The Cleveland Guardians are boasting some impressive depth on offense this season, with a roster that's versatile across the board-except in the middle infield. The outfield lineup is particularly intriguing, featuring all-around talent Steven Kwan, star prospect Chase DeLauter, and the promising George Valera.
September standout CJ Kayfus is ready to make his mark, while Nolan Jones is eyeing a bounce-back season. Angel Martinez, known for his prowess against lefties, is expected to be a key part of the mix, possibly in a platoon role.
Behind the plate, Austin Hedges serves as the backup for starting catcher Bo Naylor. Rhys Hoskins adds another power threat for the first base and designated hitter roles alongside Kyle Manzardo. And, of course, Jose Ramirez holds down the fort as the starting first baseman.
But where does that leave David Fry?
Fry is certainly in the mix, at least as long as he's on the roster. His 2024 performance, featuring a 129 wRC+ and defensive versatility, gives him some leeway. However, he'll need to find his swing soon.
After undergoing Tommy John surgery in October 2024, Fry's 2025 season was hampered, resulting in a 63 wRC+ and a concerning 36.9 percent strikeout rate. Now expected to return to a multi-positional role in 2026, including time behind the plate, Fry's offensive production will be crucial.
As of Tuesday's spring game against the San Francisco Giants, Fry's .105 batting average and 17 wRC+ in Cactus League play are cause for concern. It's been nearly a year and a half since his surgery, so the rust needs to come off fast.
Even if he finds his form at the plate, Fry's playing time hinges on the performance of his teammates. If the outfield trio is hitting well and both Manzardo and Hoskins are on fire, opportunities could be limited. Fry will need to earn his spot with consistent, strong performances.
Injuries are always a factor, potentially opening doors for Fry. Even if the team stays healthy, he'll likely get occasional starts behind the plate and some opportunities in the outfield or as a DH each week. Ultimately, Fry's future in the lineup will be determined by what he can deliver with the bat.