The federal case against Cleveland Guardians pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz is moving ahead on the original schedule, with a Brooklyn judge rejecting both players’ push for separate trials ahead of the Nov. 2 start date.
Judge Kiyo A. Matsumoto issued a set of rulings this week in the U.S.
Eastern District of New York that turned down the pitchers’ severance requests and also denied the government’s attempt to remove Clase’s lawyers from the case, according to court documents obtained by The Athletic. One piece of Clase’s request did get a yes: the judge agreed to split off his trial from co-conspirator Robinson Vasquez Germosen on the false-statements charge only.
Clase and Ortiz were placed on non-disciplinary paid leave in July 2025 after Major League Baseball was alerted to their alleged role in a pitch-rigging scheme that prosecutors say produced at least $450,000 in prop-bet winnings for gamblers. The allegation is that the two pitchers took bribes or kickbacks to bounce sliders in the dirt, then tried to mask what was happening by using words like “rooster” and “chickens” in their communications about the operation. Clase is known to be involved in rooster fighting in his native Dominican Republic.
Both pitchers have pleaded not guilty to four counts: conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to commit honest services wire fraud, conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery, and money laundering conspiracy. Vasquez Germosen, described as a middleman between Clase and bettors in the Dominican, faces a charge of making materially false statements to law enforcement agents.
Ortiz’s side had argued in February that a joint trial would leave him to “face severe unfair prejudice in a joint trial.” Clase’s lawyers backed that position and said severance was needed for both pitchers to get a fair hearing.
Ortiz attorney Christos N. Georgalis went further, calling Ortiz “a victim of Clase’s scheme, rather than a knowing and willing participant” and saying he intended to argue that Clase fed Ortiz’s pitching strategy to bettors without Ortiz knowing. That set up the kind of defense conflict lawyers call “mutually antagonistic.”
Georgalis also pointed to the gap in the alleged conduct. Clase is accused of rigging pitches in 48 games over three seasons, including the 2024 postseason.
Ortiz is under scrutiny for just two pitches from June 2025. Ortiz’s camp argued that Clase’s broader alleged ties to the co-conspirators could cause jurors to assume Ortiz was guilty too.
The court wasn’t persuaded. Matsumoto described Ortiz’s push as “finger-pointing” and said differences in culpability and proof are expected in conspiracy cases, not a reason to split defendants into separate trials. The judge also cited several rulings underscoring the preference for co-defendants accused of the same conspiracy to be tried together, in part to avoid inconsistent verdicts.
There was also a separate fight over defense counsel. Georgalis had said months ago that he planned to call Clase’s lawyers as exculpatory witnesses, and Clase’s camp responded that doing so would turn Ortiz into a “second prosecutor” against Clase.
Last summer, Clase’s attorneys interviewed four witnesses and gathered statements from them denying that a pitch-rigging operation existed, including Vasquez. Three of those witnesses signed declarations, but Vasquez and one other witness later recanted.
At a January hearing, Clase chose to keep his lawyers even after being advised about possible conflicts. The government later moved in April to disqualify them, but the judge said this week that step isn’t needed.
Clase and Ortiz remain on indefinite non-disciplinary leave, though a March agreement between Major League Baseball and the players’ association changed that status to unpaid. Clase, a three-time All-Star closer with a career 1.88 ERA, was slated to make $6.4 million this season. Ortiz was in line for a salary near the league minimum of $780,000.
In Other News...
Guardians Prospect Saga Took A Shocking Turn Before He Ever Signed
The Guardians thought they had lined up a promising addition when they reached a $2.8 million deal with a switch-hitting infielder known as David Severino, a player they had tracked as part of their international pipeline. Instead, an MLB investigation blew up the agreement before it ever became official, uncovering that the prospect had used fake documents and a fabricated gravesite to support a false identity and age.
What makes the situation especially jarring for Cleveland is that the club is not facing discipline, even as the player has been suspended for the fraud. Severino, whose real name is Daury David Severino Damaso, is now expected to sign for a much smaller bonus, leaving the Guardians to move on from a saga that never even reached the point of a signature. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Playoff Push Suddenly Has A New X Factor
The Guardians came home from an undefeated road trip with one month left before the postseason, and the timing only sharpened the sense that their push has a little more substance than a hot streak. Steven Kwan and Chase DeLauter have helped keep the lineup on base in August, while Parker Messick has settled in as a reliable starter with a 2.54 ERA over 33 starts, giving Cleveland a rotation piece it can actually lean on as the games start to matter more.
Even more important, the bullpen has been carrying real weight. Since August 10, it has posted a 1.52 ERA and sat near the top of several pitching categories, the kind of run that can change the entire shape of a stretch drive. For a club trying to hold momentum into September, that relief work may end up being the difference between simply hanging around and turning this into a legitimate playoff push. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Tied To Bizarre Prospect Suspension With Bigger Questions Ahead
Major League Baseballs latest international-amateur scandal has put the Guardians in an uncomfortable spotlight, even though the punishment landed on a prospect rather than the club. Dominican player David Severino was suspended after an investigation found he had falsified his age and identity, using doctored paperwork in an attempt to present himself as much younger than he really was. The case has already become one of the more bizarre recent examples of how high the stakes can be in the global signing market.
For Cleveland, the twist is that Severino had already agreed to a pre-deal with the organization before the suspension changed the picture. The delay now leaves the Guardians waiting on a player whose path to the international amateur market has been pushed back, while the broader questions around verification and enforcement linger well beyond this one signing. [Read more 🡒]