The White Sox have made their move on the rotation, and they didn’t do it cheaply.
Chicago agreed Tuesday to a three-year, $52.5 million deal with free-agent right-hander Dustin May, a contract that makes him the new ace of the staff and fits the offseason message general manager Chris Getz laid out earlier this winter. Getz had already said the White Sox would make starting pitching a priority once the transaction window opened, and this is the kind of swing that shows he meant it.
It’s also the kind of deal that raises eyebrows.
May is the better pitcher, but the price tag is steep enough that it would have been a hard sell for a team like the Guardians, who could have been in the mix if they wanted to chase rotation help. That said, it’s tough to picture Cleveland’s front office being comfortable with a contract that carries an average annual value north of $17 million. Even if they had been willing to go there, the long-term risk would have been obvious.
May has the kind of arm that gets attention from analytics-driven teams. His power stuff and the numbers beneath the surface have kept him in that conversation.
But the contract still lands as a surprise when you stack it against his recent production. He finished last season with a 4.70 ERA in 145 2/3 innings between the Cardinals and Brewers.
Most of the better work came in St. Louis, where he posted a 4.38 ERA and threw the first shutout of his career before things went sideways in Milwaukee, where his ERA climbed to 5.65.
He also struggled in the postseason.
The larger concern is durability. May has already been through Tommy John surgery, which came in 2021 and cost him most of the following season.
He missed all of 2024 because of a mix of injuries, and while he has stayed on the mound since then, the results have been uneven. Across the 2025 and ’26 seasons, he logged 278 innings and posted a 4.82 ERA.
That’s the gamble Chicago is making, and it’s a big one. The White Sox have already spent heavily on Luis Castillo, whose expensive contract arrived at the deadline for the same purpose: stabilize the rotation.
That move hasn’t worked out the way they hoped, and the club still doesn’t have much depth behind Sean Burke. Grant Taylor is moving from the bullpen into the rotation after a strong postseason run, but beyond that, there isn’t much to lean on.
So May steps in as the headliner of a staff that needs him. Whether the contract looks smart down the line is another question entirely.
For now, the White Sox have their new ace. Whether he’s the kind of investment that holds up is where the real test begins.
In Other News...
Guardians Suddenly Face A Tough Backup Catcher Decision
Ryan Jeffers taking the Twins qualifying offer has already started to reshape the catcher market, and it leaves clubs looking for a reliable backup with fewer comfortable choices. For the Guardians, that matters because the position is one of the few places on the roster where they have some depth, and they also brought in Kody Huff while making a change on the coaching side to help guide the group.
Austin Hedges is still out there, and his reputation as a strong defensive catcher keeps him in the conversation for teams that value handling a staff and controlling a game behind the plate. Clevelands internal options and the new catching coach could make the fit less straightforward than it first appears, which is why the Guardians may have a tougher call here than a simple free-agent chase. [Read more 🡒]
Former Guardians Pitcher Just Gave Cleveland Fans A Familiar Debate
A familiar name from the Guardians recent pipeline is moving on, and it comes with the kind of spring-training wrinkle Cleveland fans know well. Steven Perez, the left-handed pitcher originally signed by the club as an amateur free agent in 2018, has landed a minor league contract with the Cardinals that includes an invitation to big league camp for the 2027 season.
Perez reached minor league free agency after the 2026 season and opted for a fresh start in St. Louis, where he will try to win a roster spot without having made his MLB debut yet. For Cleveland, it is another reminder of how often the organizations pitching development leaves fans tracking former prospects elsewhere, wondering what might have been if the next step had come in an Indians or Guardians uniform. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Took A Risk With One Prospect And Fans Noticed
The Guardians used the final spots on their 40-man roster to protect three prospects from the Rule 5 Draft, adding Justin Campbell, Kody Huff and Jaison Chourio in a move that showed how much value the organization still places on its upper-level depth. It was a fairly straightforward bit of roster housekeeping on the surface, but it also came with a notable omission, one that immediately stood out to fans who track the system closely.
Left-hander Franklin Gomez was left unprotected, a decision that raised some eyebrows given the arms perceived upside. Cleveland may simply view him as not close enough to the majors to justify a roster spot right now, but the choice still leaves room for second-guessing, especially with the status of the 2026 Rule 5 Draft clouded by the possibility of a lockout. For now, the Guardians have made their bet on who needs protecting most, and Gomez is the name left hanging in the balance. [Read more 🡒]
