Detroit infielder Kevin McGonigle took home American League Rookie of the Year honors on Monday, edging out Guardians left-hander Parker Messick and Red Sox left-hander Payton Tolle in the Baseball Writers Association of America vote.
McGonigle finished with 204 points after collecting 28 first-place votes and two second-place votes. Messick came in second with 122 points, backed by two first-place votes, 25 second-place votes, two third-place votes and one fourth-place vote. Tolle placed third with 54 points, receiving 12 third-place votes, six fourth-place votes and six fifth-place votes.
The Guardians did have other rookies draw support. Chase DeLauter finished sixth with 23 votes, including one second-place vote, while Travis Bazzana picked up one fourth-place vote.
Cincinnati’s Sal Stewart won NL Rookie of the Year.
Messick’s finish keeps Cleveland’s Rookie of the Year count at four, but his season still put him squarely in the mix. He led all AL rookie pitchers in wins, innings and ERA, then added a Cy Young finalist nod that will be decided Wednesday.
In the regular season, Messick went 12-9 with a 2.56 ERA across 32 starts. He struck out 193 batters in 186 1/3 innings, and opponents hit just .217 against him. His 193 strikeouts were the most by a Cleveland rookie since Herb Score fanned 245 in 1955, the same season Score won AL Rookie of the Year.
Messick also joined a short list with his workload and strikeout profile. He became the fourth rookie starter to work at least 150 innings with an ERA of 2.60 or lower while averaging nine or more strikeouts per nine innings, alongside Dwight Gooden in 1984, Hideo Nomo in 1995 and Jose Fernandez in 2013.
Drafted by the Guardians in the second round in 2022 out of Florida State, Messick debuted in the majors on Aug. 20, 2025 against Arizona.
His postseason line was rougher. In four starts, two against Chicago in the ALDS and two against Tampa Bay, he went 0-3 with a 3.95 ERA.
McGonigle’s first full big league season was strong enough to carry the award race. Detroit’s No. 1 pick in 2023 hit .278 with 168 hits in 605 at-bats, along with 28 doubles, five triples, 18 homers and 72 RBI in 156 games. He scored 97 runs and finished with an .806 OPS.
He split his time between shortstop and third base, playing 90 games at short and 85 at third, with five appearances as the designated hitter. The Tigers rewarded him in April with an eight-year, $150.78 million deal.
Tolle, the Red Sox’s second-round pick in 2024 out of TCU, kept his rookie eligibility despite appearing in seven games in 2025. In 26 starts, he went 9-6 with a 3.03 ERA, striking out 171, walking 40 and allowing 123 hits in 148.2 innings.
Messick’s runner-up finish adds another chapter to Cleveland’s history in the award. He became the sixth Guardian to place second in Rookie of the Year voting, joining Tanner Bibee in 2023, Francisco Lindor in 2015, CC Sabathia in 2001, Manny Ramirez in 1994 and Kenny Lofton in 1992.
Cleveland’s list of actual winners remains limited to Score, Chris Chambliss, Joe Charboneau and Sandy Alomar, with Alomar the last to do it in 1990.
McGonigle became the sixth Tiger to win the award, joining Harvey Kuenn in 1953, Mark Fidrych in 1976, Lou Whitaker in 1978, Justin Verlander in 2006 and Michael Fulmer in 2016.
In Other News...
Emmanuel Clase Case Just Took A Brutal Turn For Cleveland Fans
Federal prosecutors say Emmanuel Clase was carrying a tax burden of more than $670,000, and they now argue that debt helped drive the alleged pitch-rigging scheme that has stunned Cleveland. The Guardians closer has already been suspended and on unpaid leave since 2025 while the investigation unfolded, but the latest filing gives the case a sharper and more troubling shape for a player who was once one of the most trusted arms in the bullpen.
The charges now hanging over Clase include conspiracy to commit wire fraud, bribery and money laundering, with prosecutors saying they have evidence of coordinated pitches that benefited bettors. For Cleveland fans, the ugly part is not just the headline, but the suggestion that the alleged scheme was tied to a personal financial pressure point, turning a baseball scandal into something far bigger than a simple betting violation. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Free Agency May Come Down To One Risky Rotation Bet
The Guardians search for rotation help could end up circling back to a familiar kind of gamble: a pitcher with enough upside to matter, and enough health baggage to make the price feel just a little lighter. Michael Soroka and Nick Pivetta both fit that mold in different ways, and each would give Cleveland a chance to add a starter without paying for a truly top-of-market arm. MLB Trade Rumors and FanGraphs both see them landing in a range that would keep them within reach, which is part of what makes them so intriguing for a front office that has long believed it can help pitchers stay on the mound.
Pivetta brings the more recent track record, but his elbow history is hard to ignore, while Soroka comes with the kind of injury past that has followed him for years even as he has logged meaningful innings again. For Cleveland, the appeal is obvious: the Guardians have built a reputation for helping pitchers manage health and squeeze value out of arms other clubs might hesitate to trust. The question is whether they want to make their rotation bet on the pitcher whose ceiling looks a bit higher, or the one whose risk profile may be easier to live with. [Read more 🡒]
Travis Bazzanas Rookie Year Left Guardians Fans With A Real Debate
Travis Bazzanas rookie season gave Guardians fans plenty to chew on, even before the year was over. He made his All-Star Game debut for the American League as a defensive substitute, a nice marker for a player whose season was defined less by a single stretch than by the way he kept popping up in big moments.
The debate came from the uneven shape of the year itself. Bazzana opened strong and closed strong, but the middle months dragged down his overall Rookie of the Year case, and the BBWAA voters reflected that by placing him 10th behind teammates Parker Messick and Chase DeLauter. For Cleveland, it leaves a familiar kind of question: how much weight should be given to the flashes, and how much to the slump in between? [Read more 🡒]