Kirk Herbstreit drew immediate backlash Thursday night after weighing in on Deshaun Watson’s future with the Cleveland Browns, with many NFL fans blasting the analyst’s defense of the quarterback as “tone-deaf.”
Herbstreit addressed Watson during the Browns’ preseason finale and acknowledged the allegations that have followed him, but said he still believes in giving people another shot. “When that news broke, everybody was kind of like, ‘Whoa, what’s going on?’
Everybody was kind of surprised,” Herbstreit said. “I’m a guy that believes in everybody deserves second opportunities.”
He didn’t stop there. Herbstreit also called Watson’s move to Cleveland “one of the worst trades in the history of the NFL.”
Even so, he argued that Watson’s age and ability still make him worth another look. “I know this has been a disaster, one of the worst trades in the history of the NFL, but this is still a 30-year-old who at one point was viewed as one of the top quarterbacks in the league,” Herbstreit said.
That didn’t sit well with a lot of fans online. Two dozen women have accused Watson of sexual misconduct since 2021, including claims that he forced them to perform oral sex during massage appointments. Watson has denied wrongdoing.
The NFL also suspended Watson for the first 11 games of the 2022 season after finding that he violated the league’s personal-conduct policy. He additionally faced 10 criminal complaints in Texas, though two grand juries declined to indict him on criminal charges.
The reaction to Herbstreit was swift and angry. One fan wrote, “Being accused by dozens of women of inappropriate sexual behavior when you’re supposed to be getting a massage?
No, you don’t deserve a second opportunity. You deserve to rot in prison.
Just astonishingly tone deaf by Kirk Herbstreit.”
Another said, “This is like a 5th fucking chance so get the f out of here with that nonsense.”
A third asked, “How many women do you have to settle with out of court to no longer get a 2nd chance?”
Despite the criticism, Watson is still set to get another opportunity with Cleveland this season. Todd Monken said the Browns chose Watson as their starter after evaluating his offseason work, training camp and preseason games. “I felt like, to start the season on the road, Deshaun gave us the best chance to move the ball and score points,” Monken said.
Watson has played only 19 games since Cleveland acquired him. In that span, he has completed 61.2% of his passes for 3,365 yards, 19 touchdowns and 12 interceptions.
Now he’ll try to prove on the field that he can still deliver. Herbstreit’s comments, though, showed just how much of the fan base remains unwilling to move on from everything surrounding Watson off the field.
In Other News...
Brayan Rocchio Is Putting Cleveland In A Tough Lineup Spot
Brayan Rocchio spent the first half of the season giving Cleveland a real boost with the bat, but the second half has looked nothing like that version of him. The downturn was severe enough to send him to Triple-A in early 2025, and it has turned what once looked like a stable middle-infield situation into a much trickier decision for the Guardians as they sort out their infield plans.
Stephen Vogt now has three names in the mix for those spots, with Rocchio competing against Angel Genao and Travis Bazzana. If the offense does not turn back in Rocchios favor, Cleveland could lean toward Genao and Bazzana and leave Rocchio in a reserve role, a sharp shift for a player who not long ago seemed positioned to hold a much more prominent place in the lineup. [Read more 🡒]
Parker Messick Is Giving Cleveland Fans A New Reason To Believe
Cleveland has stayed in the thick of the race for most of the summer, with a postseason path still very much alive and the club again proving it can hang around deep into September. A big reason for that is rookie starter Parker Messick, who has quickly moved from promising arm to one of the more dependable pieces in the rotation, giving the Guardians a fresh lift as they chase another playoff berth.
Messicks rise has also pushed him into the conversation for AL Rookie of the Year, a reminder that Clevelands recent success is being driven by more than just veteran steadiness. The Guardians still have work to do in both the Wild Card hunt and the division race, but Messicks arrival has given fans something beyond the standings to watch, with the Kalshi odds reflecting just how much his season has started to matter. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Playoff Push Just Ran Into A Frustrating Defensive Problem
The Guardians playoff push took a jarring hit at Progressive Field, where a lopsided loss to Toronto was made worse by a defensive lapse from a pair of rookies. Cleveland had already been chasing the game after Dylan Cease carved through the lineup over six scoreless innings, but the bigger problem came when Joey Cantillos outing unraveled and the defense behind him could not clean it up.
A sloppy second inning turned into the kind of inning that lingers, with Travis Bazzana and Angel Genao both involved in the breakdown that opened the door for the Blue Jays to pile on. Cleveland wound up staring at an 11-0 defeat, and the frustration was not just the final score but the way the Guardians kept giving Toronto extra life when they could least afford it. [Read more 🡒]