James Harden Faces A Cavaliers Debate That Could Sting Fans

As veteran NBA players adapt to different roles for their teams' success, James Harden faces a pivotal moment in reevaluating his approach with the Cavaliers.

James Harden’s current situation in Cleveland looks a lot different from the one CJ McCollum just embraced in Atlanta, and that contrast is hard to ignore.

McCollum, who has spent much of his 14-year NBA career as a starter, was recently moved out of the Hawks’ opening five in favor of rookie guard Kingston Flemings. Instead of pushing back, he explained exactly why he was fine with it when speaking on Amazon’s NightCap.

“He's learning and growing. And I think it gives him a chance to develop.

For us as a franchise and for us as an organization, I'm 35 and he's 19, so I see the vision of where they're going. I think for us to be successful, he has to develop.

He has to get better. We got to be able to have a deep team who's able to contribute off the bench.”

McCollum also said, “As a starting unit I think we were a little sluggish. I think we were lackluster. From a ball movement…”

That decision carries extra weight because McCollum had already settled in well after being acquired by the Hawks at last year’s trade deadline. His clutch play helped them beat the eventual-champion Knicks twice in the opening round, and now he’s willing to take a different role as the team leans into Flemings’ development.

Harden, by comparison, has not been thriving for the Cavs. His percentages and numbers are the lowest they’ve ever been as a starter, even while he continues to play a full load of minutes every night. The short version is that he has not been lifting the players around him the way Cleveland needs, and the on/off numbers for teammates have swung sharply depending on whether they’re on the floor with him or not.

His strong showing against the Knicks was encouraging, but it was still only one game out of 14.

There’s also the contract angle. Harden signed a three-year, $97 million extension, and while he could have made $40 million this season, he re-negotiated into a longer deal with a lower yearly number to help the team’s finances. That still doesn’t lock him into the starting lineup.

A reserve role could actually make sense. Harden still has plenty left, but the way Cleveland has used him suggests he could be more effective playing 27-30 minutes a night instead of the 34 he’s getting now. Donovan Mitchell has not fit especially well next to him, and he deserves a longer look running the offense on his own, which is when he has had his best games.

McCollum’s move stands out because it’s the kind of selfless choice veterans rarely make without a fight. Giving up a starting job so a younger player can grow faster is about as team-first as it gets. The question is whether Harden would ever do something similar for Meleek Thomas.

For now, that remains a question for Cleveland to answer over time. But McCollum’s decision in Atlanta is already making people think.

In Other News...

Meleek Thomas Is Forcing A Cavs Decision They Can't Ignore

Meleek Thomas is already making himself part of the Cavaliers conversation, and that matters for a team trying to sort out its future as much as its present. The rookie out of Arkansas has flashed enough early promise to stand out in a crowded rotation, including a recent outing in which he reached 20 points and kept showing the kind of energy that can earn a young player more than a passing look.

Even more notable is the way Thomas is being viewed around the league and inside the organization, with Kyrie Irving weighing in on the rookies effort and upside. For Cleveland, the question is no longer whether Thomas belongs on the radar. It is how far his game can go, and what kind of roster decisions his rise might eventually force the Cavaliers to consider. [Read more 🡒]

Cavaliers Suddenly Face A Peyton Watson Concern They Cant Ignore

Peyton Watsons night turned into a concern for Cleveland in a hurry during the Bulls game, when the versatile defender went down after a mid-air collision with Jalen Smith. Watson had already shaken off one hard fall earlier in the game and stayed on the floor, but this latest sequence left him on the court long enough to prompt an evaluation and raise an immediate question for a Cavaliers team that leans on his length and energy at the defensive end.

Before the injury, Watson had given Cleveland a useful stretch, scoring 14 points in 22 minutes while handling his usual role as a disruptive presence. For a Cavaliers defense that values his ability to cover ground and make life difficult on the perimeter, any interruption to his availability matters, and the next update on his condition will be watched closely. [Read more 🡒]

Cavs Suddenly Face A Lineup Problem Before Bulls Matchup

The Cavaliers are entering their matchup with Chicago already dealing with a familiar frontcourt wrinkle, as Evan Mobley is expected to sit again because of a toe sprain. Cleveland has had to adjust without one of its most important defensive anchors, and the timing is less than ideal with the Bulls bringing their own availability questions into the game. Nic Claxton is set to be available after returning from a hamstring injury, while Jalen Smith is listed as questionable with a finger issue.

For Cleveland, the bigger concern is how long it can keep patching together the lineup while Mobley remains out. His absence changes the way the Cavaliers defend the paint, rebound and organize their half-court coverage, and it puts more pressure on the rest of the rotation to hold up against a Bulls team that is also sorting through its own injury report. Even before tipoff, this one already has the feel of a game where the final answer may depend as much on who is active as on who is playing well. [Read more 🡒]