Steven Kwan Trade Idea Gives Guardians Fans A Tough Debate

As trade discussions intensify, a proposed swap between the Guardians and Giants could significantly shift the balance with Steven Kwan at the center.

Steven Kwan keeps showing up in trade chatter, and the latest proposal sends him far from Cleveland.

Bleacher Report’s Tim Kelly included a Guardians-Giants swap on his list of five unpopular offseason trades, with Kwan going to San Francisco and infielder Casey Schmitt coming back to Cleveland. Kelly framed it as a move that could help both clubs, but it is easy to see why it would not sit well with Guardians fans.

“Buster Posey and the Giants could use Kwan’s presence in their lineup as they try to rebound from consecutive disappointing seasons. Casey Schmitt is coming off of a second half where he posted just a .582 OPS, but he still has three arbitration years before free agency and crushes lefties. Schmitt could get at-bats at a variety of positions, including first base, left field and DH for the Guardians,” Kelly wrote.

The timing is a big part of the pitch. Kwan is headed into his final arbitration year and is projected to make about $11.3 million.

Kelly also pointed out that he could be in line for a contract worth more than $100 million next winter. He noted that the Guardians seriously explored moving Kwan before the 2025 deadline, and that Chris Antonetti left the door open in October.

Antonetti said Cleveland has handled players in Kwan’s position in different ways over the years, while also saying the club expects Kwan to be a key piece of a contending team in 2027.

Kwan’s 2026 season gives the argument even more fuel. He scuffled in the first half, batting .225 with a .614 OPS, then caught fire after the All Star break.

From there, he hit .353 with an .875 OPS and finished as one of the best players in baseball. His final line: a .282 average, a .382 on-base percentage, 85 walks and 5.3 WAR.

That kind of second-half surge is exactly why a front office might consider selling high.

For the Giants, the appeal is obvious. Kelly sees Kwan fitting neatly at Oracle Park, where the massive outfield and the right-center gap known as Triples Alley would play to his strengths. Kwan is a four-time Gold Glover and was also a finalist in center field this year, so the defense comes baked in.

Schmitt, meanwhile, is the return piece that makes the deal more complicated. He has seen time at second base, shortstop, third base and first base in the majors, and San Francisco even began using him in left field this season. Kelly suggested the Guardians could deploy him at first base, in left field or at designated hitter, all spots where Cleveland could use more help.

His year followed a familiar split. Through late May, Schmitt was hitting .293 with an .866 OPS and nine home runs, which was the best mark among Giants regulars, and his hard hit rate was a career high.

Then came the downturn, and after the break he finished with a .582 OPS. Still, there is some usefulness in the profile: Schmitt owns a .715 OPS against left-handed pitching with 13 home runs, and Cleveland’s lineup struggled badly against lefties this season.

Even with that versatility, the package feels thin for a player like Kwan. He was one of the most valuable outfielders in the American League this season, and the Guardians are coming off an ALCS run. That is why Kelly’s idea lands in the unpopular category.

In Other News...

Jo Adell Just Gave Guardians Fans Another Reason To Love Him

Jo Adells first season in Cleveland gave Guardians fans plenty to latch onto. Acquired from the Los Angeles Angels during the 2026 season, he settled into a meaningful role right away and got his first taste of postseason baseball, a new stage for a player who spent the bulk of his career trying to find the right fit and the right moment.

Adell also had a memorable year away from the field, marrying Jazmine in November 2026. Between the production, the October spotlight and the personal milestone, it was the kind of season that can change how a player is viewed in a new city, even if the bigger question is still how much more there is to come. [Read more 🡒]

Emmanuel Clase Trial Puts Guardians In An Uncomfortable Spotlight

Federal court proceedings have put Emmanuel Clase and the Guardians in an uncomfortable spotlight, with prosecutors and defense attorneys both leaning on a set of text messages tied to the closers alleged role in a pitch-rigging scheme. The messages at the center of the case are being read very differently by each side, with the government saying coded references to chickens and roosters were used to conceal the operation.

Clase and two others have been charged with conspiracy and deny the allegations, leaving the case to turn on how those messages are interpreted and what they were actually meant to describe. For Cleveland, it is the kind of off-field distraction that hangs over a team even as the legal fight plays out elsewhere, with the details still being argued in court and the broader implications far from settled. [Read more 🡒]

Guardians Are Suddenly Tied To Bold Moves With One Big Catch

With the Dec. 1 deadline for owners to lock players approaching, the Guardians are suddenly being mentioned in the same breath as a few more ambitious roster ideas. Recent free-agent movement has already started to shape the market, from Emilio Pagn landing with the Tigers to the Guardians bringing in Antoine Kelly, and that backdrop has only added to the speculation around what Cleveland might try next.

The names being floated are the kind that would change the conversation around the roster, not just fill a hole. Jazz Chisholm Jr., Sonny Gray and Seiya Suzuki all bring different appeal, and each would fit the Guardians in a different way, but for now they remain exactly what they are: speculative targets. The bigger question is whether Cleveland is ready to chase that level of move, or whether the deadline arrives with more talk than action. [Read more 🡒]