Francisco Lindor’s name is back in the conversation in Cleveland, but the idea of a reunion still feels like a long shot.
The former Guardians star, who became the face of the franchise after his MLB debut in 2015 and stayed that way through 2020, was traded to the Mets in 2021 as Cleveland moved before he could reach free agency and command a massive payday. Lindor then signed a 10-year, $341 million deal in New York.
Now the landscape looks very different. Five and a half years later, the Mets are sitting last in the NL East, while the Guardians are fighting for the top of the AL Central. That contrast has led to some speculation that New York could listen if the right offer came along, even if Lindor’s contract, his age of 32, and the rest of the situation make a deal highly unlikely.
At 92.3 The Fan, that possibility sparked a split reaction between two analysts.
“If the Guardians were one of the teams that got in on this, there’d be a part of me that would embrace the idea that Frankie comes back…but, face value, I’m not interested,” Nick Wilson said.
“You’re not interested in Lindor? Bring him here…I can’t sign up quick enough,” Jonathan Peterlin replied.
Lindor’s recent performance only adds more layers to the discussion. He is just a few months removed from hamate bone surgery, an injury that can sap power at the plate.
A year ago, he was coming off a strong season in which he hit .267/.346/.466 with 31 home runs and a 129 wRC+. This year, in 35 games, he has hit .210/.297/.355 with four homers and an 85 wRC+.
Even so, the broader view is that the bat should come around. Lindor is still in his prime, remains athletic, and has the track record and motivation to rebound. The real obstacle for Cleveland is the money.
The Guardians would not be eager to take on a 32-year-old making more than $30 million annually, especially with a lockout on the horizon. Even if the Mets were willing to cover half the salary to improve the return package, the deal would still be a major stretch.
The emotional pull is obvious. A Jose Ramirez-Lindor infield reunion would be a tempting storyline. But as things stand, the Guardians appear more likely to stay with Brayan Rocchio and use their resources elsewhere, possibly in the outfield or the bullpen.
In Other News...
Another Guardians Outfielder Just Became A Casualty Of Cleveland's Youth Shift
Stuart Fairchilds brief run with Cleveland is over after the Guardians designated the outfielder for assignment and he later elected free agency when he went unclaimed on outright waivers. The move fits the clubs broader roster churn, one that has increasingly tilted toward younger outfield options as the Guardians keep reshaping the edges of the roster.
Fairchild now has another path forward, but his departure also underscores how little room there is for veteran depth pieces when Cleveland is trying to clear space for the next wave. The Guardians have continued to lean into that youth movement in the outfield, and Fairchild became the latest casualty of it. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Draft History Looks Even Worse Than Fans Remember
For a franchise that has spent years trying to build through the draft, the Guardians history of first- and early-round swings looks rougher when revisited in one place. A review of five of the organizations biggest misses puts a harsh spotlight on how little Cleveland got back from several premium picks, especially when those players never turned into real trade chips either. Bradley Zimmers injury-plagued run, Jeremy Sowers quick fade after arriving as a high pick, and Carson Tuckers inability to establish himself all fit the same frustrating pattern.
Tuckers case is especially stark because his time in the system ended with a .164 batting average in 73 minor league games before Cleveland moved on. Add in the broader track record around those other picks, and it becomes clear why this part of the Guardians draft history still lingers with fans. The organization has had plenty of success stories to point to over the years, but these misses are a reminder that not every promising name in June turns into help in October, or even much help at all. [Read more 🡒]