Cade Smith didn’t take home the AL Reliever of the Year award, and for plenty of people around the Guardians, that still feels off.
Toronto’s Louis Varland got the honor instead, setting off the kind of offseason debate that always follows a close vote. On the Cleveland Baseball Talk Podcast this week, Paul Hoynes made it clear he wasn’t buying the result.
“I’m still scratching my head over that one. How he did not win the BBWA Reliever of the Year? I’m - I guess that’s why have elections, that’s why they have horse races,” Hoynes said.
But the discussion didn’t stay on the snub for long. It shifted to the bigger question: what matters more, the award or the run Cleveland made in October?
Joe Noga’s answer was blunt.
“Every one of these guys who we talked about who won an award over Cade Smith or Parker Messick would trade that award in, in a heartbeat to be able to be playing in the ALCS like Smith and Messick were during the year,” Noga said.
That’s the heart of the argument. Smith was one of the most dependable arms in the American League all season, piling up a dominant, steady, professional year and even drawing Cy Young votes - a rare thing for a reliever. Still, the trophy went elsewhere.
Hoynes pointed to the late-1990s Yankees as the perfect comparison. Those teams, he noted, could go through a whole season without much individual recognition and still end up with the biggest prize.
“And they won three straight World Series titles, so the awards are nice, but it’s having a team that plays together and can win and can win consistently and can win in the postseason that really matters,” Hoynes said.
That idea fits the way the Guardians operate. The organization has long leaned into depth, development, and group production, with individual honors often becoming a side effect rather than the main objective.
Smith still has one more award on the table. The Tip O’Neill Award, given by the Canadian Baseball Hall of Fame to the top Canadian-born player in the majors, remains in play, with voting closing November 20th and results due in early December.
Noga made the case that Smith’s profile should make him a strong favorite.
“If that’s a consideration, Cade Smith should win this award running away. We’ve been around him a lot and seen the way that he interacts with his teammates and just his commitment and dedication,” Noga said.
Hoynes backed that up just as quickly.
“Three straight years now, this guy is consistent. He never changes. He’s the same in the clubhouse and as on the mound,” he said.
There are still bigger individual conversations ahead, too, with José Ramírez in the MVP mix and Gavin Williams in the Cy Young discussion. Those debates will keep rolling through the offseason and into spring.
But the bigger story coming out of Cleveland’s award season isn’t what the Guardians missed. It’s what they already proved in October: they built a roster good enough to play deep into the postseason.
In Other News...
David Frys Guardians Exit Feels Worse Than Fans Expected
David Frys run with Cleveland ended in a way few around the club probably saw coming. After a breakthrough 2024 season that included an All-Star nod and one of the most memorable swings in recent postseason memory, the Guardians non-tendered him ahead of the arbitration deadline, sending him into free agency and closing the door on a player who had quickly become part of the teams recent identity.
The move makes sense only in the coldest roster-building terms, because Frys value had already been complicated by the arm injury that led to UCL surgery and changed the shape of his season. He returned in 2026 but never got back on track offensively, even with an arbitration projection of $1.9 million, leaving Cleveland to make a difficult call on a player whose peak felt like it arrived fast and faded even faster. [Read more 🡒]
Cade Smith May Be Headed For An Honor Cleveland Fans Didn't Expect
Cade Smith came up just short in the first year of a new leaguewide honor, finishing behind Louis Varland for the inaugural AL Reliever of the Year award. Even so, the Guardians closer put together a season that kept him in the conversation all the way through the vote, working to a 1.95 ERA with 107 strikeouts in 74 innings while also handling the postseason stage with the kind of poise Cleveland has come to expect from him.
Now Smith may be in line for a different kind of recognition, one that would resonate well beyond the bullpen. He is considered a leading candidate for the Tip ONeill award, which goes to the top Canadian-born MLB player, and his combination of production and character has put him squarely in the mix for an honor Cleveland fans probably did not have on their radar at the start of the year. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Suddenly Have A David Fry Question Kody Huff Could Answer
The Guardians have quietly added another layer to their roster puzzle by bringing in catcher and utility prospect Kody Huff from the Rockies in the Cal Quantrill deal and placing him on the 40-man roster. It is the kind of move that can get lost in the shuffle of a pitching trade, but it matters because Cleveland has been searching for dependable depth behind the plate and around the infield, especially from a player who can move between jobs without forcing a roster reshuffle.
David Frys path has become part of that conversation after his struggles in recent seasons following Tommy John surgery, and his hold on the utility catcher role no longer looks as secure as it once did. Huffs versatility and his work in Triple-A Columbus give the Guardians a possible next option if they decide to move in a different direction, leaving a familiar question hanging over the roster as spring approaches. [Read more 🡒]
