Gabriel Arias has all the tools to thrive in today's MLB landscape. With a cannon for an arm, a versatile glove, and a swing capable of launching balls into the stratosphere, he seems to have it all. Yet, the missing piece in his early career has been the consistency required to secure a spot as an everyday player.
This spring is pivotal for the 26-year-old Arias. With no minor league options left, the Guardians face a crucial decision: keep him on the roster or risk exposing him to waivers.
It’s not just about Arias, though. The Guardians also have to decide if fellow middle-infielder Brayan Rocchio, who is in a similar situation, can make the cut for the 2026 season.
Arias' journey has been hampered by a lack of plate discipline, leading to too many strikeouts. Last season, he had the lowest contact rate and highest strikeout rate among players with over 400 at-bats. That’s a tough stat to overlook, especially with promising talents like Juan Brito and Travis Bazzana waiting for their shot.
The Guardians' roster decisions became even more complex over the weekend with the signing of Rhys Hoskins to a minor league deal, likely paving his way to the big league roster. This move tightens the bench spots, making Arias’ position even more precarious.
Arias’ ability to play multiple positions might buy him some time, but he’s the likely candidate to be cut when the Guardians decide to bring up Bazzana and Brito. Both prospects have shown their potential this spring-Bazzana hit a homer against the Dodgers, and Brito followed with one against the Mariners.
While it’s unlikely the Guardians will make a decision on Arias before spring training ends, players in his situation often find themselves on the chopping block if they struggle into April. Arias and Rocchio ended last season as key figures in the Guardians' lineup, but as 2026 begins, their positions are anything but secure. Watching how this unfolds will be one of the most intriguing storylines in the Guardians’ camp this spring.