Parker Messick had the kind of first three innings a rookie dreams about in October. Then the game stopped on him, and the White Sox made him pay.
In his first career postseason start Saturday, the Guardians left-hander was sharp early at Progressive Field, piling up six strikeouts while allowing just a walk and a single through three innings. He was doing exactly what Stephen Vogt said he liked most about him before the game.
“I love that he pushes the pace,” Vogt said. “I love he attacks the strike zone. He’s got six weapons, and he’s not afraid.”
But the rhythm Messick built disappeared during a long bottom of the third. White Sox starter Hagen Smith lost the zone and walked three straight Guardians with two outs to load the bases.
Smith and reliever Bryan Hudson needed 30 pitches to get through the inning as Cleveland sent six hitters to the plate and came away empty. The frame stretched past 17 minutes, followed by an extended playoff television break, and Messick was left cooling off after settling in so well.
When he came back out for the fourth, the edge was gone.
Miguel Vargas opened the inning with a single to left on a 2-1 fastball that stayed over the plate. One pitch later, Munetaka Murakami jumped on a first-pitch 93.4 mph sinker that leaked too far inside and launched it 440 feet into the right-field seats. Just like that, Chicago had a 2-0 lead in a game it would win 3-0.
It was Murakami’s first career postseason homer, and it was the second time he had taken Messick deep this season.
Murakami had also homered off him at Rate Field on Aug. 8 in an 8-2 Guardians win, when he drove an 0-1 four-seam fastball 406 feet to center field for his 25th homer of the year. He finished the regular season with 35.
The matchup had the feel of a real test, and Messick said Friday he expected exactly that after seeing Chicago so often during the season.
“I’ve got just as much information on them as they do on me, so I think it’s just best stuff on best stuff and whoever executes more pitches is going to win and whoever hits more mistakes is going to win,” Messick said Friday.
Murakami got the mistake.
Cleveland threatened again in the fourth, sending six more batters to the plate and loading the bases with two outs, but Brayan Rocchio lined out to right and the Guardians stranded everyone. Messick then came back for the fifth, got one out, and was lifted after Colson Montgomery singled. Daniel Espino entered and got Chase Meidroth to ground into an inning-ending double play.
Messick’s final line: 4 1/3 innings, four hits, two earned runs, two walks and six strikeouts. The only damage came from Murakami’s homer.
He had the kind of October debut that showed plenty of poise, but one bad sequence ended up defining it. That was especially true after the long wait between innings, the exact kind of pause Messick had tried to guard against when he talked before the series about keeping himself under control.
“One pitch at a time,” Messick said. “I’m going to have natural adrenaline. ... I’m just going to slow myself down one pitch at a time, execute, execute, execute.”
In Other News...
Jo Adell Sends Guardians A Clear Message After Flat ALDS Opener
The Guardians opened the American League Division Series with a flat afternoon, managing only three hits and no runs in a Game 1 loss to the White Sox. It was the kind of start that can linger if a club lets it, but Cleveland now has little choice but to reset quickly with Game 2 set for Monday at Progressive Field.
Jo Adells day was part of the frustration, as he went 0-for-4 with four strikeouts before speaking to the media and urging the team to move on from the opener. For a Guardians group that already knows how thin the margin is in October, the message is simple enough: one rough game does not decide a series, but the next one can quickly change the mood. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Have A 20-Year-Old Shortstop Fans Need To Watch
Welbyn Francisca is already turning heads again, and the Guardians 20-year-old shortstop prospect wasted little time making noise in the Arizona Fall League. On Opening Day, he went 5-for-5 with a double, a home run, three runs scored, three RBIs, a walk and a stolen base, the kind of all-around showing that reminds people why his rise through the system has moved so quickly.
Francisca spent the 2026 minor league season proving he can impact games at every stop, batting .272 with 19 home runs and 53 RBIs across multiple levels despite missing time because of injury. For Cleveland, the appeal is obvious: a young infielder with a fast track, real pop and the chance to keep showing he belongs against advanced competition in the Fall League. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians May Be Headed For A Costly 2027 Roster Squeeze
Projected arbitration salaries for the Guardians 2027 roster are already hinting at a future squeeze, with MLB Trade Rumors projecting Steven Kwan and Jo Adell among the teams highest earners. It is still early to treat any of it as fixed, since these numbers are speculative and tied to current performance and arbitration eligibility, but they offer a glimpse at how quickly a young core can become expensive to keep together.
For Cleveland, the larger issue is not just the rising cost of retaining top players, but the possibility that the roster could look different by then anyway. Slade Cecconi and David Fry are among the names projected in the mix, yet those estimates also underscore how much can change before the Guardians reach that point, and why the front office may soon have to balance roster continuity against the realities of a tighter payroll. [Read more 🡒]