The Colorado Avalanche can handle Nathan MacKinnon leaning into the rough stuff. They can live with the hits, the puck battles, the edge he brings when the temperature rises.
What they can’t live with is their star getting hurt in a fight.
That was the uneasy backdrop when MacKinnon dropped the gloves with Brandt Clarke in Colorado’s first game of the season. MacKinnon held his own and clearly came out on top, but the bigger issue is the one that lingers after the dust settles: the Avalanche can’t afford to keep seeing their best player involved in fights.
There’s no question MacKinnon deserves credit for not backing down. He has always played with an edge, and that competitiveness is part of what drives the physical side of his game. When a team needs a spark, a superstar standing up for himself can carry real value.
Still, the risk is obvious. One awkward fall is all it takes.
The source of the concern isn’t theoretical. Matt Rempe of the New York Rangers broke his thumb in a fight last season, and Logan Mailloux of the St.
Louis Blues suffered a hand injury after fighting in the preseason, in a game that didn’t mean anything. Those injuries mattered for them.
The same kind of setback for MacKinnon would matter far more.
A broken hand could cost him weeks. A shoulder injury could become an even bigger issue. For a team with so much tied to his health, that’s a gamble Colorado doesn’t need to make.
That’s also why NHL teams still keep a place for players in the enforcer role. The old version of that job may not look the same anymore, but the need hasn’t disappeared. Teams still want players who can absorb some of the physical punishment that comes with fights and rough play.
If someone wants to send a message, the Avalanche need someone else on the roster willing to answer it.
That doesn’t mean MacKinnon should stop playing hard. Quite the opposite.
His intensity is part of what makes him so effective. But there’s a clear line between being aggressive and stepping into unnecessary mayhem.
Colorado needs MacKinnon scoring goals and creating chances, not taking punches. He doesn’t need to prove his toughness that way.
He may have walked away from the fight with Clarke just fine. He may even have sent a message that he won’t be pushed around. But the Avalanche can’t afford to keep rolling those dice with their best player.
In Other News...
Matt Duchene Suffers Another Setback At Brutal Time For Dallas
Matt Duchenes latest setback lands at a rough time for Dallas and brings another layer of uncertainty to the early part of the season. The former Avalanche first-round pick has been placed on long-term injured reserve after suffering a lower-body injury in training camp, forcing the Stars to start the year without one of their most proven forwards.
Duchene, who spent nine seasons in Colorado before becoming a key piece in Dallas, led the Stars in scoring last season and was expected to remain a central part of their offense. Instead, he will miss at least 10 games and cannot return before Oct. 25, leaving Dallas to adjust its lineup while waiting on a player whose absence changes the look of the top end of the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Top Line Is Creating A Problem Opponents Havent Solved
The Avalanche have barely gotten through the first week of the season, and already their top line looks like the sort of matchup problem opponents spend all night trying to solve. Nathan MacKinnon, Martin Necas and Artturi Lehkonen have each found ways to drive the attack, with MacKinnon setting the tone as a distributor and the other two finishing plenty of the chances that have followed.
It showed up most clearly in the 6-1 win over the Blues, when MacKinnon piled up three assists and Necas scored twice on his way to 50 goals with Colorado. Lehkonen has done his part too, chipping in with goals and assists, which gives the line a balanced look that is hard to key on for a full shift, let alone a full game. [Read more 🡒]
Avalanche Fast Start Puts Early Lineup Crunch In Focus
A 2-0 start has the Avalanche feeling good about the way the season has opened, but it is also setting up an early test for roster management as reinforcements get closer. Logan OConnor was on the ice in a full-contact jersey in practice, a sign his return is drawing near, and Zachary LHeureux is also trending toward a comeback after being sidelined.
The timing matters because Colorado has a busy stretch ahead, with games coming against the Winnipeg Jets, Calgary Flames and Toronto Maple Leafs. Getting both forwards back would give the Avalanche more depth and flexibility at a moment when the lineup is starting to tighten, leaving coach and staff to sort out how quickly they can fold the newcomers back into the mix. [Read more 🡒]