Cleveland Cavaliers guard James Harden just can't seem to catch a break. On the same day he was diagnosed with a fractured thumb, Harden found himself drawn into a conversation comparing his defense to that of Luka Doncic.
In a recent episode of The Zach Lowe Show, The Ringer's Michael Pina critiqued Doncic's defensive efforts, likening them to the Houston Rockets era of Harden. Pina noted that Harden was often the subject of memes for his defensive lapses back then. Lowe added that Harden still occasionally shows similar tendencies.
However, let's not forget why the Cavaliers brought Harden on board. They weren't seeking a defensive stalwart, and his presence hasn't hindered Cleveland's impressive 6-1 record with him in the lineup. Offensively, Harden has been a game-changer, boosting the production of teammates like Jarrett Allen and enhancing the team's overall efficiency.
Comparing Harden's defense to Doncic's isn't entirely fair. Doncic, despite his offensive brilliance, has other issues, such as frequent complaints to officials, which can undermine his defensive focus. Harden, on the other hand, provides a physical presence at 6-foot-5, improving the Cavs' defense compared to the smaller Darius Garland.
While neither Harden nor Doncic are known for their defensive prowess, Harden's size gives him an edge in matchups, especially in playoff scenarios. This is a concern for the Los Angeles Lakers as well, where both Doncic and Austin Reaves face similar defensive challenges.
Ultimately, the comparisons between Harden and Doncic are inevitable due to their unique offensive styles. However, it's crucial to recognize that their defensive shortcomings are not identical. Harden may have moments of defensive inattention, but he can still lock in when needed, distinguishing him from Doncic's defensive struggles.