David Fry’s journey back to the catcher’s spot for the Cleveland Guardians is nothing short of inspiring. The last time Fry donned the catcher’s gear was back in July 2024, before Tommy John surgery on his throwing elbow sidelined him.
Fast forward to June 2025, Fry re-entered the MLB scene, but only as a designated hitter. With a 63 wRC+ over 157 plate appearances, it was clear he wasn’t in his prime form, especially compared to his standout seasons in 2023 and 2024.
Now, Fry is on a mission to prove he’s more than just a bat. He’s eager to showcase his skills behind the plate once again.
Sunday’s game was a pivotal moment for him, as he got the chance to test his arm against the Texas Rangers. Though his throw to pick off Jeff McNeil didn’t result in an out, the act itself was a victory for Fry, signaling a return to normalcy.
“It felt great to throw without restrictions,” Fry shared, reflecting the relief and excitement of being back in action. Despite a .167 batting average in spring training, his performance as a catcher was a significant step forward in his recovery.
The Guardians are looking at a competitive situation behind the plate, with Fry, Bo Naylor, and Austin Hedges all vying for time. For Fry, the key will be finding his rhythm at the plate to secure more innings as a catcher. Now, 16 months post-surgery, the Guardians are hoping Fry can recapture his 2024 form and help them make a push in the AL Central.