Power can get a young hitter noticed fast. It can also hide a lot of problems until the competition gets tougher, and that’s the concern hanging over Guardians outfield prospect Nolan Schubart.
Schubart, 22, was Cleveland’s third-round pick in 2025 as part of a class that leaned heavily into slugging upside. The raw power is obvious. The question is whether the rest of the profile can hold up once pitchers start exploiting the holes.
That’s the part that has some evaluators uneasy. Baseball America’s J.J. Cooper pointed to Schubart’s strikeout rate as a major warning sign, even while acknowledging the damage he can do at the plate.
“Schubart is hitting .249/.406/.522. He has 21 home runs and was just promoted from High-A Lake County to Double-A Akron.
To bring in another prospect, Shelton at Low-A Ontario ranks second in the minors with 31 home runs. But Shelton has a 33% strikeout rate.
So does Schubart. Those sorts of strikeout rates are generally disqualifying for a prospect, even those with massive power production.
Therefore, history suggests that the odds of Schubart or Shelton becoming a long-term MLB player are small,” Cooper wrote.
The concern is familiar in Cleveland. The Guardians have already seen what happens when power comes with too much swing-and-miss, with Bobby Bradley serving as the cautionary example. Bradley launched 16 home runs in 74 games as a rookie in 2021, but his 35.5 percent strikeout rate eventually caught up with him and he faded as a big leaguer.
Schubart has started his Double-A run with a 198 wRC+ and two homers in his first eight games for Akron, but the strikeouts are still there. He has punched out at a 27.5 percent clip in that small sample, and his larger High-A body of work showed a 33.5 percent strikeout rate.
That’s the problem with this kind of profile. In the minors, the power can carry a player a long way.
In the majors, pitchers are better at finding the cracks. They throw harder, their breaking balls are sharper, and their command gives them more ways to attack a hitter who struggles to make consistent contact.
Schubart is still young enough to believe there’s time to clean things up. But the path forward is clear: improve the contact rate, shorten the swing, and prove the doubters wrong. If he can do that, the power becomes a weapon instead of a warning label.
In Other News...
Guardians Suddenly Linked To The Kind Of Bat Fans Have Begged For
The Guardians have been searching for a right-handed bat that can deepen the lineup, and a familiar trade partner has surfaced in that conversation. Toronto outfielder George Springer has come up as a possible fit, with his ability to handle designated hitter duties or play the outfield giving Cleveland a flexible way to add offense without forcing a bigger roster shuffle.
Financially, the idea is not quite as simple as the fit on paper. Springer is still attached to a sizable 2026 salary, and even with Toronto having already covered most of it, Cleveland may need the Blue Jays to take on more money before anything gets serious. The two clubs have done business before, including recent deals involving Shane Bieber, Miles Straw and Andres Gimenez, but for now this is still one of those rumors that hints at a move without quite crossing the finish line. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians May Have Found A Deadline Bat Fans Would Actually Feel
The Guardians have spent much of the deadline season being linked to pitching, but the more interesting possibility might be a bat that could actually change how the lineup feels in a series. In that search, one name stands out as a fit because he brings real power, positional flexibility and enough control to make him more than a rental, which matters for a club that has to be careful about every move it makes.
There are still reasons to pause before getting too excited. He has been much less effective against left-handed pitching over the past two seasons, and the defensive profile is more useful than flashy, with value spread across the outfield and designated hitter spot. Even so, the price tag could be the kind of prospect package that forces Cleveland to decide whether adding a slugger now is worth parting with a piece from its deeper young core. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians May Finally Have A Marlins Bat Worth The Risk
The Guardians have spent much of the summer weighing whether to add a bat that can actually change the shape of their lineup, and the Marlins could offer a name that fits the search. Cleveland has been linked to the idea of chasing a left-handed hitter with some real thump, the kind of player who could step into the everyday mix and give the offense a different look as the trade deadline approaches.
What makes the conversation tricky is the price. Any deal for a bat with this kind of appeal would not come cheaply, and the Guardians would likely have to decide how much prospect capital they are willing to spend for a player who could help right away. For a front office that usually prefers to protect its long-term inventory, that is the real tension here, and it is why this remains more of a possibility than a finished move. [Read more 🡒]