The Cleveland Guardians pulled off one of the most improbable comebacks in recent memory last season, clawing their way back from a staggering 15.5-game deficit to win the AL Central on the final day. It was the kind of late-season surge that turns clubhouses into believers and skeptics into fans. But as impressive as that run was, the front office knows there's still work to be done - and the 2026 season is shaping up to be a fascinating next chapter.
Looking ahead, one projected version of the Guardians' lineup offers a glimpse at what could be a new era of young talent taking center stage. It’s a group that blends promise with potential, and if things break right, it could be the foundation of another playoff push.
Projected 2026 Guardians Lineup:
- C: Cooper Ingle
- 1B: Kyle Manzardo
- 2B: Brayan Rocchio
- SS: Gabriel Arias
- 3B: José Ramírez
- LF: Steven Kwan
- CF: Angel Martinez
- RF: CJ Kayfus
- DH: David Fry
Let’s break it down.
Infield: Youth Movement with a Veteran Anchor
José Ramírez remains the heartbeat of this team - one of the most consistent and complete third basemen in the game. His presence alone gives the Guardians a competitive edge every night. Around him, though, we’re seeing a clear shift toward youth.
Brayan Rocchio and Gabriel Arias are penciled in up the middle, and both bring strong defensive chops. Rocchio’s range and quick release make him a natural fit at second, while Arias has the arm and instincts to handle shortstop. Kyle Manzardo at first is a bat-first option who could bring some much-needed pop to the lineup if he finds his rhythm at the plate.
Behind the plate, Cooper Ingle is an intriguing name. He’s got a higher ceiling than most catching prospects, but it’s tough to envision manager Stephen Vogt moving on from Bo Naylor without a real competition.
Let’s not forget, the Guardians also brought back veteran Austin Hedges - a clear sign they value experience behind the dish. So while Ingle might be the future, the present could still belong to Naylor, at least early on.
Outfield: Opportunity Meets Depth
Steven Kwan is locked in at left - no surprises there. He’s a steady presence at the top of the order and one of the more underrated defenders in the league.
In center and right, though, things get interesting. Angel Martinez and CJ Kayfus are both solid prospects, but they’ll have to earn their keep with some stiff competition looming.
Chase DeLauter, who made his MLB debut during the postseason, is very much in the mix. The Guardians clearly believe in his upside, and he could push for an everyday role sooner rather than later.
George Valera, meanwhile, ended last season on a high note and has the kind of bat that can’t be ignored if he stays healthy. The outfield picture is crowded, but that’s a good problem to have - and it gives Vogt plenty of flexibility depending on matchups and performance.
DH Spot: A Role for Fry
David Fry is slotted in as the designated hitter in this projection, and that feels like a logical fit. He’s a versatile piece who can play multiple positions in a pinch, but his bat is what keeps him in the lineup. If he can provide consistent power from the DH spot, it’ll go a long way toward balancing this lineup.
What About Travis Bazzana?
Keep an eye on former No. 1 pick Travis Bazzana. He’s not in this projected lineup just yet, but it’s only a matter of time before he gets his shot. His bat is advanced for his age, and if he continues to develop, he could force the Guardians to make some tough decisions in the infield.
Rotation Depth and the Bigger Picture
While this projected lineup focuses on position players, it’s worth noting that the Guardians have an enviable amount of depth in their pitching rotation. That’s been a hallmark of their identity in recent years, and it’s not going away anytime soon. The real question is whether this revamped lineup can generate enough offense to support that pitching and carry the team through another grueling AL Central race.
The Guardians proved last season that they’re never out of it. Now, with a younger, more dynamic roster taking shape, they’re hoping to avoid the need for another miracle finish. There’s a lot to like here - and even more to watch closely as spring training approaches.