José Ramírez has been the Guardians’ safety net for so long that the idea of him becoming part of the problem feels almost upside down. But that’s the reality Cleveland is staring at now, with a hand injury changing the conversation around its most important player.
On the latest Cleveland Baseball Talk Podcast, reporters Joe Noga and Paul Hoynes didn’t dance around it. They asked whether Ramírez, in his current physical state, is actually hurting the Guardians.
“I think this team is built for José Ramírez to drive it,” Hoynes said on the podcast. “And, you know, he just isn’t the José Ramírez that we’ve seen for the last, you know, 10, 11 years. You know, the hand injury, whatever is holding him back.”
Ramírez has been the kind of player Cleveland leans on every year - a perennial All-Star, a Silver Slugger, and one of the game’s most durable and dangerous hitters. That’s why the drop-off since his hamate bone injury has been so hard to ignore.
He suffered the injury on June 13 against the Tigers and had surgery on June 16. Since coming back, he’s hitting .214, with 12 hits in 56 at-bats, no home runs, no extra base hits and just four RBIs. For a hitter whose game is built on impact and production in big spots, those are empty numbers.
Noga pushed the issue even further on the podcast, asking the question hanging over the season: “Has he turned into, you know, a big question mark rather than the, the one sure thing that the, the Guardians can rely on?”
That isn’t a knock on Ramírez’s effort. He’s always played through pain and found ways to stay on the field. But there’s a difference between normal discomfort and an injury that changes what a player can do at the plate.
Hoynes also pointed out that the Guardians went 15-15 in the games Ramírez missed, which at least shows the team can survive without him in the lineup. Whether that says more about the club’s depth or Ramírez’s limited production now is part of the debate.
The timing only makes the issue bigger. Cleveland has 42 games left and sits two-and-a-half games behind the third wild card spot, so every inning and every run matters. That puts the possibility of another injured list stint on the table, if it means Ramírez can heal properly and come back closer to full strength.
Angel Genao’s recent arrival from Triple-A Columbus adds another wrinkle. He’s provided an offensive spark, and his emergence could give the Guardians a way to rest Ramírez without taking a major hit in the lineup.
It’s not an easy call, but as Noga noted, something may have to give.
In Other News...
Myles Straw Puts Clevelands Old Contract Mistake Back In Focus
Myles Straw is back in a familiar spotlight in Toronto, where he has a chance to work his way into the center field picture after the Blue Jays moved on from Daulton Varsho. For Cleveland fans, his name still carries a little extra weight because of the extension the Guardians handed him, a deal that now looks even more consequential as his career continues elsewhere.
The appeal remains obvious on the defensive side, but the bat has long been the sticking point, and that combination makes his situation tricky for any club trying to sort out its future roster. With Toronto weighing bigger-picture decisions for the seasons ahead, Straws place in those plans is not a simple one, and the contract attached to him keeps the old Cleveland decision very much in view. [Read more 🡒]
Chase DeLauter Sounds Off On Why Cleveland Keeps Stalling At The Plate
Clevelands offensive frustrations have become impossible to ignore over the last few weeks, and Chase DeLauter put a finger on the problem in plain language. The Guardians have been under .220 with runners in scoring position over their last 17 games, a stretch that has left too many chances sitting on the basepaths and too few runs coming across. DeLauters read is that the approach changes when the moment gets bigger, with hitters pressing and chasing pitches instead of staying simple.
He framed those spots as no different from hitting with the bases empty, where the goal is still just to find a good pitch and take a clean swing. It is a basic answer to a persistent issue, but it also speaks to why the lineup has stalled so often when the pressure rises. Until the Guardians settle back into that easier mindset, the same missed opportunities are likely to keep showing up in the box score. [Read more 🡒]