CLEVELAND, Ohio - The Guardians’ season ended Monday night the way so many of their October games felt: with the offense going quiet and the bullpen finally running on fumes.
Tampa Bay finished off a 7-3 win to close out the American League Championship Series in six games, and the late innings told the story. Cade Smith came in during the seventh with Cleveland down 3-1, but Junior Caminero turned on a splitter that floated into the zone and blasted it off the left-field foul pole for a two-run homer. That stretched the Rays’ lead to 5-1.
Cleveland scratched across two runs in the top of the eighth to make it 5-3, but the comeback never got any closer. Hunter Gaddis entered in the bottom half, and Yandy Diaz answered with a two-run shot that slammed the door.
The Guardians had actually taken a 2-1 lead in the series before dropping the last three games. Over those three losses, they managed just seven runs total.
They scored more than three runs only once in the entire series, and they finished 7-for-37 with runners in scoring position. That was the difference, plain and simple: they didn’t hit.
Tampa Bay, meanwhile, looked every bit like the stronger club. The Rays finished the regular season 98-64, best in the American League, and then swept the Yankees in three games in the AL Division Series. Cleveland had its chances, but the better team moved on.
Even getting this far was a pretty remarkable run. In early September, the Guardians were six games behind the White Sox in the Central Division.
Then they caught Chicago, won the division, and did it again in the postseason. They dropped the first two games of the division series at Progressive Field, then ripped off three straight, including two in Chicago, to advance.
But once Cleveland reached Tampa Bay, the energy seemed to drain out of the final three games. The club has long fought to score consistently, and that issue showed again. This time, though, the pitching strategy became part of the conversation too.
The Guardians entered the series believing they had two dependable starters in Parker Messick and Gavin Williams. Messick went five innings in Game 2 and allowed three unearned runs.
Williams gave up two runs in five innings in Game 3. Beyond that, Foster Griffin gave them four innings in Game 1, while the rest of the staff was pieced together around bullpen work.
Tampa Bay, by contrast, took a more traditional route with its starters. In five of six games, the Rays’ starter worked at least 5 1/3 innings. Three of those starts went at least six innings.
Cleveland tried to manage things differently. Tanner Bibee was not used as a starter, and Joey Cantillo was viewed as a relief weapon because of what he had done in the regular season. In four relief appearances totaling 15 innings, he allowed one run, which is why the Guardians wanted him as a bulk option out of the bullpen.
Game 6 brought that plan into focus. Shawn Armstrong started.
Tim Herrin followed as the first reliever. Then came Matt Festa.
Watching that unfold, it was hard not to wonder whether the Guardians were asking too much from a bullpen that had already been stretched thin.
Smith and Gaddis had both been used heavily all postseason, appearing in nine of Cleveland’s 11 postseason games. By Monday night, they looked spent. Smith’s appearance in the seventh and Gaddis’ in the eighth were reminders of just how much the club had leaned on them to get through October.
Shawn Armstrong did give the Guardians a strong one-inning outing, and Messick’s five-inning effort in Game 2 stood out. An exhausted Messick only managed two innings in Game 5, bringing his season total to 200 innings, a pro career high.
Still, the bottom line remained the same. The Guardians lost the series because they couldn’t hit enough, and because the bullpen they kept asking to carry the load eventually wore down.
In Other News...
Guardians Turn To An Unexpected Arm In Must Win Game 6
With their backs against the wall in Game 6, the Guardians are making a less conventional call on the mound by turning to right-hander Shawn Armstrong as the opener. It is the kind of move that speaks to the urgency of the moment, especially with the series slipping and Cleveland looking for any edge it can find against a Rays club that has been getting strong pitching at the right time.
Tampa Bay brings plenty of confidence into the matchup after Drew Rasmussen followed up with another dominant postseason showing in Game 5, while Freddy Peralta is lined up to get the ball for Game 6 after settling in quickly since arriving. Cleveland, meanwhile, is still trying to rebound from Parker Messick's rough recent start, and the Guardians' choice to hand the first inning to Armstrong only adds another layer of intrigue to a game they simply cannot afford to waste. [Read more 🡒]
Parker Messick Sent A Defiant Message Guardians Fans Will Love
Parker Messicks two innings in Game 5 were only a small part of a night that left the Guardians in a tough spot, as the Rays pulled out a 3-1 win and moved within one victory of the World Series. Even so, the young pitcher did not sound rattled after the loss, and his postgame message carried the kind of edge Cleveland fans tend to appreciate when the season is hanging in the balance.
The Guardians now head to Tropicana Field needing to win both remaining games to keep their postseason run alive, a steep ask against a Rays club that has already taken control of the series. Messicks confidence after his early exit offered a reminder that the mood inside the clubhouse is still pointed toward a comeback, even with the margin for error gone. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Took A Risk With Parker Messick In The Worst Spot
The Guardians made a notable change behind the plate in Game 5 of the American League Championship Series, pairing Parker Messick with Patrick Bailey instead of Austin Hedges for the first time. It was the kind of move that spoke to the moment as much as the matchup, with manager Stephen Vogt leaning on Baileys strong bat while accepting the possibility that it could alter the rhythm Messick had built with his usual catcher.
It proved to be a tough night for the rookie. Messick got through only two innings and allowed two runs, and Cleveland never quite recovered in a 3-1 loss to the Tampa Bay Rays. In a postseason game where every small edge matters, the Guardians took a calculated swing on catching alignment, and the result only sharpened the question of whether the risk was worth it in the biggest spot. [Read more 🡒]