The Guardians are once again staring at the non-tender market as a place to find help, and the appeal is obvious: this is where smart teams scoop up players who become available because their arbitration price tag no longer fits.
That kind of shopping trip has long made sense in Cleveland. It’s a familiar lane for a front office that has built real value from modest moves.
But heading into Friday’s deadline, the bigger question isn’t whether bargains exist. It’s whether bargains are enough when the rest of the division is making louder, more expensive plays.
On the Cleveland Baseball Talk Podcast, Joe Noga and Paul Hoynes walked through the club’s priorities, and the list starts with pitching. Hoynes said the Guardians need both starters and relievers, plus a right-handed bat to help offset a lineup that leans heavily left.
Those two areas are the non-negotiables as Cleveland looks ahead to 2027, even if the roster can be shuffled in plenty of different ways.
There are some intriguing pitching names in the non-tender pool. Noga mentioned Luis Gil, the former AL Rookie of the Year with the Yankees, along with Tanner Houck of the Red Sox and Grayson Rodriguez, who was recently with the Angels. Rodriguez comes with injury questions, but the kind of low-commitment deal that lets a team stash him in Triple-A if needed could make sense.
The most interesting name, though, might be Lucas Erceg. The Royals reliever could be on the move, and Hoynes made it clear why that caught his attention.
“It surprises me that Kansas City would non-tender him,” Hoynes said. “I wonder if he’s healthy. But that’s an interesting guy to me - especially when you consider how much the back end of Cleveland’s bullpen gets used.”
That’s where the fit becomes easy to see. Cleveland’s late-inning arms were worn down by the time the ALCS wrapped up, and a proven reliever available at a projected $2.3 million is exactly the sort of move the Guardians have been willing to make work.
The right-handed bat search brought up a different set of names. Hoynes pointed to Jake Burger, a power hitter who has moved between Miami and Texas and has done damage against Cleveland. Noga added Mark Vientos from the Mets and Luke Raley, a left-handed bat with the ability to handle the outfield or first base.
Still, the larger concern hung over the whole discussion. Noga put it plainly:
“My big issue right here is are we getting too comfortable with the Guardians shopping in the clearance aisle when it comes to adding pieces here while their division rivals are going out there and making bigger moves and making headline moves during this offseason,” he said.
That’s the offseason tension Cleveland has to live with. The non-tender market can be efficient, and it can absolutely produce useful players.
But it doesn’t look much like the kind of splashy talent that rivals can land elsewhere. Sonny Gray isn’t a non-tender cut.
Bryce Miller isn’t either. At some point, the Guardians have to decide whether the bargain rack is enough.
In Other News...
Guardians May Have Escaped A Gabriel Arias Roster Headache
When Cleveland designated Gabriel Arias for assignment on Aug. 5 to clear room for Angel Genao, it looked like the kind of roster decision that could come back around quickly. Arias had only brief stops with the Mets and Cubs after leaving the Guardians, and his path through the second half never really settled into anything firm enough to make him a safe bet for a long-term spot.
Now the Cubs appear to be weighing him as a non-tender candidate, which only adds to the uncertainty surrounding his place for next season. For the Guardians, it is a reminder that a move made to open space for a younger infielder may have also spared them from having to make a more complicated call later on. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Trade Chatter Just Put Clevelands Outfield Crunch In Focus
The Guardians crowded outfield picture has made Angel Martinez a name worth watching, and a recent trade proposal only sharpened that conversation. In the idea floated by an analyst, Cleveland would send Martinez to the Phillies in exchange for reliever Orion Kerkering and pitching prospect Gage Wood, a swap built around two clubs trying to patch different roster needs while also managing their young talent.
It is still just speculation, not a report of confirmed talks, but it does underline the kind of roster squeeze Cleveland is dealing with. Martinezs value is tied not only to what he can do on the field, but also to how the Guardians choose to balance depth, upside and pitching help as they sort through an outfield logjam that could shape the rest of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Infield Race Just Got More Interesting For One Roster Holdover
Milan Tolentinos place in the Guardians organization got a little more secure when Cleveland added him to the 40-man roster on Oct. 30 to keep him from reaching minor league free agency. Now hes trying to keep building on that momentum in winter ball, where he opened his season with Naranjeros de Hermosillo in the Mexican Pacific League by reaching base twice and driving in a run.
For a club that is always sorting through infield depth, Tolentino remains an interesting name because he brings more than just one defensive home. He has played multiple infield and outfield spots, and his recent minor league seasons have shown a blend of power and speed that makes him worth watching as the Guardians weigh their options for the roster ahead. [Read more 🡒]
