The Cleveland Guardians do not have the luxury of waiting around this winter. The offseason is already moving, the market is thinning, and with the collective bargaining agreement set to expire on Dec. 1, a lockout could shut down free agency and trades for a stretch that could last weeks or even months.
Chris Antonetti has already said payroll will go up in 2027, and Cleveland has been connected to a number of available players. The challenge now is separating the fits from the noise.
Two needs stand out above everything else: a starting pitcher and a right-handed bat at first base.
The pitching search comes first, and it has to. Antonetti has already made clear that adding a starter is a priority, and the rotation needs help.
Foster Griffin worked 172 2/3 innings this season and is expected to sign elsewhere. Behind Gavin Williams and Parker Messick, there are plenty of questions.
Tanner Bibee had an uneven year, Joey Cantillo’s command faded late, and Daniel Espino has managed only 15 1/3 big league innings after years of injuries.
The free-agent board still has a few names that fit Cleveland’s budget, but the list is shrinking. Dustin May was one of the Guardians’ known targets, but he signed a three-year, $52.5 million deal with the White Sox on Nov.
- That stings twice over: not only did Cleveland lose a target, but he landed with the club it edged for the division title.
One name that still makes a lot of sense is Casey Mize. He put up a 2.70 ERA in 16 starts for Detroit before fading badly in San Diego, and he has been especially effective against Cleveland, carrying a 2.41 ERA in six career starts against the Guardians.
Nick Pivetta is another option worth watching. He finished sixth in NL Cy Young voting in 2025, then an elbow injury wiped out most of this year, which could keep his price in range.
There’s also the trade route, and that may be the most practical one if Cleveland wants control without a long-term commitment. The farm system is deep, the infield is crowded, and the Guardians could use that surplus to chase a controllable starter. Young players such as Kyle Manzardo or Ángel Genao could be part of a package if the front office decides to go that direction.
The other glaring hole is at first base, where Cleveland needs a right-handed presence. The lineup was short on power and production overall, finishing 24th in runs scored and 27th in home runs, and it leans heavily left-handed.
Nathaniel Lowe and Rhys Hoskins are both free agents, while Manzardo hit just .215 this season. Ralphy Velazquez remains the long-term answer, but he is only 21 and has not reached the majors yet.
Ty France looks like the cleanest bridge option. He hit .295 with 21 home runs, posted an .865 OPS and produced 4.5 WAR for San Diego this season.
He also won a Gold Glove at first base in 2025. Cleveland is reportedly one of several teams that make sense for him, and he could split time between first base and designated hitter with Velazquez while giving the lineup a right-handed bat to pair with Jo Adell.
The Guardians do have some flexibility. Their 40-man roster sits at 39 after David Fry was non-tendered, which leaves room for one addition before the club has to clear space. That makes a trade involving multiple young players even more realistic.
But the bigger point is simple: the clock is ticking. The White Sox have already made their move, and every other AL Central club is trying to get better too.
Cleveland will enter 2027 as the team to beat in the division. If it wants to stay there, it needs to add an arm and a bat before the winter runs out.
In Other News...
David Frys Guardians Exit Feels Worse Than Fans Expected
David Frys run with Cleveland ended in a way few around the club probably saw coming. After a breakthrough 2024 season that included an All-Star nod and one of the most memorable swings in recent postseason memory, the Guardians non-tendered him ahead of the arbitration deadline, sending him into free agency and closing the door on a player who had quickly become part of the teams recent identity.
The move makes sense only in the coldest roster-building terms, because Frys value had already been complicated by the arm injury that led to UCL surgery and changed the shape of his season. He returned in 2026 but never got back on track offensively, even with an arbitration projection of $1.9 million, leaving Cleveland to make a difficult call on a player whose peak felt like it arrived fast and faded even faster. [Read more 🡒]
Cade Smith May Be Headed For An Honor Cleveland Fans Didn't Expect
Cade Smith came up just short in the first year of a new leaguewide honor, finishing behind Louis Varland for the inaugural AL Reliever of the Year award. Even so, the Guardians closer put together a season that kept him in the conversation all the way through the vote, working to a 1.95 ERA with 107 strikeouts in 74 innings while also handling the postseason stage with the kind of poise Cleveland has come to expect from him.
Now Smith may be in line for a different kind of recognition, one that would resonate well beyond the bullpen. He is considered a leading candidate for the Tip ONeill award, which goes to the top Canadian-born MLB player, and his combination of production and character has put him squarely in the mix for an honor Cleveland fans probably did not have on their radar at the start of the year. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Suddenly Have A David Fry Question Kody Huff Could Answer
The Guardians have quietly added another layer to their roster puzzle by bringing in catcher and utility prospect Kody Huff from the Rockies in the Cal Quantrill deal and placing him on the 40-man roster. It is the kind of move that can get lost in the shuffle of a pitching trade, but it matters because Cleveland has been searching for dependable depth behind the plate and around the infield, especially from a player who can move between jobs without forcing a roster reshuffle.
David Frys path has become part of that conversation after his struggles in recent seasons following Tommy John surgery, and his hold on the utility catcher role no longer looks as secure as it once did. Huffs versatility and his work in Triple-A Columbus give the Guardians a possible next option if they decide to move in a different direction, leaving a familiar question hanging over the roster as spring approaches. [Read more 🡒]
