The rain stopped, but the Guardians’ offense never showed up.
After a delay of three hours and 11 minutes, Cleveland opened Sunday’s game against San Diego with the same problem that has followed it for much of the last two months: not enough hits, not enough runs, and not enough answers. Casey Mize carved through the lineup for six shutout innings, Tanner Bibee was bitten again by the long ball, and the Padres left Progressive Field with a 5-0 win and two of three in the series.
It was the Guardians’ 11th shutout loss of the season, and it pushed them into a tougher spot in the AL race. Cleveland has now dropped seven of its last 10 and five straight series since taking two of three from Cincinnati in late July. The loss also left the Guardians two games behind Baltimore for the third AL wild card spot.
The day started with weather and got worse when Chase DeLauter exited in the third inning with mild left hamstring tightness. DeLauter, who went 0-for-1 with a popout, had been one of Cleveland’s brightest bats lately, hitting .345 with a .919 OPS in August. He also had multiple hits in six of his previous nine games.
The Guardians did create a few early chances against Mize, but none of them turned into anything on the scoreboard. José Ramírez singled in each of his first two trips, and Nathaniel Lowe doubled with one out in the second. That was the story in miniature: traffic, but no payoff.
Cleveland came into Sunday batting .263 in August, its best monthly average of the season, yet the club had also stranded an AL-high 114 runners and hit just .227 with runners in scoring position. That gap showed up again.
Mize, who came over from Detroit at the trade deadline, allowed only three hits in six innings. He walked one, struck out three and picked up his fifth win.
Bibee’s afternoon unraveled in the second inning, and the damage came from two familiar names. Luis Rengifo and Gavin Sheets went back-to-back to put San Diego up 2-0.
Rengifo had entered the day 6-for-11 with a homer against Bibee, while Sheets was 2-for-2 with a homer and four RBI against him. Each has now homered twice off Bibee.
That home-run issue has become a season-long headache. Bibee has now allowed 25 homers, second-most in the American League behind Athletics left-hander Jeffrey Springs, who has 28.
San Diego added to the lead in the fourth. A Bibee wild pitch helped set the table, and Xander Bogaerts followed with an RBI single to make it 3-0.
Bibee did keep the Padres from blowing the game open in the sixth. With the bases loaded and one out, Freddy Fermin lined to Lowe at first, and Lowe fired to Brayan Rocchio at second to double off Rengifo. Rengifo was initially called safe after second-base umpire Shane Livensparger ruled Rocchio’s foot came off the bag, but Stephen Vogt challenged the play and the call was overturned.
Bibee finished with three runs allowed on seven hits and three walks over six innings. He struck out three and gave up the two home runs.
He entered Sunday with a 6.00 ERA in August after giving up 10 runs, eight earned, over 12 innings in his first two starts this month. He also owns a 5.73 ERA and a 1-6 record in eight interleague starts.
The Padres kept adding late. Tim Herrin gave up a solo shot to rookie outfielder Jase Bowen with two outs in the eighth, Bowen’s second career home run and the fifth allowed by Herrin this season. In the ninth, Logan Allen, recalled from Triple-A Columbus ahead of Saturday’s game, surrendered a solo homer to Jake Cronenworth.
Ramírez was one of the few Cleveland hitters to make consistent contact, finishing with two of the team’s three hits. He continues to own San Diego, now 26-for-65 (.400) against the Padres.
That was about it for the Guardians. Their offense has gone quiet at the wrong time, and after another series loss, the margin for error keeps shrinking.
Cleveland is off Monday before opening a three-game series against the Giants at Progressive Field on Tuesday. Left-hander Foster Griffin (13-4, 3.25) will start for the Guardians, while San Francisco will counter with left-hander Carson Whisenhunt (3-3, 6.11).
First pitch is set for 6:40 p.m. The game will air on Guardians TV, WTAM 1100 AM, WMMS 100.7 FM, WARF 1350 AM (Spanish) and the Guardians Radio Network.
In Other News...
Chase DeLauters Exit Leaves Guardians Facing A Brutal Offensive Question
Chase DeLauters latest run of progress hit a bump Friday night against the Padres, when the Guardians had to adjust their outfield in the third inning. Angel Martnez took over in left field and Jo Adell slid to right, a reminder of how quickly Cleveland can feel the loss of a young bat that has helped stabilize the lineup this season.
DeLauter has been one of the more important hitters on the roster, putting together a rookie campaign built around a .286 average, 13 homers and 57 RBI. Any interruption to that production matters for a Cleveland club that has leaned on his presence, and now it has to wait to learn whether the setback is only a brief pause or something that lingers longer. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Prospects Are Forcing One Big Question About Clevelands Future
MLB Pipelines latest reset of every farm system offered another reminder that Clevelands long-term outlook is still being shaped as much by young talent as by what happens in the majors. The updated rankings reflect the impact of recent draft classes and trade deadline moves, and the Guardians continue to feature a prospect group that gives the organization plenty to work with. Angel Genao, Ralphy Velazquez, Braylon Doughty, Juneiker Caceres and Cooper Ingle all stand near the center of that conversation, with the system again drawing attention for the volume of high-end upside it has assembled.
Justin Campbell is one of the more interesting names in that mix, especially after his professional debut this season pushed him from unranked to No. 10 in the Guardians system. When a player can rise that quickly, it only adds to the sense that Clevelands pipeline is still evolving and that the front office has more than a few options to consider as it looks ahead. The bigger question is how all of that talent eventually fits together, and whether the organization can turn this collection of prospects into the kind of future core that changes the shape of the roster. [Read more 🡒]
Braves Move On As Carlos Santana Faces One More Big Question
Carlos Santanas latest stop ended the way a lot of late-career baseball chapters do, with a brief stay in Triple-A and an open calendar. After being designated for assignment by the Diamondbacks earlier this season, Santana signed a minor league deal with Atlanta and played 27 games for the Braves Gwinnett affiliate, adding another familiar name to a roster that hoped his experience might still carry some value.
Now a free agent again, Santana is in familiar territory but with one important wrinkle still ahead. He can sign with another club before the postseason roster deadline, which leaves at least one more decision in front of a player who has been around long enough to know how quickly a season can turn from opportunity to uncertainty. [Read more 🡒]