The Minnesota Vikings have settled on Kyler Murray as their starter, and that decision has J.J. McCarthy back in the conversation for all the wrong reasons. The third-year Michigan product is now the clear No. 2, and with his path in Minnesota looking murkier, speculation around a possible trade is starting to build.
McCarthy’s case is a tough one to ignore. His first season never really got off the ground because of injury, and last year he played in 10 games while throwing for 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. That kind of uneven production has fueled the questions about whether his future is still in Minnesota at all.
In a FanSided feature, Mark Powell pointed to several possible landing spots and made clear that McCarthy may need a fresh start. “There are plenty of Vikings who should benefit from more stable QB play, but McCarthy is not one of them,” he says in the piece.
One of the teams he floated was the Cleveland Browns, a club that already has its own quarterback battle brewing between veteran Deshaun Watson and second-year player Shedeur Sanders. Powell’s proposed deal would send McCarthy and a 2027 seventh-round pick to Cleveland, while Minnesota would receive quarterback Dillon Gabriel and a 2027 fifth-round pick.
“A Browns trade for McCarthy is complicated by the number of young quarterbacks already on the roster,” he states in the piece. “Deshaun Watson seems likely to start Week 1 for Cleveland, although Todd Monken has yet to make that official.”
He also noted another wrinkle: “Shedeur Sanders could be up for grabs if the Vikings wish to make this trade more interesting, but they already have Carson Wentz as a reliable backup should they deal McCarthy elsewhere.”
It’s an intriguing idea on paper, but Cleveland may be too locked in on its own quarterback situation to take on another one right now.
In Other News...
Guardians Bullpen Doubts Keep Growing As One Former Arm Thrives Elsewhere
The Guardians have spent much of the season trying to sort out the back end of the bullpen, and the comparison between Matt Festa and Justin Bruihl only adds to the uncertainty. Festa has been a steady enough presence in 51 appearances, but the numbers have not been strong enough to quiet questions about how much trust Cleveland can really place in that group as the year wears on.
Bruihls path makes the situation look even a little more frustrating from the Cleveland side. The left-hander was only briefly part of the roster before moving on to St. Louis, where he has settled in and found a clearer role in the Cardinals bullpen. In a similar job to Festas, he has simply gotten more out of his opportunities, and he is now being leaned on in more important moments. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Playoff Push Is Being Dragged Down By One Infield Problem
Brayan Rocchios recent slump has become part of the larger concern around Clevelands infield at the exact moment the Guardians needed stability most. Since late July, Rocchio has been in a deep offensive funk, and Jos Ramrez has not provided the usual lift either after coming back from injury, leaving the middle of the lineup short on production during a crucial stretch.
The timing has made the issue feel even bigger because Cleveland has slipped out of the postseason picture while those bats have cooled. The Guardians are still trying to keep their season alive, but the infield answer they were counting on has not arrived yet, and the lack of offense there has turned into one of the biggest reasons the push has lost momentum. [Read more 🡒]
Guardians Offensive Skid Comes Down To One Frustrating Problem
The Guardians have spent enough time putting men on base to know the problem is not always about traffic, but what happens once that traffic reaches the key spots. In the biggest scoring chances, Cleveland has been stuck near the bottom of the league at turning runners on third with fewer than two outs and runners on second with no outs into runs, a frustrating drag on an offense that has often found baserunners but not the payoff.
Stephen Vogt and Chase DeLauter have both pointed to the mental side of those situations, which fits the way the numbers have looked. For a club trying to squeeze more out of a lineup that has already created chances, the next step is less about finding baserunners and more about sharpening the approach when the game is asking for one clean swing, one productive out or one simple run-scoring play. [Read more 🡒]