The Guardians keep circling the same question in center: who is actually next?
For now, Steven Kwan is the cleanest answer, and probably the most practical one. He’s still the player most likely to hold the spot in 2027, but that comes with a built-in deadline. Kwan is set to hit free agency after the 2027 season, which means the Guardians either extend him, ride out his final year and take the comp pick, or start looking elsewhere before then.
An extension would not come cheap. The source here makes it clear the Guardians are not going to go anywhere near $20 million per year for Kwan, and even $15 million annually feels doubtful.
A deal in the range of 6/$75-80M, though, is described as realistic if Kwan is willing to think long term and value comfort. The risk is obvious: if his body breaks down and he can no longer be an elite defensive outfielder, his value drops fast.
At the plate, he’s already turned his contact-heavy style into something that works, and there’s a belief that another club would pay for that in free agency. The bigger question is whether the Guardians should be the ones to do it.
If they don’t, the internal options get messy in a hurry.
Petey Halpin and Kahlil Watson are both in the mix as defense-first, speed-first centerfield candidates, and both come with the same glaring issue: the bat may not carry them. Halpin is 24 and has an 87 wRC+ against righties, which sounds like the shape of his offensive profile.
Watson, 23, still has some upside, but he’ll need to tighten up a 36% chase rate and a 77% zone-contact rate in the majors to get closer to the 26% chase rate and 82% zone-contact rate he’s shown at Triple-A. He also looks unlikely to be much against lefties, which means the glove would have to do a lot of heavy lifting.
The source even says it wouldn’t be surprising if the Guardians traded Kwan in November and gave Watson the first shot in center in 2027, while also admitting that experience probably wouldn’t be fun for anyone. Halpin, meanwhile, is viewed more as a clear fourth or fifth outfielder than a long-term answer.
Aaron Walton is the name with the most momentum. The 22-year-old is in Double-A and has a 124 wRC+ with a 23.7/14.4 K/BB%.
He hits the ball hard, handles center well, and bats right-handed. Contact remains the issue, with a 77% contact rate, but there’s real progress there: his swinging-strike rate has dropped in his second year as a pro and is down to 8.3% in Akron.
If that holds and the power he showed in A-ball starts showing up more consistently, he could force his way to Columbus and then into the picture for 2027. He’s also producing as a pulled-air hitter and has even splits against righties and lefties.
Still, the source is careful not to oversell him. The contact concerns have been there since he was drafted, and he still has more to prove.
Jaison Chourio is another possibility, even if the case is more developmental than immediate. He’s 21, has a 107 wRC+ at Akron, and is posting a 20.4/13.7 K/BB% with a 79% contact rate and an 8.9% swinging-strike rate.
He’s more of a line-drive, ground-ball hitter than a power bat, and the read here is that he probably can stick in center, which is his clearest route to the majors. He looks better from the left side, though he has shown enough against left-handed pitching to make switch-hitting a viable MLB option.
The source says plainly that it is not especially high on Chourio, but his age keeps him in the conversation, and a breakout this season or next would change the picture quickly.
There’s also a more complicated route involving Angel Genao or Travis Bazzana, but that path depends on position shuffling elsewhere. If Brayan Rocchio remains the shortstop of the future, then Genao or Bazzana would have to move.
Bazzana’s arm is viewed as a poor fit for center, though the source notes the Guardians have used players like Kipnis out there before. Genao could handle center, but it would probably take away from his value as a middle infielder.
If Rocchio’s second half keeps going badly, the source suggests he could slide into a utility role while Genao and Bazzana form the double-play pairing. Another possibility is Bazzana moving to left while Rocchio and Genao stay up the middle.
Even so, neither player is seen as a likely centerfield solution, despite both having the speed and athleticism to make it work. Only Genao has the arm.
And then there’s the outside market, which the source basically dismisses as fantasy. Centerfielders are expensive to acquire and sign, so free agency does not look like the answer. Daulton Varsho is mentioned as the best option there, while Jose Siri and Oneil Cruz are floated as trade ideas, with the obvious warning that hoping for a repeat of this season is a dangerous bet.
So the picture is pretty simple: the Guardians are probably best off keeping Kwan through 2027 and letting the rest sort itself out. By the end of that season, they can hope Watson, Walton or Chourio has made a real case to inherit centerfield.
In Other News...
Guardians Power Problem Keeps One Old Trade Looking Even Worse
Power has been one of the biggest question marks around Cleveland for a while, so it is hard not to look back at the November 2021 deal that sent Junior Caminero to Tampa Bay in exchange for Tobias Myers. At the time, it was the sort of prospect-for-pitching swap front offices make all the time, but the gap between the two players has only grown since then.
Caminero has since emerged as one of the American Leagues most dangerous power bats, breaking through as a full-time major league regular in 2024 and giving the Rays the kind of middle-of-the-order threat the Guardians can only wish they had more often. Myers, meanwhile, never found much traction in Cleveland and is now in Triple-A with the Mets, which leaves this trade looking like another painful reminder of how much value can disappear when a young slugger gets dealt before the breakout arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Former Guardians Outfielder Just Got Another Shot To Finally Break Through
Johnathan Rodrguez is getting another chance to push his way back into the picture, this time with the Athletics, who claimed the outfielder off waivers from the Pirates and sent him to Triple-A Las Vegas. For a player who has already been designated for assignment by both the Guardians and Orioles this year, the move keeps him in the game and in front of a club that suddenly has room to look for help.
Oaklands outfield injuries could make this a more meaningful landing spot than a typical waiver stop. Rodrguez still has to do the work in Las Vegas, but the path is a little clearer now, and the next stretch could determine whether this becomes just another transaction on his resume or the opening he has been waiting for. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Suddenly Have A Depth Problem They Cant Yet Explain
Rhys Hoskins landing on the injured list with a back injury was the latest reminder that Clevelands margin for error is getting thinner by the day. The Guardians answered by bringing up David Fry to take his roster spot, but the move came amid a broader injury picture that has started to nibble at the teams depth in a real way. Jo Adell has been working back from a lower-body issue, while Chase DeLauter is also dealing with one and is expected back soon.
For a club that has leaned on versatility and roster flexibility, the concern now is less about one absence than the possibility of a chain reaction. Cleveland is already looking at possible reinforcement options such as Daniel Schneemann, Kahlil Watson and Cooper Ingle if the outfield situation worsens, which tells you how quickly the conversation has shifted from filling one hole to preparing for more. The Guardians do not have a full-blown emergency yet, but the next injury might force them into a harder decision than theyd prefer. [Read more 🡒]