
He finished the deal and played one more season before retiring.
Scott Hannan checks in at No. 3 after signing a four-year, $18 million contract in 2007. Giguere was swinging for the fences that summer, and Hannan was one of the big additions.
At the time, he looked like a steady defensive defenseman with a little bit of offensive value. In reality, he was already on the decline.
His minutes and performance slipped on both sides of the puck, and he ended up with just 58 points in 322 games for Colorado. The Avalanche did at least salvage something late in his run, moving him for Tomas Fleischmann, who had 21 points in 22 games.
David Jones comes in at No. 2 on a four-year, $16 million deal from 2012. He had two 20-goal seasons behind him and brought a physical edge, so the contract was understandable at the time, even if it felt rich.
Then came the lockout-shortened 2012-13 season, and Jones produced just nine points in 33 games. That was enough for Colorado to move on quickly, sending Jones and Shane O’Brien to the Calgary Flames for Cory Sarich and Alex Tanguay.
Tanguay added a little nostalgia, but the real objective was getting away from Jones’ contract.
The worst of the bunch was Ryan Smyth’s five-year, $31.3 million deal from 2007. Colorado saw a power forward who had scored 36 goals in back-to-back seasons with the Edmonton Oilers and tried to use that momentum, along with the Hannan signing, to push back into contention.
Smyth did have a solid first year with 37 points in 55 games, then followed it with 26 goals and 59 points in 77 games in 2008-09. But the decline was already visible, and the Avalanche eventually shipped him to the Los Angeles Kings for Tom Preissing, Kyle Quincey, and a fifth-round draft pick.
For all of those misfires, Colorado has mostly been strong with its contracts in the cap era. Nathan MacKinnon’s deal is one of the best values in the league, and that kind of bargain has helped the Avalanche stay in the contender mix since moving to Denver in 1995. The margin for error is tighter when so much of the cap is tied up keeping core players around, but in this case, the Avalanche have also benefited from the fact that plenty of other teams have made even bigger mistakes.
In Other News...
Avalanche Rookie Weekend Put A Few Unexpected Names On The Radar
The Avalanches rookie weekend offered the usual first look at the organizations next wave, with a practice session leading into two games at the rookie tournament. Colorado handled Anaheim 7-2 in the opener before dropping the second game to Vegas 6-5 in a shootout, giving the staff a quick early read on who looked comfortable in a fast, competitive setting.
A few names stood out along the way, including Teddy Lechner, Alex Gagne and Beckett Hamilton, each of them making enough of an impression to land on the radar coming out of the weekend. For an Avalanche system that always has to balance immediate depth needs with longer-term development, these are the kinds of early showings that can matter when training camp starts to tighten the picture. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Add A Proven Winner To A Roster Still Facing Questions
Jaden Schwartz brings a championship pedigree and a familiar touch of Colorado to a roster that still has plenty to prove. The former St. Louis Blues forward, who won the Stanley Cup in 2019, has signed a three-year contract with the Avalanche, adding another experienced piece to a team that keeps pushing for another deep playoff run. His connection to the state goes back to his college career, which gives this move a little more weight than a typical offseason addition.
Schwartz is now getting ready to join the group and work his way into the lineup, a process that will matter as much as the contract itself. Colorado has talent, but it also has questions, and bringing in a player who has already lived through the grind of a championship run gives the Avalanche another voice in the room as they chase the same goal again. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Camp Suddenly Has A Forward Crunch Fans Should Watch
Colorados recent rookie tournament offered a useful glimpse at two names worth tracking as camp approaches, with TJ Hughes and Taylor Makar both making a strong impression. Hughes, the Avalanches top NCAA free agent signing, is viewed as a player who should get his first NHL look at some point, while Makars path is a little different after already logging limited NHL time and showing enough to at least enter the conversation for a fourth-line role.
Their rise matters because the Avalanche are already navigating a crowded forward picture, and that kind of internal pressure can ripple through the rest of the roster. Even if both players are likely to start in the AHL because of waiver rules and cap constraints, their performance gives Colorado more options, whether that means forcing a tougher camp decision or creating added trade flexibility down the line. [Read more 🡒]