CLEVELAND, Ohio - The Guardians got only one side of the postseason formula right in Game 1. They pitched well enough to stay alive, but they didn’t come close to supplying the power that usually decides October.
That left them in an early hole after Saturday’s 3-0 loss to the White Sox in the opening game of the best-of-five ALDS. Chicago’s five pitchers combined on a three-hitter, and Munetaka Murakami delivered the blow that mattered most with a two-run homer. In this kind of baseball, that’s enough.
That’s how teams win in the postseason. It’s Big Boy baseball.
Cleveland can run arms out there with the best of them when the calendar flips to October. The question is whether the lineup can match that level. Once Parker Messick gave up Murakami’s homer in the fourth, manager Stephen Vogt stuck with him for four more outs before going to the bullpen in search of a spark.
Daniel Espino, Erik Sabrowski, Hunter Gaddis, Tim Herrin and Cade Smith all got called on, but the offense never gave any of them a cushion. Sabrowski, Gaddis, Herrin and Smith are the Guardians’ top relievers, yet they never had a chance to tilt the game.
Now the pressure shifts to Monday, when the White Sox come back with another bullpen game. Anthony Kay is set to start against the Guardians, who will counter with 14-game winner Gavin Williams.
Kay worked 1 1/3 scoreless innings Saturday, so the length of his outing remains unclear. He made 31 starts during the regular season, though, which gives him a chance to go longer than a typical opener.
Sean Burke is expected to follow him. Burke faced Cleveland three times in the regular season, including two starts, and went 2-0 with a 1.04 ERA, allowing two runs in 17 1/3 innings with three walks and 21 strikeouts.
Burke described the Guardians as a team full of hitters with “different personalities who play offense as a team. They do a good job of taking advantage of mistakes.
They do a good job of taking walks. They do a good job on the bases.
“They do a lot of things that aren’t the sexy things and that’s how they win games.”
That kind of offense can work over 162 games. It doesn’t always look like the sort that survives a short October series against a pitching staff built to keep changing the picture.
The White Sox have leaned into power, too. They don’t just have one threat; they have several.
Murakami has 35 home runs, Miguel Vargas has 33 and Colson Montgomery has 31. Cleveland, meanwhile, does not have a player who began the season with the club and reached 20 homers.
Chicago has already hit four homers in three postseason games this year.
Steven Kwan said the Guardians are not seeing anything unfamiliar from the White Sox arms. The two clubs played 13 times, with Chicago winning the season series 7-6. What makes the matchup difficult, Kwan said, is the constant parade of different looks.
“It’s super difficult - that’s kind of what they’re trying to do with us, give us different angles, different looks,” said Kwan. “Thankfully we’ve seen them do that this year, so that gives us some familiarity.”
Kwan also pointed out that the Guardians would have a harder time preparing for that kind of plan against a team like the Astros, whom the White Sox beat in the wild card round, because they wouldn’t know the pitchers as well.
“But we’ve seen those (White Sox) arms during the year,” he said. “We saw what we expected from most of the pitchers, so we can have that moving forward.”
Still, knowing what’s coming and doing damage against it are not the same thing.
And that brings the spotlight to Cleveland’s biggest October question. The Guardians have one undeniable big-time hitter in Jose Ramirez, and he is limited after June surgery on his left hand. So who steps forward now?
Kwan has given the offense a lift since reclaiming the leadoff spot after the All-Star break, but he’s more of a catalyst than a finisher. Jo Adell, acquired from the Angels at the deadline, brings real pop with 23 homers and 94 RBI, yet this is his first postseason.
Nathaniel Lowe and Austin Hedges helped Texas win the World Series in 2023, but neither is an everyday force. Chase DeLauter and Travis Bazzana have had productive rookie seasons, though they’re still rookies.
That leaves Brayan Rocchio and Angel Martinez as possibilities to change the series. Rocchio has built a reputation for late-season walk-off hits, and Martinez led the Guardians with 18 home runs this year. In a best-of-five where Cleveland has to win three of the next four, the Guardians are still waiting for someone to take over the stage.
In Other News...
Guardians Send Clear Message With Urgent Game 2 Lineup Shakeup
The Guardians came into Game 2 against the White Sox with a noticeably different look, making several lineup adjustments that suggested urgency after the opener. Patrick Bailey was behind the plate and Nathaniel Lowe handled first base, while Chase DeLauter and Jo Adell were shifted into different defensive spots as Cleveland also rearranged the batting order.
Chicago answered with changes of its own, inserting Andrew Benintendi, Sam Antonacci and Tristan Peters while moving Kyle Teel up to the No. 2 spot. With both clubs altering the mix on the fly, the second game had the feel of a quick reset, with Cleveland clearly trying to spark something early and keep the series from settling into one team's preferred rhythm. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Suddenly Have A Real First Base Problem
Clevelands run to a third straight AL Central title came with plenty of familiar caveats, but first base has emerged as one of the clearest offseason questions on the roster. Kyle Manzardo looked like part of the answer after his breakout in 2025, only to stumble offensively in 2026 and wind up back in Triple-A. The Guardians responded at the trade deadline by adding Nathaniel Lowe and Jo Adell, a sign they were willing to patch the spot quickly rather than wait for the bats to come around.
Now the bigger issue is what comes next. Manzardos future in Cleveland is uncertain, and prospect Ralphy Velazquez is expected to take over first base, which puts the organization in a position it likely did not expect when the season started. The Guardians have survived roster uncertainty before, but this one has the feel of a move that could reshape how they handle the position for the long haul. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Need Jo Adell To Answer After Game 1 Exposed A Problem
Jo Adells view of Game 1 was pretty simple: the White Sox made the night feel uncomfortable from the start. Chicago kept changing pitchers and angles, and Cleveland never settled in at the plate, finishing with just three hits in a 3-0 loss that left the Guardians chasing the series before it really found a rhythm.
The good news for Cleveland is that the fix sounds familiar even if the setting is tense. The Guardians know they need a sharper approach and better work with runners in scoring position in Game 2, because dropping another one would put them in a tough 2-0 hole and make every adjustment from here on out feel a little more urgent. [Read more 🡒]