Stephen Vogt’s handling of Gavin Williams in the ALCS is going to hang over the Guardians for a while.
Cleveland spent the last nine innings of its 2026 season leaning on an odd mix of arms: Shawn Armstrong opened on the mound, Joey Cantillo pitched in relief, and Cade Smith and Hunter Gaddis both allowed home runs late. Through all of that, Williams was still waiting in the dugout for a Game 7 that never arrived.
That was the plan from the moment last Friday’s rainout scrambled everything. Vogt made it plain that Williams would not be available until a potential winner-take-all game, a move that would have given the Guardians a major edge if the series had gotten that far. It didn’t, and Cleveland’s pitching staff couldn’t survive long enough to make that choice matter.
Game 4 turned into the Shawn Armstrong-led pitching chaos experiment, and it ended in a 7-3 loss after all but one reliever behind him allowed a run. Then Vogt and the rest of the Guardians’ decision-makers moved Parker Messick up to Game 5. That lasted just two innings, and from there the series started slipping away for good.
Williams’ absence still stands out because of what he was this October. In his third postseason, he posted a 2.16 ERA over 16 2/3 innings, working three starts and one relief appearance while striking out 33. He did all of that, yet he appeared only once in a six-game series that had Cleveland within reach of the World Series.
His usage was limited in part because he had thrown the final game of the American League Division Series, which kept him out until Game 3 of the ALCS. Even so, it’s tough to get past how little the Guardians got out of their best pitcher in the series that gave them their best shot to reach the World Series in a decade.
That frustration grows louder when you look at what happened around him. Cleveland allowed 17 runs over the final three games while deploying two bullpen games and leaning heavily on Matt Festa. So even if Williams’ limited role felt like a painful footnote, it wasn’t the reason the season ended there.
It also doesn’t erase what was a huge year for him. Williams led the American League with 248 strikeouts and did it in a career-high 184 1/3 innings, while trimming nearly 3% off his walk rate. With arbitration now in play and a projected $4.4 million salary, he’s about to get more expensive, though still not at a level that should push the Guardians into considering a trade yet.
He may not have been central to the ALCS plan, but he’s going to matter plenty in 2027.
In Other News...
Guardians Face Tough Free Agency Calls With Key Veterans Up Next
The Guardians are heading toward another familiar offseason crossroads, with several veterans set to hit free agency and each one carrying a different kind of value to the roster. Shawn Armstrong, Foster Griffin, Austin Hedges, and Rhys Hoskins all fit into that category of players who helped fill needs during the season, even if their futures now look increasingly uncertain as Cleveland weighs fit, performance, and long-term planning.
Armstrong appears to be the likeliest departure, while the rest of the group is drawing varying levels of outside interest as clubs look for short-term help or depth. Griffin is projected to land with the Braves, Hedges with the Rockies, and Hoskins on a minor league deal with the Athletics, leaving Cleveland with more work to do if it wants to keep any of that experience in-house. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Make Their Stephen Vogt Stance Clear Amid Seattle Buzz
Stephen Vogts name surfaced in the Seattle managerial conversation, but Cleveland moved quickly to make its position clear. Vogt confirmed he will remain with the Guardians, and team president Chris Antonetti said the club views him as under contract beyond 2027, a sign the organization is treating this as a long-term arrangement rather than a short-term stop along the way.
The bigger takeaway for Cleveland is stability. The Guardians expect continuity not just in the dugout but throughout the staff, with pitching coach Carl Willis also slated to return in 2027. For a team that has leaned on consistency to stay competitive, keeping the current structure intact matters almost as much as any offseason move. [Read more 🡒]
Steven Kwan Puts Cleveland At A Tough Offseason Crossroads
Steven Kwans status gives Cleveland one of its most interesting offseason questions, because the Guardians are staring at the final year of his club control while also weighing a future that could get expensive fast. He is projected to earn more than $11 million through arbitration in 2027, and after a strong second half in 2026, he again showed why he remains a valuable piece, even earning Gold Glove finalist recognition in center field.
For a team still trying to add more power to the lineup, the calculus is not simple. Cleveland can keep Kwan and explore an extension, or it can listen to trade interest before he gets any closer to free agency, and the speculation around him has not gone away even with his recent surge. That leaves the front office trying to balance present value, payroll concerns and the possibility that one of its most reliable players could become the centerpiece of a bigger offseason decision. [Read more 🡒]