Ben Livelys Return Could Give Cleveland A Tough Rotation Decision

With Ben Lively's imminent return, the Cleveland Guardians' already formidable pitching roster may gain a crucial advantage as they edge closer to the postseason.

The Guardians’ rotation has been carrying the load all season, and now another familiar arm is inching back into the mix.

Cleveland’s pitching staff has been the club’s backbone, even with the offense running hot and cold. Gavin Williams and Parker Messick have emerged as ace-level pieces, while Joey Cantillo, Foster Griffin and Tanner Bibee have helped give the Guardians one of the league’s deepest and stingiest rotations. Only seven pitchers have made starts for Cleveland this year: those five, Slade Cecconi before the Griffin trade, and Logan Allen’s one outing.

That group is about to get a little bigger.

Ben Lively turned in 4.2 scoreless innings for Triple-A Columbus on Friday, according to Guardians Prospective on X. He struck out four St. Paul batters, allowed three hits and one walk, and reached 94.4 miles per hour while throwing 65 pitches, 43 for strikes.

Cleveland #Guardians RHP Ben Lively struckout four St. Paul batters tonight over 4.2 scoreless innings of work for Columbus topping out at 94.4 mph.

Line - 4.2(IP) 3H 0R 0ER 1BB 4SO

(65 Pitches 43 Strikes)

First two Triple-A starts:

  • 8.2(IP) 5H 0ER 1BB 7SO 0.00 ERA… pic.twitter.com/gak7GiFs27
  • Guardians Prospective (@CleGuardPro) August 22, 2026

Across his first two Triple-A starts, Lively has thrown 8.2 scoreless innings, and he may need one more rehab outing simply to build his pitch count a bit further. Even so, the finish line is coming into view.

The Guardians haven’t had to lean on starting pitching as a major fix, but Lively’s return still gives them another useful option. Where he lands is not clear with the current rotation throwing so well, yet if he keeps dealing like this, Stephen Vogt will have a way to work him in.

Lively has not appeared in a game since May of last year, so Cleveland is expected to bring him along carefully. Still, the 34-year-old has rebuilt his career since arriving with the club, posting a 3.68 ERA over 38 starts in 2024 and 2025.

There’s also a practical reason to welcome him back. Messick and Cantillo are both young and have piled up innings this season, and another veteran arm could help lighten that workload before the postseason. Lively can serve as a spot starter or a long reliever, and his next steps will be worth watching.

In Other News...

Gabriel Arias Just Forced A Former Guardian Back Out Of Chicago

The Cubs infield shuffle kept turning over before Owen Miller could really settle in. Chicago brought him up after Dansby Swanson went down with an injury, looking for quick depth in the middle infield, but his stay on the roster was about as brief as it gets. For a player who has already worn uniforms for Cleveland, Milwaukee and Colorado, it was another short stop in a career that has bounced around the league.

Chicago then claimed Gabriel Arias off waivers, and the move pushed Miller back out of the picture almost immediately. Arias is expected to fill a utility role behind Nico Hoerner and Pedro Ramrez, giving the Cubs another versatile infield option while closing the door on Millers latest chance to stick in Chicago. [Read more 🡒]

Angel Genao Is Forcing A Guardians Infield Dilemma

Angel Genaos first taste of the big leagues has been enough to make the Guardians pay attention. Since making his MLB debut on Aug. 5, he has handled a utility infield role with the kind of steady play that can change a managers thinking, pairing a .320/.382/.440 slash line with encouraging defensive work through his first 50 at-bats.

Stephen Vogt has already acknowledged the ripple effect, noting that Genaos performance is turning the infield into a real competition for playing time. For Cleveland, that is the good kind of problem to have, but it can also lead to difficult roster decisions as the club tries to balance production, versatility and opportunity across the group. [Read more 🡒]

Stephen Vogt Just Sent A Clear Message With Clevelands Lineup

Stephen Vogt did something rare for Cleveland this week by rolling out the same lineup in back-to-back games, a small choice that still carried plenty of meaning in a season where the manager has mixed and matched often. It suggested a group that was starting to settle in, and it came with rookie Angel Genao holding down shortstop for a second straight start while Erik Sabrowski continued to trend up after his return from the injured list.

The lineup stability also fit the broader tone around the club, where Vogt had checked in with key players about how they were feeling before locking things in. Jos Ramrez was part of that conversation, and he kept adding to his place in franchise history with another hit, nudging himself further up Cleveland's all-time list while the Guardians tried to find a rhythm that has been elusive for much of the season. [Read more 🡒]